Media representations Flashcards
Vir, Hall and Foye (nationality)
English - BBC said to have more of a Southern English bias and London focus - BBC was perceived as representing the interests of its English viewers more than other nations’ viewers
Media example: BBC
Mulhern (nationality)
Irish - media portrayal of the irish stereotyped: homesick and drinking bad Guinness while listening to bad ballads in north London, too successful to be homesick while making megabucks in the City, and reporting the good wealth home via Skype
Media example: Mrs Brown’s Boys
Vir, Hall and Foye (nationality)
Scottish - those living in the Highlands feel under-represented in media portrayals and coverage (outside nature and wildlife programming) - one participant stated “I think it (sport) is very much English broadcast and Scotland is quietly left behind” and another claimed that “The Scottish person is always drunk and an abusive drunk at that”
Media example: Groundskeeper Willie from the Simpsons
Graham (nationality)
Welsh - media can sometimes force other nationals into TV programmes leading to tokenism. One participant discussed “Gavin and Stacey - it’s all about portraying Wales as thick”
Media example: Gavin and Stacey
Vir, Hall and Foye (nationality)
Welsh - In Wales, there was a perception that reality TV can be exploitative in their portrayal of the Welsh. Some were more positive and stated that personalities such as Alex Jones and Huw Edwards were seen as further demonstration of the BBC potentially doing more than other broadcasters of their nation
Media example: Dirty Sanchez and The Valleys
Van Dijk (ethnicity) (traditional/negative)
Content analysis into media representations of ethnic groups in the UK over a 10 year period. Black people are stereotyped in the media in 5 ways - criminal, abnormal, a threat, dependent, unimportant
Media example: Stacey Dooley
Malik (ethnicity) (traditional/negative)
She examined Channel 4’s research that found that the majority of white British people found that broadcasters were reflecting multicultural Britain to a satisfactory level, other ethnic groups felt that contrasting this was done very poorly. Broadcasters are guilty of tokenism and stereotyping
Media example: Channel 4
Barker (ethnicity) (traditional/negative)
Studied ethnic minority groups in the soap opera Eastenders, and noted that it had been heavily criticised for stereotyping of ethnic minority groups - for example Asian and black characters being given the roles of doctors and shopkeepers. Characters were portrayed as having limited, stereotypical character traits as opposed to being multifaceted, complex people. Eastenders’ producers still have a long way to go to overcome the latent racism of the programme as key characters are still often White British
Media example: Eastenders
Hall (ethnicity) (traditional/negative)
Overt racism and ethnic minority folk devils - Black people are seen through the White Eye
Media example: Good Luck Charlie
Husband and Hartman (ethnicity) (traditional/negative)
Media operates within a culture that sees Black Afro-Caribbean people as foreigners and as inferior. The media emphasises racial conflict and problems and presents negative images and stereotypes of ethnic minorities
Media example: News channels
Children Now - Fair Play Survey (ethnicity) (traditional/negative)
There is a continuation of stereotyping of ethnic minorities within new media such as video games - 86% of heroes were White, 8/10 black characters wer eportrayed as competitors in sports games and 86% of black female characters were portrayed as victims of violence. It seems from this evidence that the new media aimed at the younger generations is more stereotypical than traditional media
Media example: Marvel video games
Moghissi (ethnicity) (traditional/negative)
Muslims are huddled together by the media, which ignores the huge range of differences between Muslims in class, beliefs and culture. Since 9/11 and 7/7 there has been moral panic about Islam and coverage is negative, stereotyped and Islamaphobic
Media example: BBC
Malik (ethnicity) (changing/positive)
Reality TV such as Gogglebox was increasingly more inclusive compared to other genres of TV and there has been a shift in how ethnic minority groups are depicted in new forms of media
Media example: Love Island
Barker (ethnicity) (changing/positive)
Eastenders can be seen to be chaning the way in which ethnic minorities are presented through its storylines. There are now a range of Asian and black characters that reflect the demographic of London more fairly than it used to. Ethnic minority characters also hold some significant roles and explains that they are given meaningful attention and stories
Medi example: Eastenders
Hall (ethnicity) (changing/positive)
The media has shifted from displaying overt racism to inferential racism meaning it is an unconscious act and refers to the idea that presumptions are made about a race which does hold racist, unquestioned assumptions. Therefore this is a subtle positive change as overt racism would no longer be acceptable in the media
Media example: Eastenders
Nayak (ethnicity) (hybridity)
Refers to young, working class, White males who adopt the language and style of black culture. In this hybrid ethnic identity, White youths listen to hip hop, gangsta-rap, wear of bling and dress in a style associated with black males.
Media example: Professor Green
Gill (ethnicity) (hybridity)
Studied the emergence of new ethnic identities. Blasians refers to Asian youths who adopt black culture of rap, etc and Brasians refers to Asian youths who adopt a White British culture when with peers e.g. Laddish culture
Media example: Zayn Malik
Tunstall (gender) (traditional/negative)
Media representations emphasise women’s domestic, sexual, consumer and marital activities to the exclusion of all else. The media generally ignore the fact that a majority of British women go out to work
Media example: Baywatch
Tuchman (gender) (traditional/negative)
Narrow range of roles for women lead to their symbolic annihilation
Media example: Wolf of Wall Street
Glascock (gender) (traditional/negative)
When portrayed as aggressive in the media, males were more physically aggressive, whereas females were more verbally aggressive
Media example: Mean Girls
Katz (gender) (traditional/negative)
Epidemic of male violence due to medias inability to move away from stereotypical versions of masculinity. Media portrays masculinity as violence, sexism and homophobic
Media example: Call of Duty
Gauntlett (gender) (traditional/negative)
Despite a changing media landscape there are many magazines aimed at male audiences that continue to sexually objectify women and present images of traditionally masculine men. These magazines represent retributive masculinity - a way to reaffirm masculine authority by glorifying what is conventionally male
Media example: Andrew Tate
Easthorpe (gender) (traditional/negative)
A variety of media, transmits the view that masculinity is based on strength, aggression, competition and violent is biologicall determined and therefore, it is a natural goal for boys to achieve
Media example: Marvel
Westwood (gender) (changing/positive)
Gender representations have changed - transgressive female roles in British television
Media example: Doctor Who