learning theories research method Flashcards
Define structured observations
When observations are structured so that the same situation is repeated with different participants and researchers observe what happens, the manipulation of the setting and situation makes the observation structured
When are structured observations used
- When the behaviour of interest doesn’t occur naturally so it is hard to observe in a natural setting
- So that there is a procedure that can be used in other places and countries and comparisons can be made between findings
What are the advantages of structured observations
- A controlled environment allows focusing on particular aspects of behaviour, e.g. children playing with feminine toys to observe how boys and girls react. This means that specific conclusions can be drawn about gender responses.
- It may be possible to draw some tentative causal conclusions if variables are deliberately changed by the researcher and different effects are observed then it suggests that one caused the other.
What are the disadvantages of structured observations
- Environment may feel unnatural and then participants may not behave as they would in everyday life, this could reduce the validity of observations
- Observer may see less
Define naturalistic observations
- They capture real-life data from a real situation and real behaviour
- There is no element of setting up what will happen and what will be observed
What are the advantages of naturalistic observations
- A realistic picture of natural, spontaneous behaviour. The observation takes place in a person’s natural environment and so they are likely to behave as they normally do. This means the results are likely to be high in ecological validity
- A useful method to use when investigating a new area of research, gives the researcher ideas of what further investigation may be planned, for example using certain behavioural categories or experimental methods
What are the disadvantages of naturalistic observations
- The observation is likely to be covert which raises ethical issues
- Difficult to draw conclusions if the focus is too wide, if behavioural categories and event/time sampling have been used that may restrict the amount of data collected which makes it easier to see of patterns of behaviour
Describe participant observations
The observer is a participant in the behaviour being observed (being in a bus stop queue and observing behaviour in the queue)
What are the advantages of participant observations
- Likely to provide special insights into behaviour, from the inside. The participant has greater familiarity with what is likely to happen don’t therefore may see greater detail that would be missed by someone new to the situation.
- Being on the inside means the observer may see more
What are the disadvantages of participant observations
- Objectivity is reduced due to observer bias because the observer is familiar with what is going on and they are looking at the situation more subjectively
- More difficult to record and monitor behaviour if the observer is part of the group being observed, therefore the observation is likely to be overt and participants are aware they are being studied which may alter their behaviour
Describe non-participant observations
observer is not a participant in the behaviour being observed
What are the advantages of non-participant observations
- Increased objectivity because of a psychological and physical distance
- Can observe in a way that is not blatant therefore participants will not be self-conscious about being observed. This may increase validity because participants behave more naturally.
What are the disadvantages of non-participant observations
The observer may misinterpret the communications within the group because they are an outsider, this could reduce the validity of the observations
Observer may see less
Describe an overt observation
Participant is aware of being observed
What are the advantages of an overt observation
- Avoids lack of informed consent because participants can decide if they want to participate
- It is easier to see everything that is going on because the observer doesn’t have to hide
What are the disadvantages of an overt observation
If participants know they are being observed they are likely to alter their behaviour due to demand characteristics
Describe a covert observation
Observations made without a participants knowledge
What are the advantages of a covert observation
Participants behave more naturally because they aren’t aware of being studied
What are the disadvantages of an covert observation
- Raises ethical issues about observing people without their knowledge, participants may be able to give informed consent if asked afterwards but in practice its difficult
- Invasion of privacy, even for observations in a public place, people might regard it as unethical to record what they are doing
What are the different ways of capturing data in observations
- Tallying
- Time sampling
- Event sampling
Describe behavioural categories for collecting quantitative data
Objective methods to separate continuous stream of action into components so behaviours can be counted
What are the advantages of behavioural categories for collecting quantitative data
- Enables systematic observations to be made so important information is not overlooked, enhances the validity
- Categories can be tallied and conclusions drawn
What are the disadvantages of behavioural categories for collecting quantitative data
- Categories may not cover all possibilities, some behaviours not recorded so low validity
- Poor design of categories may reduce reliability
Define event sampling
Draw up a list of behavioural categories then count (tally) each time of the behaviours occurs in a specific time period
What are the advantages of event sampling
Event sampling is useful when behaviour to-be-recorded only happens occasionally, missing events would reduce validity
What are the disadvantages of event sampling
Observations may not be representative if list of events is not comprehensive, reduces validity
Define time sampling
- Count behaviours at regular time intervals
- Or take a sample at different times of day or month
What are the advantages of time sampling
Time sampling allows for tracking of time-related changes to behaviour