Media: Representations Flashcards
Media gaze
-Media reflects the perspective of the dominant groups – mostly white, able-bodied, upper/middle-class men.
-This leads to lack of representation of wider social diversity in media content.
Symbolic annihilation (Tuchman)
-Describes how some social groups are ignored, trivialised or stereotyped in the media.
-Affects groups based on: Ethnicity, Gender, Sexual orientation, Age, Disability, Social class.
-Under-representation and limited roles distort public perception or erase visibility of these groups in society.
Diversity of interpretation (Gauntlett)
-People do not all react the same way to media.
-Media audiences are diverse and often resist or reinterpret representations.
Meaning varies depending on personal experience:
-> A minority ethnic viewer may interpret a portrayal differently than a white viewer.
-> Disabled viewers may resist or reject stereotypical portrayals.
-In the postmodern era, people may ‘pick ’n’ mix’ representations to create their own identity.
Hyperreality - Baudrillard
-In a media-saturated society, people may struggle to distinguish media from reality.
-Media representations can become hyperreal - more real than actual reality.
-Media doesn’t just reflect reality – it creates it.
-Especially influential for people with no personal experience to challenge what they see in the media.
Media representations & dominant ideology (GMG)
-Media content is shaped by the dominant ideology in society.
-Stereotypes and representations often:
-> Reflect the values of the ruling class
-> Reinforce cultural hegemony (Gramsci)
-> Justify existing social inequalities in power, wealth, and status.
-Media helps maintain consent for the dominant social order.
Representations of Gender: Under-representations of women in the media
-The international women’s media foundation (2010) found that in
UK news women faced a glass ceiling that was fixed at the junior professional level. 60% of senior professional roles were filled by men.
-Women in Journalism (2011) - 74% of news journalists on national newspapers were men & there are twice as many male news editors than women. In 2012 78% of all front page articles were written by male journalists.
-Guardian (2011) 77% of news reports are written by male journalists.
-Zomen (1994) argues that to succeed in the media, women have to adapt to the patriarchal ideology that dominates media companies.
Representations of Gender: The male gaze
-GMG, Marxists feminists and Radical feminists argue that gender representations of gender are filtered through the media gaze of the / pre-dominantly male-dominated media establishment, which means that women are portrayed through what Mulvey calls the male gaze.
-Men gaze at women as sexual objects, with images of women focusing on their physical appearance and sexuality. This is all done for men’s pleasure.
-Levenson inquiry (2012) found that the tabloid press failed to show consistent respect for the dignity and equality of women as there was a tendency to sexualise and demean women.
Representations of Gender: Under-representation & stereotypes in media content
-Global media monitoring projects (2010) - nearly half of all news stories reinforced gender stereotypes. The news remains predominately male with male presenters being seen as experts and women as ‘ordinary’,
-Cumberbatch et al. (2014) - content analysis of popular TV shows - women appear less often on TV in comparison to men. Women appear as supporting roles, this is particularly the case for older women who are under-represented in comparison to older men who are over-represented.
-Martinson (2014) - over 50’s appear on BBC TV 82% are men.
-Across all major TV channels over 50’s women make up just 5%.
-Almy et al (1994) argues that media representations are important because these stereotypes provide role models that we are encouraged to aspire to.
Representations of Gender: Patriarchal ideology & symbolic annihilation of women
-Women are either invisible, under-represented or represented in a limited range of stereotypical roles. -Tuchman - Symbolic annihilation: women’s achievements are often not reported, or are condemned or trivialised by the mass media. Or their achievements are presented as less important than their looks and sex appeal. She found:
1. Women were overwhelmingly represented in two roles, domestic (housewife and mother) and sexual (including romantic).
2. Men were portrayed as authority figures, workers, breadwinners and sportsmen.
3. Men outnumbered women on TV by 3 to 1. Women suffered
‘symbolic annihilation’ by the media ‘through absence, condemnation or trivialisation’.
4. Game shows, quizzes and discussion programmes were invariably presented by men (authority figures).
Media & Gender - Hegemony (Connell)
Media helps construct gender through hegemonic stereotypes.
-Hegemonic masculinity: strength, dominance, aggression, emotional restraint.
-Hegemonic femininity: beauty, nurturing, passivity, emotional sensitivity.
The beauty myth (Wolf)
-Women judged primarily by appearance, shaped by male ideals.
-Media promotes unrealistic beauty standards (e.g. size zero, airbrushed models).
-Tebbell (2000): Modern women are more obsessed with body image than ever before.
-Media has made real female bodies invisible.
-Industries (cosmetics, fashion, cosmetic surgery) profit from insecurity.
Gendered media content
Magazines reflect traditional gender roles:
-> “Men’s interests” vs. “Women’s interests”
-> Romantic fiction = female-focused; action/sports = male-focused
-Girlguiding UK (2012): Girls rely heavily on celebrity/reality TV role models.
