Media: Representations Flashcards

1
Q

Media gaze

A

-Media reflects the perspective of the dominant groups – mostly white, able-bodied, upper/middle-class men.
-This leads to lack of representation of wider social diversity in media content.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Symbolic annihilation (Tuchman)

A

-Describes how some social groups are ignored, trivialised or stereotyped in the media.
-Affects groups based on: Ethnicity, Gender, Sexual orientation, Age, Disability, Social class.
-Under-representation and limited roles distort public perception or erase visibility of these groups in society.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Diversity of interpretation (Gauntlett)

A

-People do not all react the same way to media.
-Media audiences are diverse and often resist or reinterpret representations.
Meaning varies depending on personal experience:
-> A minority ethnic viewer may interpret a portrayal differently than a white viewer.
-> Disabled viewers may resist or reject stereotypical portrayals.
-In the postmodern era, people may ‘pick ’n’ mix’ representations to create their own identity.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Hyperreality - Baudrillard

A

-In a media-saturated society, people may struggle to distinguish media from reality.
-Media representations can become hyperreal - more real than actual reality.
-Media doesn’t just reflect reality – it creates it.
-Especially influential for people with no personal experience to challenge what they see in the media.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Media representations & dominant ideology (GMG)

A

-Media content is shaped by the dominant ideology in society.
-Stereotypes and representations often:
-> Reflect the values of the ruling class
-> Reinforce cultural hegemony (Gramsci)
-> Justify existing social inequalities in power, wealth, and status.
-Media helps maintain consent for the dominant social order.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Representations of Gender: Under-representations of women in the media

A

-The international women’s media foundation (2010) found that in
UK news women faced a glass ceiling that was fixed at the junior professional level. 60% of senior professional roles were filled by men.
-Women in Journalism (2011) - 74% of news journalists on national newspapers were men & there are twice as many male news editors than women. In 2012 78% of all front page articles were written by male journalists.
-Guardian (2011) 77% of news reports are written by male journalists.
-Zomen (1994) argues that to succeed in the media, women have to adapt to the patriarchal ideology that dominates media companies.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Representations of Gender: The male gaze

A

-GMG, Marxists feminists and Radical feminists argue that gender representations of gender are filtered through the media gaze of the / pre-dominantly male-dominated media establishment, which means that women are portrayed through what Mulvey calls the male gaze.
-Men gaze at women as sexual objects, with images of women focusing on their physical appearance and sexuality. This is all done for men’s pleasure.
-Levenson inquiry (2012) found that the tabloid press failed to show consistent respect for the dignity and equality of women as there was a tendency to sexualise and demean women.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Representations of Gender: Under-representation & stereotypes in media content

A

-Global media monitoring projects (2010) - nearly half of all news stories reinforced gender stereotypes. The news remains predominately male with male presenters being seen as experts and women as ‘ordinary’,
-Cumberbatch et al. (2014) - content analysis of popular TV shows - women appear less often on TV in comparison to men. Women appear as supporting roles, this is particularly the case for older women who are under-represented in comparison to older men who are over-represented.
-Martinson (2014) - over 50’s appear on BBC TV 82% are men.
-Across all major TV channels over 50’s women make up just 5%.
-Almy et al (1994) argues that media representations are important because these stereotypes provide role models that we are encouraged to aspire to.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Representations of Gender: Patriarchal ideology & symbolic annihilation of women

A

-Women are either invisible, under-represented or represented in a limited range of stereotypical roles. -Tuchman - Symbolic annihilation: women’s achievements are often not reported, or are condemned or trivialised by the mass media. Or their achievements are presented as less important than their looks and sex appeal. She found:
1. Women were overwhelmingly represented in two roles, domestic (housewife and mother) and sexual (including romantic).
2. Men were portrayed as authority figures, workers, breadwinners and sportsmen.
3. Men outnumbered women on TV by 3 to 1. Women suffered
‘symbolic annihilation’ by the media ‘through absence, condemnation or trivialisation’.
4. Game shows, quizzes and discussion programmes were invariably presented by men (authority figures).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Media & Gender - Hegemony (Connell)

A

Media helps construct gender through hegemonic stereotypes.
-Hegemonic masculinity: strength, dominance, aggression, emotional restraint.
-Hegemonic femininity: beauty, nurturing, passivity, emotional sensitivity.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

The beauty myth (Wolf)

A

-Women judged primarily by appearance, shaped by male ideals.
-Media promotes unrealistic beauty standards (e.g. size zero, airbrushed models).
-Tebbell (2000): Modern women are more obsessed with body image than ever before.
-Media has made real female bodies invisible.
-Industries (cosmetics, fashion, cosmetic surgery) profit from insecurity.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Gendered media content

A

Magazines reflect traditional gender roles:
-> “Men’s interests” vs. “Women’s interests”
-> Romantic fiction = female-focused; action/sports = male-focused
-Girlguiding UK (2012): Girls rely heavily on celebrity/reality TV role models.
-Reinforces narrow versions of femininity.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Video games - Children Now (2001)

A

-Only 16% of characters were female.
-Female characters: sexualised, often scantily clad.
-Male characters: aggressive, dominant.
-Games like Grand Theft Auto glorify violence against women.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Hegemonic male characteristics

