Lesson 10: Language Inside and Outside Flashcards
Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis
the structure of a language influences how its speakers perceive the world around them
Strong Form of Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis
Lingustic Determinism
the structure of a language determines how speakers think
Weak Form of Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis
Linguistic Relativism
different languages encode different categories, and speakers of different languages think about the world in different ways
True or False:
The Hopi language shows evidence for the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis because it does not have any tense terms.
False
The Hopi language has tense markers, units of time, and timekeeping devices.
True or False:
The Inuit language shows evidence for the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis because it has several terms for snow.
False
The number of snow terms in Inuit is not unique to the language; it is an example of specialization in language.
What are 4 pieces of evidence against the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis?
- mismatches
- ambiguity
- new words for new concepts
- Case of Ildelfonso
How do mismatches show evidence against the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis?
linguistic sense is often different from intended sense
(ex: metaphors)
How does ambiguity show evidence against the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis?
ambiguous words have concepts that are clearly distinct
How do new words for new concepts show evidence against the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis?
speakers make up new words or borrow language when there’s no word to express something
concept comes before language
True or False:
Because Ildelfonso did not have language, he was not able to perform basic tasks throughout his life.
False
Ildelfonso still had a concept of the world around him.
True or False:
Cultures with limited terms for color do not differentiate between colors.
False
There’s a unviersal physiological basis for color naming, independent of language.
True or False:
The Russian blues experiment supports the stronger view (linguistic determinism) of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis.
False
It supports the weaker view.
What is linguistic determinism?
A. the logical problem that children are able to acquire complex structures based on limited input.
B. the idea that the structure of a language constrains the way its speakers think.
C. the fact that higher primates lack language, which determines that they also lack number concepts.
D. the idea that the number of grammatical categories in a language is determined by the number of lexical items.
E. the idea that culture can determine the structural properties of a language.
B. the idea that the structure of a language constrains the way its speakers think.
Which of the following case studies show support for a strong Sapir-Whorf theory like Linguistic Determinism?
A. Inuit words for snow
B. Hopi words for time
C. Russian words for blue
D. None of the above
D. None of the above
What does the case study of the Inuit’s words for snow tell us about language and thought?
A. Languages can only express terminology for concepts in their culture.
B. Inuit see snow in an inherently more in-depth way than other cultures.
C. English is a superior language for expressing terms for snow.
D. Nothing.
Nothing.