-Reinforces narrow versions of femininity.
Video games - Children Now (2001)
-Only 16% of characters were female.
-Female characters: sexualised, often scantily clad.
-Male characters: aggressive, dominant.
-Games like Grand Theft Auto glorify violence against women.
Hegemonic male characteristics
-Heterosexual
-Sexually dominant
-Independent
-Repressed emeotionally
-Strong/muscular/tall
Hegemonic female characteristics
-Sexual passivity
-Heterosexuality
-Expression of emotions
-Dependance
-Physically weak/fragile/small
-Gentle & non-aggressive
-Concerned with physical appearance
Female representations: Limited roles
-Feminists such as Wolf often argue that women are represented in a narrow range of social roles or are excluded from representation altogether.
-Feminists suggest that the media strongly encourage women to conform to ideological patriarchal ideals that confirm they’re subordinate to men.
Stereotypes of women in media
- The WAG / Femme Fatale – Obsessed with beauty, love, and keeping their man.
- The Sex Object – Slim, seductive, scantily clad; often used in tabloids, ads, and porn.
- The Supermum – Home-maker; juggles childcare, housework, and emotional labour.
- The Angel – Good, domestic, low sexuality; supports the man.
- The Ball Breaker – Career-driven, independent, sexually active; not reliant on men.
- The Victim – Seen in horror/crime media; harmed by men, sometimes rescued by them.
The ‘cult of femininity’ - Ferguson
-Teen girls’ magazines teach traditional feminine roles.
-Promote:
-> Getting/keeping a partner
-> Being a good wife/mother
-> Focus on appearance, cooking, fashion, emotions.
-Continues into adult women’s magazines.
What are the impacts of this?
-Gross & Jefferies-Fox: Boys who watched large amounts of TV were more likely to believe that women were happiest in domestic roles (making a home or caring for children).
-French & McGhee: Found a positive correlation between heavy TV viewing and gender stereotyping in kindergarten children in the US.
-Beuf (1980s): Interviewed 63 boys and girls aged 3-6 and found that many girls at a young age had ruled out certain careers, believing they were for boys.
-Role of Female Role Models: The small number of high-status female role models may limit female aspirations.
-Media vs. Family Influence:!Unclear whether the media or the family is more responsible for reinforcing these gender attitudes.
-Hermes (1995): Argues that the effect of media on women is not passive. Instead, she believes magazines are read in different ways, suggesting an active role for the audience in interpreting the media.
-Complex Relationship: The media’s portrayal of gender involves a complex relationship between the messages, the audience, and the effects, indicating that the impact is not straightforward.
Masculinity in the media
-Men are often shown in higher-status occupations, such as bosses or managers, compared to women in subordinate roles like secretaries or PAs.
-Male voices are more frequently used in voice-overs on TV and in advertising, reinforcing the image of men as authority figures or experts.
-Older men are often shown as sexual partners for younger women, a depiction that is rarely reversed in media.
-The stereotyped image of the tough, assertive, dominant, and rational male is common (Gilmore, 1991). He is often seen as the provider, protector, and impregnator.
-Men’s magazines tend to focus on stereotypical masculine interests, such as sport, photography, technology, DIY, and various forms of transport (cars, motorbikes, boats).
Stereotypes of men in the media
- The Joker - Uses humor to avoid showing emotion.
- The Jock - Avoids softness, shows aggression to demonstrate strength and win approval.
- The Strong Silent Type - In control, avoids emotions, successful with women.
- The Big Shot - Economically and socially successful, high status with matching possessions.
- The Action Hero - Strong, aggressive, often violent.
- The Buffoon - Well-intentioned but inept, especially in domestic or parenting roles.
Masculinity in media representations
-Kibly (1980s): Shows like The A-Team and Magnum linked masculinity to power, authority, aggression, and technology.
-Butler & Paisley: Found men were stereotyped similarly to women (as workers, authority figures, etc.).
-Easthorpe Media (films, games) portray masculinity as biologically determined, based on strength, aggression, and violence, creating an ideal many men internalize but can’t fully achieve.
-Crechen’s Surveys: Majority view women’s sports as inferior to men’s, with 80-90% of media coverage focused on men’s sports, emphasizing aggression and strength.
Theoretical explanations for gender stereotyping: Pluralists
-Stereotyping occurs because it satisfies the desires of both media audiences and organisations.
-Media organisations, driven by the need to attract audiences and make money, use stereotypes as a simple and effective way to appeal to viewers.
Theoretical explanations for gender stereotyping: Liberal feminists
-Media representations reflect the under-representation of women in positions of power (e.g. chief executives, editors).
-The dominance of men in media organisations shapes a male-centered view of the world.
-As women gain more power and equal opportunities in media, they will break through the “glass ceiling,” leading to changes in media representations.