A

-Heterosexual
-Sexually dominant
-Independent
-Repressed emeotionally
-Strong/muscular/tall

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Hegemonic female characteristics

A

-Sexual passivity
-Heterosexuality
-Expression of emotions
-Dependance
-Physically weak/fragile/small
-Gentle & non-aggressive
-Concerned with physical appearance

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Female representations: Limited roles

A

-Feminists such as Wolf often argue that women are represented in a narrow range of social roles or are excluded from representation altogether.
-Feminists suggest that the media strongly encourage women to conform to ideological patriarchal ideals that confirm they’re subordinate to men.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

Stereotypes of women in media

A
  1. The WAG / Femme Fatale – Obsessed with beauty, love, and keeping their man.
  2. The Sex Object – Slim, seductive, scantily clad; often used in tabloids, ads, and porn.
  3. The Supermum – Home-maker; juggles childcare, housework, and emotional labour.
  4. The Angel – Good, domestic, low sexuality; supports the man.
  5. The Ball Breaker – Career-driven, independent, sexually active; not reliant on men.
  6. The Victim – Seen in horror/crime media; harmed by men, sometimes rescued by them.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

The ‘cult of femininity’ - Ferguson

A

-Teen girls’ magazines teach traditional feminine roles.
-Promote:
-> Getting/keeping a partner
-> Being a good wife/mother
-> Focus on appearance, cooking, fashion, emotions.
-Continues into adult women’s magazines.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

What are the impacts of this?

A

-Gross & Jefferies-Fox: Boys who watched large amounts of TV were more likely to believe that women were happiest in domestic roles (making a home or caring for children).
-French & McGhee: Found a positive correlation between heavy TV viewing and gender stereotyping in kindergarten children in the US.
-Beuf (1980s): Interviewed 63 boys and girls aged 3-6 and found that many girls at a young age had ruled out certain careers, believing they were for boys.
-Role of Female Role Models: The small number of high-status female role models may limit female aspirations.
-Media vs. Family Influence:!Unclear whether the media or the family is more responsible for reinforcing these gender attitudes.
-Hermes (1995): Argues that the effect of media on women is not passive. Instead, she believes magazines are read in different ways, suggesting an active role for the audience in interpreting the media.
-Complex Relationship: The media’s portrayal of gender involves a complex relationship between the messages, the audience, and the effects, indicating that the impact is not straightforward.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

Masculinity in the media

A

-Men are often shown in higher-status occupations, such as bosses or managers, compared to women in subordinate roles like secretaries or PAs.
-Male voices are more frequently used in voice-overs on TV and in advertising, reinforcing the image of men as authority figures or experts.
-Older men are often shown as sexual partners for younger women, a depiction that is rarely reversed in media.
-The stereotyped image of the tough, assertive, dominant, and rational male is common (Gilmore, 1991). He is often seen as the provider, protector, and impregnator.
-Men’s magazines tend to focus on stereotypical masculine interests, such as sport, photography, technology, DIY, and various forms of transport (cars, motorbikes, boats).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

Stereotypes of men in the media

A
  1. The Joker - Uses humor to avoid showing emotion.
  2. The Jock - Avoids softness, shows aggression to demonstrate strength and win approval.
  3. The Strong Silent Type - In control, avoids emotions, successful with women.
  4. The Big Shot - Economically and socially successful, high status with matching possessions.
  5. The Action Hero - Strong, aggressive, often violent.
  6. The Buffoon - Well-intentioned but inept, especially in domestic or parenting roles.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

Masculinity in media representations

A

-Kibly (1980s): Shows like The A-Team and Magnum linked masculinity to power, authority, aggression, and technology.
-Butler & Paisley: Found men were stereotyped similarly to women (as workers, authority figures, etc.).
-Easthorpe Media (films, games) portray masculinity as biologically determined, based on strength, aggression, and violence, creating an ideal many men internalize but can’t fully achieve.
-Crechen’s Surveys: Majority view women’s sports as inferior to men’s, with 80-90% of media coverage focused on men’s sports, emphasizing aggression and strength.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

Theoretical explanations for gender stereotyping: Pluralists

A

-Stereotyping occurs because it satisfies the desires of both media audiences and organisations.
-Media organisations, driven by the need to attract audiences and make money, use stereotypes as a simple and effective way to appeal to viewers.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

