Lecture 5 Flashcards
Case studies are NOT a
Research method
Case studies use a range of
Research methods
People get confused about case studies because
A case study can be not just one individual but focused on a particular unit ie an organisation, or group of ppl
Case studies used to:
Generate theory
To explore something in depth
Idiographic perspective is one if the identifying features of case studies. What is this?
Concern with particular (idiographic) rather than identifying general laws of behaviour.
Does not generalise results
Idiographic means
Particular
Nomothetic means
General
Attention to contextual data is one if the identifying features of case studies. What is this?
Holistic approach…considers things like what is happening in environment. Does not aim to replicate results.
Triangulation is one if the identifying features of case studies. What is this?
Integrates info from diverse sources (interviews, observations) to gain understanding of the phenomena/an overall answer
- use a range of research methods
Temporal element is one if the identifying features of case studies. What is this?
Investigations of occurrences over time
A concern with theory is one if the identifying features of case studies. What is this?
Facilitate theory generation. Data generated by case studies is often interpreted within the context of GT
What are the methods of data collection for case studies?
- semi structured interview
- participant observation
- diaries
- personal and official documents
Methods of case study data analysis include:
TA (theme analysis)
GT
IPA
FDA
Why can’t you use DA for case study data analysis??
Because you aren’t working with naturally occurring speech!
What are the 3 different case study designs?
- Intrinsic v. Instrumental
- Single v. Multiple
- Descriptive v. Explanatory
Why are there 3 different types of case study design?
They each allow the researcher to address different research q’s
In Intrinsic case studies the researcher wants to know about
The case in particular rather than a more general problem or phenomenon
Intrinsic case studies are pre-specified why?
The intrinsic interest pre-exists the research
Examples of intrinsic cases studies:
Patients with rare diseases
Clients with unusual problems
Instrumental case studies are contrasting to intrinsic case studies why?
Because the focus of general phenomenon.
In instrumental case studies cases are chosen to explore
How a phenomenon exists within a particular case
Single case studies are
Detailed investigation of a single case
Single case studies have an ………interest to the researcher
Intrinsic
Single case studies provide opportunity to test applicability of existing theory to
Real world data
3 reasons to select a single case
- Critical test for well formulated theory
- unique/extreme case of intrinsic interest to researcher
- revelatory case that may have previously been inaccessible
Multiple case studies are great for
Banding together to create new theory
In multiple case studies your theory is developed and refined on the basis of
Comparative analysis of series of cases
In multiple case studies your theory is ……….to account for all instances of phenomenon revealed with each new case
Modified
Descriptive case studies provide
Detailed description of phenomenon within its context
The descriptive case studies the info is collect how?
Without changing the environment
The detail in descriptive case studies provides
New insights into and better understandings of phenomenon under investigation
What is an example if descriptive case study?
Ethnographies - conducted in the field
4 procedural issues with case studies
- Selection of cases
- Method of data analysis
- Role of theory
- Ethical concerns
Advantages of case studies. 4
- Address a wide range of experiences, behaviours, phenomena
- Rich data
- High Eco validity
- Versatile approach
Case study disadvantages: 1
Methodological triangulation (frameworks may be incompatible)
What are the first 2 features if observational research?
Extent to which observation is 1. covert and 2. Standardised/systematic
Second two features of observational research…
- Extent to which observation occurs in natural setting and
- How much observer takes part in activity bring observed.
Final feature of observational research
Extent to which observation involves self-observation (reflexivity )
Observational research involves watching individuals in 3 contexts.
Lab
Field
Participant (researcher as participant)
In Fully structured observation data is collected
Using systematic manner using grid recording systems and coding systems
Why is systematic data collection important?
- reliability of material collected
- ensures coding system used reliably
Naturalistic observation is where you investigate
Phenomenon of interest for a set period of time
In naturalistic research you try to work out
Patterns of behaviour related to a phenomenon of interest
Case studies are:
In depth (ALOT of data) and focused explorations of single cases
What are the 4 activities central to participant observation
- participation
- documentation
- informal interviewing
- reflection
3 types of notes maintained in participant observation
- Substantive notes
- Methodological notes
- Analytic notes
Substantive notes are
Descriptions of settings, events, people
Methodological notes are on the
Process of observation
Analytic notes are on
Data analysis and theory building
3 types if data recording
Note taking
Video
Coding
2 methods of data sampling
Event sampling
Time sampling
Event sampling involves looking at
One particular event or a behaviour
Time sampling looks at
Snapshots of time. Ie 15 secs every 5mins (taking in everything that is happening)
Narrative method is the way in which humans
Make sense if and order the chaos and disorder in their worlds
Through narrative we do 3 things
- Define ourselves
- Establish temporal continuity to the self
- Distinguish ourselves from others
A narrative is an organised interpretation of
A sequence of events. It’s linear ie beginning, middle, end
Narrative stories involve 2 things
Attributing agency to characters
Establishing causal links between events
Two functions of narrative are:
Emplotment
Creation of self identity
Whole purpose of emplotment is to
Bring order to disorder into a linear plot. How we make sense of things that are disordered in our life.
Narratives are often provisional. Why?
They are subject to change as new info is discovered
Out narratives are shaped by our
Social contexts
Groups also have narratives which shape
Group identities
Your particular narrative you tell is going to be slightly different depending on:
The type of audience you have
The broader social and cultural context
Narrative research method is
Unstructured interview
Episodic interview deals with a
Particular disruptive event
When going a narrative you must have the following details from the person:
- Biographical info
- Background material about central participants in the participants narrative
- detailed log for each interview
Descriptive read if the narrative involves you becoming
Familiar with structure and content
Prepare short summary (beginning, middle, end)
Identify sub-plots
Interpretive reading of your narrative involves looking at 5 issues:
Structure Tone (emotional flavour) Dominant themes Context Language