Lecture 5 Flashcards
Dr. Roy thinks the importance of which debate has been overstated in the history of psychology?
structuralism (Titchener) vs functionalism (James)
Edward Boring was a student of ______.
His 1929 book, ______ (one of first psych history books), put lots of emphasis on the debate between ____ and ____
student of Titchener (structuralist!)
book: A History of Experimental Psychology
debate btw structuralism and functionalism
Edward Bradford Titchener (1867-1927) was a (structuralist/functionalist)
structuralist (leader of structuralist school)
Titchener believed that experimental psychology’s major goal was _______
the atomistic analysis of the elements of consciousness
Titchener was one of _____’s most influential students
Wundt
What warning of Wundt’s did Titchener disagree with?
- Wundt warned against reductionism (introspectively revealed dimensions of consciousness can’t be considered “elements” bc they can’t exist on their own!!
Titchener thinks that by using ___ we can break down complex thoughts into ____. This process goes the opposite way of which thinker’s idea?
introspection; simpler elements (atoms of thought, sensory in nature)
opposite of Locke (experience –> simple ideas –> complex ideas)
What does Titchener think about Kant’s idea that inner observation cannot be separated and recombined at will?
disagrees with this; we can identify basic elements of thought
According to Titchener, how should we use the method of introspection?
- trained “introspectors” have to work hard to reduce all their mental contents into more basic elements while avoiding stimulus error
What is stimulus error?
- describing the object rather than one’s experience w the object
- Titchener warns against this
According to Titchener, all conscious experience can be reduced to ______
introspectively accessible sensory images
What does Titchener think about the use of language?
we should use specialized language, but it shouldn’t be too technical
Titchener established _____ distinguishable elements of sensory experience (___ visual, ____ auditory, ___ taste, ____ sensations of digestive tract)
43 000
30 000 visual, 11 000 auditory, 4 taste, 3 sensations of digestive tract
According to Titchener/Boring, the 4 main dimensions of consciousness are:
Quality, intensity, extensity (space) and protensity (duration)
What 3 reasons were given for why Titchener’s structuralism had limited impact in the field of psychology?
- introspection did not intuitively give rise to the experience of elementary sensations (our minds do things without us being conscious of it (ex creative synthesis))
- no practical impact
- failed to convince the researchers who remained interested in contents of consciousness (he took structuralism too far; it goes totally against gestalt psych idea that whole is different from sum of its parts)
How do mechanistic and vitalistic physiology fit into the reductionist/emergentist framework?
mechanistic physiology is similar to reductionism
vitalistic physiology is similar to emergentism
Who wrote “The Principles of Psychology” (1890)? How many years did it take?
- William James
- first english psych textbook
- took 12 years
James was more of a _____ than a program builder
communicator!
Who taught the first American uni course (at Harvard) on the new scientific psychology? (1872)
William James
Was Wundt a structuralist?
not really, hard to put him in a box
What did Wundt think of James’ work?
it is literature, it is beautiful, but it is not psychology
What did James think of Wundt’s work?
thought experimental psych concerned w very specific questions was boring!
What topic does James’ psych textbook start with?
physiology!
James: although it has limitations _____ is still the best available psychological method
introspection (didn’t like experimental methods)
James’ ideas can be interpreted as a precursor to ______ (by observing experience itself and letting experience dictate the categories)
- phenomenalism!
- here James is kinda in agreement w Titchener
James: minds are ____ in the natural world
objects
What metaphor can be used to describe James’ thoughts on consciousness? What about Titchener?
James: stream of consciousness
Titchener: train of thought
James: the stream of consciousness goes from a ____ part to a ____ part back to a _____ part
substantive part –> transitive part (moves fast, not totally aware of all thoughts) –> substantive part
5 key points about James’ “stream of consciousness”
- every thought is part of a personal consciousness
- thought is always changing
- thought is sensibly continuous
- there is an intentionality or “aboutness” of consciousness; object of attention is experienced as an “undivided state of consciousness”
- intrinsically related to direction of our thoughts/perceptions; only pay attention to a fraction of what we can be aware of
Attention in James’ “stream of consciousness” is similar to what element of Wundt’s ideas about consciousness?
- apperception!!
James: “My first act of free will shall be _______”
“… to believe in free will”
What did James decide during his existential crisis in 1870?
- to believe in free will
- built habit of thinking more positive thoughts (like mindfulness!)
- used free will in his personal life and determinism in science