Theoretical explanations for gender stereotyping: Liberal feminists

A

-Media representations reflect the under-representation of women in positions of power (e.g. chief executives, editors).
-The dominance of men in media organisations shapes a male-centered view of the world.
-As women gain more power and equal opportunities in media, they will break through the “glass ceiling,” leading to changes in media representations.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Theoretical explanations for gender stereotyping: Marxist/marxist feminists
-Media stereotypes are driven by the need for profit, with media owners and advertisers targeting audiences to sell products. -Advertisers require stereotypes (primarily of women) to promote items like cosmetics, fashion, and diet products. -E.g. Tebbel, editor of New Woman magazine, featured a size-16 model on the cover, which was well received by readers. However, a major advertiser withdrew support, claiming the imagery was harmful to sales, forcing her to remove the model and resign. -Patriarchal media imagery is linked to social class inequality, with media promoting a lifestyle that working-class women cannot afford, reinforcing male-dominated middle-class values.
26
Theoretical explanations for gender stereotyping: Radical feminists
-Media stereotypes are used to reproduce and maintain patriarchy and patriarchal ideology. -The media world, like society, is male-dominated and aims to keep women in narrow, stereotyped roles, reinforcing their subordination. -Stereotypes of femininity and the beauty myth encourage women to look good for the male gaze, undermining women’s opportunities and reinforcing male dominance in society.
27
Changing media stereotypes of gender
-**McRobbie (1994):** In PM society, gender representations in the media are more fluid and flexible, reflecting broader societal changes. -**Gauntlett (2008):** There’s a growing social expectation of gender equality, reflected in changing media portrayals of men and women.
28
Changing representations of women
-**Wilkinson (Genderquake):** Women's aspirations have changed significantly, referred to as a "genderquake," influencing media portrayals. -**McRobbie (1994):** A new feminism in magazines promotes assertiveness, control, and sexual freedom, integrating "girl power" into culture. -**Brundsman et al:** TV now features stronger, more empowered women. -**Abercrombie (1999):** Soap operas now center on strong female characters. -**Winship (1987):** Women’s magazines emphasize independence, confidence, and address issues like domestic violence. -**Policy Studies Institute (1999):** Magazines depict women as consumerist, sexually assertive, and pleasure-loving. -**Knight (2010):** New representations still conform to femininity and beauty standards, reinforcing patriarchal ideals despite showing women in non-traditional roles.
29
Changing representations of men
-**Gauntlett (2008):** Changing media portrayals give men more options to construct identities beyond traditional masculinity. -**The New Man:** A modern man who embraces caring, shares child care, and participates in housework. -**Metrosexual Male:** A man who takes pride in grooming and appearance. -**Retributive Masculinity:** A reactionary form of masculinity that reasserts traditional male concerns like football. -**Male Body as Sex Object:** The sexualisation of men in media, similar to the portrayal of women.
30
Explaining changing representations
-**Advertisers' Influence:** Advertisers target men with products like cosmetics, while women’s growing success and power lead to a need for more relevant media representations to keep female audiences. -**Women’s Media Power:** Women are gaining influence in media production; if mainstream media doesn’t evolve, women may turn to platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and blogs to challenge stereotypes. -**Ongoing Stereotypes:** Despite changes, gender stereotypes remain strong, especially in tabloids, advertising, video games, and music videos. -**New Media Technology:** While new media offers chances to challenge stereotypes, it has also led to the increased sexualization of women, especially in the growth of pornography online.
31
General features of representations of ethnicity
-Stereotypical portrayals of ethnic minorities limit societal understanding and reinforce negative views & lead to self-fulfilling prophecy. -Marginalisation and tokenism exclude ethnic minorities from significant roles, promoting one-dimensional representations. -The lack of authentic, diverse portrayals leads to cultural erasure and alienates minority audiences. -Media shapes public opinion, so negative depictions can fuel discrimination and affect policy, hindering equality. -Ethnic minorities underrepresented in senior management positions.
32
How would this impact media representation of ethnicity or wider societal views?
-Stereotypical portrayals of ethnic minorities limit societal understanding and reinforce negative views & lead to self-fulfilling prophecy. -Marginalisation and tokenism exclude ethnic minorities from significant roles, promoting one-dimensional representations. -The lack of authentic, diverse portrayals leads to cultural erasure and alienates minority audiences. -Media shapes public opinion, so negative depictions can fuel discrimination and affect policy, hindering equality. -Ethnic minorities underrepresented in senior management positions.
33
Media stereotypes of ethnicity: Deviants & law-breakers
-Minority ethnic groups, particularly black and Asian people, are frequently portrayed as criminals in the media. -Common associations include drug-dealing, terrorism, welfare fraud, street robbery (mugging), and gang culture. -Studies (e.g., Hargrave, 2002) reveal that black people are more than twice as likely as white people to be shown as criminals on television. -Black boys and young men are often depicted as dangerous, with their lives revolving around crime, such as drugs, guns, and gangs. -Media often highlight black people committing crimes, while black victims of crime, such as racially motivated attacks, are underreported. -The moral panic around the 'black mugger' in the 1970s was used to distract from economic and political crises and reinforced racial stereotypes. -Contemporary portrayals of black youth continue to link them with negative symbols like gangsta rap, further cementing the 'folk devil' image.
