Lecture 4 Flashcards
Classification and diagnosis
diagnosis
DSM - 5
ICD - 10
classification
a system that divides into categories on a basis of characteristics or features
psychological disorders may be categorised into symptoms for example
Kraepelin
one of the first to use classification systems that uses symptoms to classify disorders
ICD
official world classification
intended for use by all health practitioners
special attention given to primary care and low and middle income countries
major focus on clinical utility with reduction of number of diagnosis
provides diagnostic description and guidance by
but does not employ operational criteria
DSM
US classification
used primarily by psychiatrists
focused mainly on secondary psychiatry care in high-income countries
tends to increase the number if diagnosis with each succeeding revision
diagnostic systems depend on operational criteria using polythetic systems for most conditions
inter rater reliability
two independent researches will arrive at the same diagnosis
DSM multi axial system
5 dimensions
involves biological, psychological and social factors
enables a person-centred approach - Carl Rodgers
helps plan treatment
helps predict outcome
axes
- clinical disorders
- underlying pervasive/personality conditions
- acute medical conditions
- psychosocial and environmental factors
- global assessment of functioning
why do we classify?
name/group
science
shared language
homogeneity
aid research
develop causation theories
treatment
DSM 5
a classification system used to determine how and when symptoms presented combine to suggest the presence of a specific mental disorder
provides a specific criteria for diagnosing psychological disorders
circular argument
without bodily signs to confirm the presence of these illnesses diagnoses is not an explanation
why does this person have delusions?
because they have schizophrenia?
how do we know they have schizophrenia?m
because they have delusions?
validity
the extent t which the classification system is measuring what it claims to measure
reliability
varies between disorders
poor across clinical settings
nature of diagnosis is important
cross cultural differences
most classification systems are based on the western view of what is ‘abnormal’
gender bias
male based assumption influenced what is included in DSM
Ford and Widger - men are more likely diagnosed with ASPD and women diagnosed with histrionic personality disorder for the same profile labels