34
Media stereotypes of ethnicity: As posing a threat
-Ethnic minorities, particularly Muslims, are often portrayed as a threat to British culture and values, reinforcing the 'enemy within' stereotype. -Immigration is frequently framed as a threat to the British way of life, with ethnic minorities portrayed as a threat to jobs and social stability. -Rare events like forced marriages and honour killings are sensationalised, giving the false impression that all minority groups practice these traditions. -Muslims, in particular, are regularly depicted as a cultural threat to British values, framing them as inherently at odds with Western societal norms.
35
Media stereotypes of ethnicity: As causing social problem, conflict & trouble
-Media representations often frame ethnic minorities as the cause of social problems like racial tensions, riots, school underachievement, and welfare dependency. -These portrayals focus on individual shortcomings rather than addressing broader issues like poverty, racial discrimination, and systemic inequality. -Asylum seekers are commonly depicted as 'bogus' migrants, rather than people fleeing persecution, leading to further stigmatization. -Media-generated moral panics, such as the stories about asylum seekers eating swans or donkeys, serve to reinforce prejudice against these groups. -Such sensationalised stories distort public perception, leading to unfair stereotypes and discrimination against vulnerable communities.
36
Media stereotypes of ethnicity: As having limited talents & skills
-Minority ethnic groups are often portrayed as having a limited range of skills or talents, typically shown in low-paid, unskilled jobs such as cleaning. -They are rarely depicted as successful professionals, academics, or high achievers. -Stereotypes frequently highlight success in sports or music, but exclude portrayals of academic or intellectual achievement, reinforcing the notion that minorities are less capable in other areas.
37
Media stereotypes of ethnicity: As having problems internationally
-Developing countries, particularly in Africa, are often depicted as chaotic, struggling with issues like poverty, AIDS, famine, and war. -These portrayals are oversimplified and fail to provide context, focusing instead on disasters and crises that reinforce negative perceptions. -Media coverage of developing countries often neglects the complexity of global issues and the role of Western involvement in maintaining or exacerbating these problems. -Eastern European immigrants have been similarly stereotyped in recent years, blamed for a wide range of societal problems, such as taking jobs, committing crimes, and causing economic issues. -These exaggerated and absurd media stories reinforce negative stereotypes and contribute to prejudice against both minority ethnic groups and immigrants, perpetuating racial and cultural discrimination.
38
Stereotypes applied to white people from Eastern Europe
-Immigrants from Eastern Europe (e.g. Ukrainians, Poles, Romanians) have been blamed for a wide range of problems in Britain, often unfairly. -Media stories falsely accuse these groups of being: -> Benefit scroungers, lone parents, and job stealers. -> Responsible for issues like shortage of £50 notes, road signs in foreign languages, and various criminal behaviors (e.g., drunken driving, groping women). -> Associated with negative cultural impacts such as bad service in restaurants and overcrowded churches. -These exaggerated or fabricated reports contribute to racial prejudice by blaming immigrants for societal issues they are not responsible for.
39
The rise of Islamophobia
-Media coverage of terrorist attacks (e.g. 9/11 and 2005 London bombings) has fueled Islamophobia, associating Muslims with terrorism. -In 2014-15, the involvement of some British youths in ISIS activities contributed to the stereotyping of all Muslims as a threat to societal values and safety, leading to an increase in hate crimes. -A 2007 report showed that 91% of news articles about Muslims were negative, reinforcing the idea that Muslims are a threat. -Muslims have been portrayed as fundamentalists, with negative stereotypes about oppression of women, forced hijab-wearing, and attempts to impose Sharia law on British society.
40
The rise of Islamophobia & stigmatised identity
-Media representations of Muslims in the 2000s led to a moral panic, with the term "Muslim" becoming a stigmatised identity, excluding Muslims from full societal acceptance. -Warsi coined the term **"fashionable Islamophobia,"** highlighting how anti-Muslim prejudice has become normalized and socially acceptable, even in middle-class settings. -Hargrave's findings show that negative media portrayals of Muslims contribute to discrimination and amplify the moral panic, exacerbating prejudice against the group.
41
Research support for the stigmatisation of Islam
-**Poole (2000):** Argues that Muslims have been demonised by Western media even before 9/11. A content analysis of broadsheet newspapers (1993-1996) showed that British Muslims were often portrayed as a threat to UK values. -**Ameli et al:**!Found that media discussions about the hijab and veil were often negative, presenting them as inferior to Western dress. -**BBC2 (2002):** Research suggested ethnic minority groups felt that the media often inaccurately treated arranged marriages and failed to distinguish between "arranged" and "forced" marriages. -**Richardson (2001):** Highlighted that British Muslims are largely absent from the news, and when they do appear, it's usually in a negative light. British Muslims are also rarely featured as news commentators.
42
Pluralist explanation for stereotyping of ethnicity
-Media reflects the views, interests, and demands of audiences. -Stereotypes of ethnic minorities are based on news values and consumer interests, not intentional bias. **Cottle (2000):** -Media representations help audiences form identity by defining who "we" are in contrast to "them." -Cultural differences of ethnic minorities may be used to strengthen white majority identity.
43
Neo-Marxist/GMG explanation for stereotyping of ethnicity
-Media is controlled by a white-dominated establishment, producing content through a biased lens. -Negative portrayals reinforce racist stereotypes and uphold the dominance of white culture. -Ethnic minorities are scapegoated for problems they didn’t cause, fuelling racism and division among working-class people. -This distracts from real issues like structural inequality and economic deprivation across all groups. -Media moral panics (e.g., Hall et al.'s study on mugging or fears about Muslims) help reinforce ruling-class power and hegemony.
44
Changing ethnicity stereotypes
-Appreciation of black culture has grown, and there are more black and Asian figures appearing in music, arts and the media generally. -There are more media forms targeted at black and Asian audiences than in the past- the new media facilitates this, allowing narrowcasting to occur and also for ethnic minority groups themselves to have a platform to express their views and to counter negative ethnic stereotypes. -**Abercrombie** - Increasing representations of EM's within popular dramas and soaps. -There have been greater policy commitments in TV to recruit more people from EM as presenters, and Beattie et al showed this was most obvious in the areas of children's TV, education and the news.
45
General features of social class representations
1. **Class bias in media production:** -Media is shaped by upper-class owners and middle-class professionals so more positive portrayals of upper/middle classes and under-representation or negative portrayal of the working class. 2. **'We're all middle class now' narrative (Jones, 2011):** -Media promotes middle-class lifestyles as the norm. -Working class and the poor are often shown as deviant, abnormal or to be pitied. 3. **Class shown as lifestyle, not structure:** -Focus on ‘taste’ and consumer choices as markers of class (Lawler, 2005). -Ignores structural inequality in wealth, income, and life chances. 4. **Media prioritises stories about the rich:** -News tends to report crimes involving rich and famous more than similar working-class stories. -Poverty is rarely covered unless it’s an extreme or individualised case (McKendrick et al. 2008). 5. **Working class devalued across media genres:** -Sitcoms, soaps, dramas, and reality TV often show working-class people as less important or lower status (Weltman, 2008). -Marxists argue media hides class inequality and avoids discussing privilege or conflict, protecting elite interests.
46
Representations of Monarchy & upper class: Royalty & lavish lifestyles
-Media frequently focuses on the monarchy - royal weddings, jubilees, and gossip. -Royals are often portrayed as **’well bred’,cultured, superior, and respectable**, though sometimes a bit eccentric. -Period dramas like Downton Abbey romanticise the past and portray the upper class as decent, even idealising the lives of those who served them. -Tabloids and celebrity magazines (e.g., OK, Hello) focus heavily on wealth-luxury homes, holidays, fashion, and cars (Newman, 2006). -This promotes admiration and aspiration among the working and middle classes.
47
Neo-Marxist vs Pluralist view
-Pluralists argue this content is what audiences want. -Neo-Marxists argue it glamorises inequality, encourages class envy, and legitimises the current social hierarchy.
48
The monarchy & the media (Nairn)
-Royals usually avoid criticism and are portrayed as part of the national identity. -Positive coverage, like during the Golden/Diamond Jubilee, helps reinforce their status. -After Princess Diana’s death, criticism of the royals emerged—but selective.
49
Media double standards - Meghan Markle
-Meghan Markle was often negatively portrayed—likely due to both race and class dynamics. -In her Oprah interview, she revealed the monarchy had power to stop negative stories but didn’t. -An “invisible contract” exists between the monarchy and the media—positive coverage is protected in exchange for access, explaining silence around figures like Prince Andrew. -Media owners and editors, often from privileged backgrounds, have vested interests in maintaining the status quo.
50
Representations of the Middle classes
-The middle class (professionals, managers, white-collar workers) are often overrepresented in the media. -Typically shown in a positive light – mature, sensible, educated, successful, and capable. -Middle-class families are portrayed as stable and functional, with their lifestyles and consumer choices depicted as the social norm and something to aspire to. -These positive portrayals reflect the media gaze, which is largely controlled by middle-class professionals. -This promotes the dominant hegemonic ideology, reinforcing middle-class values while devaluing the working class.
51
Neo-Marxist view on M/C representation
-Since most media professionals are middle class, Neo-Marxists argue that media content reflects middle-class ideology and interests. -This leads to positive portrayals of the middle class and negative or limited representations of the working class, reinforcing class inequality. -Newspapers like the Daily Mail and Daily Telegraph target middle-class audiences, focusing on consumer goods (e.g., luxury cars, homes, tech) that reflect a comfortable lifestyle. -These papers also create moral panics (e.g., about asylum seekers or paedophiles), playing on middle-class fears about social decline and promoting British pride and traditional values. Neo-Marxists argue this maintains the dominance of middle-class norms and distracts from deeper issues of social inequality.
52
Representations of the working class & Curran and Seaton
-The working class is underrepresented in the media, and when they do appear, they are often portrayed through negative and harmful stereotypes, usually for not conforming to middle-class values. -**Curran & Seaton (2010):** Newspapers like the Sun, Mirror, and Daily Star aimed at working-class audiences focus on celebrity gossip, sport, sex, and entertainment, suggesting the working class isn't interested in serious political or social issues.
53
Representations of the working class: Dumb baffoons (Butsch)
-Found that US TV shows regularly depict the working class as buffoons – immature, irresponsible, inarticulate and lacking in common sense. -E.g.The Royle Family, where characters are couch potatoes having absurd conversations. -This portrayal reinforces the idea that the working class needs middle-class supervision, helping justify inequality and maintain ideological control.
54
Representations of the working class: Source of trouble & conflict
-Often shown as welfare scroungers, lone parents, or delinquent youth. -Neo-Marxists like the GMG argue this stereotype targets those who challenge the dominant ideology, reinforcing social divisions.
55
Representations of the working class: Living in romanticised W/C communities
-Seen as respectable and hardworking, with life revolving around pubs, families, and tight-knit communities. -Represented in shows like EastEnders or Call the Midwife. -**Jones (2011)** argues these portrayals are middle-class fantasies – nostalgic and unrealistic, especially as traditional working-class industries have declined.
56
Representations of the working class: White trash & scum
-Emerged in the late 1990s/early 2000s. -Terms like ‘chavs’ and ‘chavettes’ present the working class as undeserving, vulgar, and criminal. -Jones suggests this is now the dominant stereotype, showing a shift from romanticising the working class to despising them.
57
More representations of W/C
-The poorest groups are often shown through negative stereotypes – as ‘chavs’, bad parents, criminals, or welfare scroungers. -Media shows like Shameless and Jeremy Kyle turn poverty into entertainment (‘poverty porn’), exaggerating lifestyles for laughs or drama. -Structural causes of poverty (like inequality or lack of opportunity) are ignored – instead, poverty is blamed on individual failings (Shildrick et al.). -McKendrick et al. found poverty was rarely taken seriously in media. -Murray argues the media accurately shows the underclass (e.g. NEETs) as dependent and irresponsible. -Overall, the media often blames the poor for their situation and reinforces the idea that they are undeserving.
58
Are these representations changing? - ‘I Daniel Blake’
-I, Daniel Blake challenges stereotypes of the poor as lazy or morally weak, focusing on systemic issues like austerity and bureaucracy. -Shift away from shows like Shameless or Jeremy Kyle, which often presented poverty as a result of individual failure. -Media increasingly acknowledges the structural causes of poverty rather than attributing it solely to personal shortcomings.
59
Are these representations changing? - Power elite & Epstein
-Scandals involving Jeffrey Epstein and Prince Andrew expose the dark side of the powerful elite, highlighting sexual exploitation and corruption. -These revelations challenge the portrayal of the elite as respectable, infallible, and beyond reproach. -Media coverage of these scandals questions the accountability of powerful figures and undermines their idealized public image.
60
Representations of Heterosexuality
**Heteronormativity:** -In the UK, heterosexuality is considered the norm, shaping media portrayals of 'normal sexuality.' -Women are historically depicted through their sexual appeal to men (Mulvey's male gaze). **Shifting Attitudes:** -Social changes have led to more focus on men’s appearance and sexual appeal, particularly in men’s magazines. -McRobbie (1994) suggests men now face the same scrutiny as women in terms of beauty. **Metrosexual Stereotype:** -The metrosexual male is a new stereotype: a heterosexual man who embraces grooming and fashion traditionally associated with femininity. **Gendered Representation:** -Women are still more sexualised in the media than men, especially in pornography, which is more embedded in young men's culture due to new media.
61
Stereotypes of gay men
**Camp (Dyer):** Gay men are often portrayed as flamboyant, colorful, and fun (Dyer, 1986), but this can reinforce negative stereotypes about gay sexuality. -**Macho:** Some portrayals show gay men as masculine, challenging traditional masculinity. This can be seen as a threat to heterosexual males. -**Deviant:** Gay men are often depicted as "different," with their homosexuality seen as a problem. News and dramas sometimes depict gays as criminals or perverse, especially in coming-out storylines (Bennett, 2000). -**Sexually Dangerous (Gay Plague):** During the AIDS crisis of the 1980s, gay men were stereotyped as carriers of a "gay plague." News coverage often blamed homosexual behavior for the spread of AIDS, reflecting societal fear and hatred of the gay community (Watney).
62
Symbolic Annihilation of Gay and Lesbian Sexuality
-Gross (1991): The media often "symbolically annihilates" gays and lesbians by excluding them, trivializing, condemning, or making fun of them. -Gauntlett (2008): While progress is being made, gays and lesbians are still underrepresented or portrayed negatively in mainstream media.
63
Stonewall study
-Only 5% of TV programs popular with young people feature gay or lesbian characters, mostly in a few shows like Hollyoaks and Emmerdale. -Half of these portrayals are based on stereotypes, and 36% are negative, depicting gays as figures of fun, predatory, or promiscuous.
64
Cowan findings
-1 in 5 people believes TV is responsible for anti-gay prejudice. -Cowan & Valentine (2005): Gay people are five times more likely to be portrayed negatively than positively on the BBC. Gay life is mainly featured in entertainment programs, rarely in factual content.
65
Changing stereotypes of gay people
-The traditional stereotypes of the camp gay man and butch lesbian are fading, reflecting growing social acceptance of homosexuality. -Matt Lucas, Alan Carr highlight changing representations of gay people in the media, signaling a shift in portrayal. -The Influence of the 'Pink Pound' - purchasing power of gay people, particularly those who are professionals with higher disposable incomes, is being recognised by companies, influencing more positive portrayals of the community. **Pluralists** -The media is responding to the demands of gay and lesbian audiences, particularly through advertising and media products. -New media platforms, such as gay and lesbian websites and apps, reflect this shift.
66
Sanitisation of gay sexuality
-Gay men’s sexuality is often toned down in the media, focusing on style rather than sexual intimacy to avoid challenging heterosexual norms and alienating advertisers **(Gill)** -Lesbian imagery is often sexualized through the male gaze, focusing on women's bodies for male pleasure. -The commercial nature of media limits diverse sexual representations to prevent alienating audiences and advertisers. -Media often avoids showing the sexual aspects of gay identity, as seen in shows like Will and Grace.
67
Criticism of Sanitisation
These portrayals marginalise gay and lesbian experiences, suggesting their lives are less important than heterosexual ones. They also portray heterosexuals as tolerant for having gay friends.
68
Gay sexuality & moral panic
-The media increasingly sensationalises issues like paedophilia and child grooming, especially through internet chatrooms. -Headlines often focus on how children are exposed to adult sexual behaviours - e.g. provocative dress, body language, or access to porn. -These topics frequently spark moral panics, becoming recurring headline-grabbing stories in the press.
69
Representations of age: Children stereotypes (Headliners)
Children are often shown in a positive light, especially as consumers in adverts or as sources of humour in sitcoms. 1. Victims – seen as innocent, led astray or harmed by others. 2. Cute kids – used to generate emotional, feel-good reactions. 3. Little devils – portrayed as naughty, disruptive or dangerous. 4. Brilliant kids – exceptional achievers, often exaggerated. 5. Accessories – children enhancing their parents' public image. 6. Modern – adults express nostalgia, suggesting kids today are too grown up or corrupted. 7. Little angels – brave, innocent, or enduring adversity with grace.
70
General portrayal of youth
-Often shown in a negative light: rebellious, lazy, violent, and involved in anti-social behaviour, especially young working-class males. -Linked to crime, gangs, drugs, alcohol, and binge drinking. -Rarely shown as responsible or facing real societal challenges.
71
Wayne et al
-Analysed 2130 TV news items: -> Only 286 focused on young people. -> Of those, 82% portrayed them as perpetrators or victims of violent crime. -> Only 1% included the perspective or voice of young people themselves. Conclusion: media presents a one-sided view that promotes fear and condemnation, rather than understanding real youth issues like poverty, lack of housing, or unemployment.
72
Women in journalism (2009)
-Teenage boys were usually represented in crime stories, described using terms like: -> “Yobs,” “thugs,” “feral,” “louts,” “heartless,” “evil,” “scum”. -Reinforces a hostile and threatening image of teenage boys.
73
White et al (2012)
-Found that broadcasters often negatively stereotype young people. -Over 40% of young viewers felt misrepresented as disrespectful and living “unproductive and vacuous lives.”
74
Cohen & moral panic
-Young people are powerless and easily blamed for society’s problems. -Particularly young Black males are turned into “folk devils” to create a sense of public unity. -Media fuels moral panics, which justify tougher control and criminalisation of youth.
75
Mazzarella & Pecora (2001) – Teenage Girls
-Over half of media stories were about intervention or prevention (e.g. teen pregnancy, STDs). -Only 20% included actual input or quotes from teenage girls. -Shows a lack of youth voice and a focus on controlling their behaviour rather than understanding it.
76
Key representations of teenage girls
-“Ladette” culture (drinking, swearing). -Sexualisation and pressure to conform to beauty standards. -Focus on body image and moral judgement.
77
Resistance & change through new media
-Young people are major users of digital platforms, including social media, YouTube, and TikTok. -This enables “citizen journalism”- they can challenge stereotypes, share real experiences, and reclaim their own narratives. -Over time, this may pressure traditional media to portray youth in a more balanced and realistic way.
78
Underrepresentation & stereotyping of old people
-Cuddy & Fiske (2004): Only 1.5% of US TV characters are elderly; when shown, they’re often used for comic relief and mocked for physical, mental or sexual decline. -Biggs (1993): In the UK, elderly characters are often portrayed as forgetful or difficult. -White et al. (2012): Older viewers find media stereotypes insulting, especially portrayals of them as bigoted.
79
Negative framing of old people
-Old age shown as a social and economic burden: -> Associated with poverty, ill health, and loss of independence. -> Represented as “out of touch” with modern life and technology. -**Lasch (Marxist view):** Capitalism sees the elderly as economically useless because they don’t work or spend much. -Society promotes “youthfulness”: Industries profit from fear of ageing (e.g. cosmetics, fitness, surgery).
80
Ageism & gender inequality
-US study: Only 3% of prime-time characters were over 70. -33% of male prime-time characters were over 40, but only 19% of females. -Hollywood often pairs older men with much younger women, but rarely the reverse. **Age Concern (2000):** -65+ population was 21%, but only 7% of TV characters were in that age group.
81
Class & gender differences
**Newman (2006):** -Middle-class elderly shown more positively in high-status roles like judges, politicians, executives. -Older men = wise, authoritative, successful. Often romantically paired with younger women. **Older women:** -Symbolically annihilated in media after a certain age. -Naomi Wolf: “In patriarchy, a woman dies twice — at menopause, and then at death.” -Rare to see older women in romantic roles, especially not with younger men.
82
Rise of the ‘grey pound’
-Media slowly shifting to target elderly consumers. -Older people now seen as an important market with spending power. -E.g. Dove advertising campaign featuring older women to market beauty products.
83
Representations of Disability
-Disability = a physical or mental impairment with long-term effects on a person’s ability to carry out everyday tasks. In 2025 YouGov, 25% of UK adults were classed as disabled — yet they are severely underrepresented in media (symbolic annihilation).
84
Disability as a social construction
-Shakespeare (1998) - a sociologist with dwarfism: -> Argues disability is a social construction. -> The real "problem" isn't the impairment itself, but society’s attitudes towards it. -Most of what people understand about disability comes from media and socialisation, not direct experience. -This means media stereotypes shape public attitudes, often inaccurately or harmfully.
85
Symbolic annihilation of disability (Cumberbatch)
-Content analysis (2013–2014) showed only 2.5% of TV characters were portrayed as disabled, despite over 20% of people being disabled in real life. -In 2/3 of cases, the disability was the main part of their character. -Only 1/3 of disabled characters were just shown as people who happened to have a disability. -Over a third were shown as needing aids (e.g. wheelchairs).
86
Stereotyping & tokenism (OfCom)
-40%+ of disabled portrayals appeared in shows discussing prejudice, stereotypes, or discrimination. -80% of impairments shown were mobility, sensory, disfigurement, or physical/mental illnesses
87
Negative representations
**Briant et al (GMG study)** -Compared 5 newspapers (2010–11). -Media had shifted from sympathy to hostility. -Articles linking disability to benefit fraud more than doubled in 5 years. -Nearly 1 in 5 used terms like "scrounger", "cheat", "skiver". **Philo et al (GMG):** -Focused on mental illness. -Nearly 50% of peak-time portrayals of mental illness showed individuals as dangerous/threatening. -Reinforced fear and stigma.
88
Some positive progress (GMG follow up)
-Noted improvement in soap/drama portrayals of mental illness. -More authentic, nuanced, and sympathetic representations. -Fewer “mad and bad” stereotypes. -However, portraying disabled people only as victims is still seen as limiting and problematic.
89
Cumberbatch & Negrine’s 3 Broad Stereotypes
1. The Criminal – Disabled characters shown as dangerous or villainous. 2. The Subhuman – Lacking full human qualities. 3. The Powerless/Pathetic – Weak, dependent, and helpless
90
Barnes’ 10 stereotypes of disabled people
1. Pitiable or Pathetic – Disabled people are shown to evoke pity, often used in charity appeals and emotional storytelling. 2. Atmospheric or Object of Curiosity – They are included to create mood, mystery or intrigue, rather than as full characters. 3. Object of Violence – Disabled characters are often portrayed as helpless victims of abuse or bullying. 4. Sinister or Evil – Disability is linked with villainy, madness, or danger, especially in horror and thriller genres. 5. Super Cripple – They are portrayed as inspirational heroes who overcome their impairments with extraordinary strength or abilities. 6. Laughable or Ridiculed – Disabled people are used as comic relief or mocked for their condition. 7. Own Worst Enemy – Media blames the individual for their struggles, suggesting it’s their attitude holding them back. 8. Burden – They are depicted as dependent and a heavy responsibility for others to care for. 9. Non-Sexual – Disabled people are seen as lacking sexual desire or attractiveness, making their lives appear incomplete. 10. Unable to Participate in Daily Life – They are rarely shown living normal lives, with roles like workers, friends or parents often excluded.
91
Media Representations of Disability: Karpf and Roper
**Karpf (1988):** The media focuses on miracle cures and portraying disabled people (especially children) as pitiful victims in charity telethons, which promotes patronising stereotypes and benefits corporate sponsors more than the disabled community. **Roper (2003):** Telethons turn disabled people into passive beggars, encouraging viewers to donate out of guilt rather than educating them about the real social and structural issues faced by disabled people.
92
Ross (1996) - Disabled Viewers' Attitudes
-Unrealistic and stereotypical portrayals of disability. -Overuse of visual symbols like wheelchairs and guide dogs. -Disabled characters often shown as angry, bitter, or unable to accept their condition. -Lack of representation of disabled people living normal lives. -Media practitioners often lack firsthand experience with disability.
93
How will new media lead to change?
-New media (e.g., social media, YouTube) allows disabled people to control their own narratives. -These platforms enable sharing of real-life experiences and challenging stereotypes. -Increased visibility of disabled influencers pushes for more inclusive media portrayals. -Traditional media may adapt to changing demands for more authentic representation.
94
Are representations changing? - O’Sullivan & Jewkes
-Argue there are more disabled people on TV now. -Disabled people are being portrayed in a more rounded and complex way in films. -Disability is depicted more authentically and diversely, moving beyond stereotypes.
95
Overall AO3 - Have representations of social groups in the media changed over time?
-**Postmodernists' View:** Media representations were more fixed in the modern era, but have since become fragmented and more diverse. -Movements like feminism influencing portrayals of gender, age, and sexuality. -**Political Correctness:** The media appears more politically correct in its portrayal of minority groups, suggesting a shift toward more inclusive representations. -**Democratic Influence:** Complaints to regulators (e.g., OFCOM) and the rise of new media have allowed individuals to influence media content and create their own media, making it more democratic. -**Legal Reforms:** The Equality Act, 2010 has improved legal protections against discrimination, impacting media portrayals. -**Underrepresentation in Media Employment:** Despite progress, minority groups remain underrepresented in media employment, leading to inaccurate or limited coverage of these groups, like people with disabilities.