Landlord & Tenant (Ag) Flashcards
What compensation for improvements is a tenant entitled to at the end of a FBT?
- Tenants improvement they have gained either Landlords (s17) or Arbitrators (s19) written consent for.
- Consent should be obtained before the work is started since otherwise tenant has no right to arbitration. (except routine improvements).
- Compensation for either Intangible Advantage or Physical improvements (long or short term). - Defined in S15!
- Compensation is often calculated on the value of the improvement to the holding (S16).
How are dilapidations dealt with under a FBT?
- Inspect Tenancy Agreement
- If Agricultural (Model Clauses for Fixed Equipment) (Wales) Regulation 2019 are incorporated in full the landlord can;
- Serve a written notice on the tenant requiring him to do work (no prescribed form but must specify the repairs and works).
- If tenant does not serve a counter notice within 1 month, start the work within 2 months or complete the work within 3 months the Landlord can then carry out work himself.
- If Tenant wishes to contest liability, they can serve a counter notice, requiring the question of liability to be determined by Arbitration under the Act.
- LLs right to recover reasonable costs does not happen unless the question of liability is determined by Arbitration or 3rd party determination, in favour of LL.
- Other remedies include s146 of Law of Property Act 1925.
How is compensation for disturbance calculated under an AHA 1986?
- Basic compensation = 1 years rent
- Greater amount of compensation = 2 years rent
- Additional compensation = up to 4 year rent
(Additional compensation is only available on Case B)
At the end of an AHA tenancy, what compensation can the tenant claim for improvements?
- Long term improvements
- Short term improvements
- Tenant right matters
How would the compensation for improvements be calculated at the end of the AHA tenancy?
- Long term improvements = Equal to the increase attributable to the improvement in the value of an ag holding, as a holding.
- Short term improvements = Value to an incoming tenant.
- Tenant right matters = Value to an incoming tenant, calculated in accordance with prescribed regulations.
How can a Landlord claim compensation for dilapidations if Tenant quits AHA Tenancy?
- 1 month prior to the termination of tenancy, LL must serve a s83 notice notifying tenant intention to claim under s72 (general deterioration of holding) confirming intention to claim.
- 2 months prior to termination of tenancy, LL must serve a s83 notice notifying tenant intention to claim under s71 (deterioration of part) confirming intention to claim.
- compensation payable is equal to the decrease attributable to the value of the holding as a holding.
When are the Agriculture (Model Clauses for Fixed Equipment) Regulations 2015 used?
If the tenancy agreement was granted before 1st October 2015 and refers to the 1973 Model Clauses, “as amended or replaced”.
How can a Landlord serve a Notice to Remedy?
- Raise issue with tenant.
- Serve a Case D notice to remedy under Sch 3, s25.
- Notice must give reasonable time to carry out the works (at least 6 months).
- Tenant can dispute notice, by serving a Counter Notice within one month and refer to arbitration.
- If tenant is unsuccessful at Arbitration, LL can serve a NTQ.
- Whatever the outcome of arbitration, the tenant can also (within one month of the arbitrator’s award or service of a notice to quit) serve a counternotice under section 28 of the Act.
- This forces the landlord to apply for consent to operation of the NTQ within one month.
- That means the landlord has to apply to the Tribunal and persuade it that, a fair and reasonable landlord would insist on possession.
How can a Landlord serve a ‘general’ NTQ?
- Under s27, LL can serve a ‘general’ NTQ.
- Tenant can challenge by serving a counter notice (s26 - No prescribed form) within one month.
- LL has one month to apply to the Tribunal (prescribed form - state grounds on which they notice is to have effect).
- Tribunal will then consider the 6 grounds (Good Husbandry/Sound Management of the Estate/Agri research/ Creation of allotments/ Greater Hardship and non agri use).
- Law leans towards tenant, only very limited circumstances that a NTQ under s27 is successful.
- LL must satisfy the Tribunal that the case falls within one of the grounds and a fair and reasonable landlord would insist on possession.
What are the 6 grounds under s27 of the AHA 1986?
- Good husbandry.
- Sound management of the estate.
- Agricultural research.
- Creation of allotments.
- Greater hardship.
- Non-agricultural use.
& a fair and reasonable landlord would insist upon possession!
What section under an FBT allows the tenant right to remove any fixtures?
- s8
How is an AHA rent assessed?
“the rent at which the holding might reasonably be expected to be let by a prudent and willing landlord to a prudent and willing tenant taking into account all relevant factors”.
All relevant factors include:
- Character & situation of the holding
- Terms of the tenancy
- Productive and related earning capacity
- Comparable evidence
- Non agricultural income
How is an FBT Rent assessed?
The basis of a rent review for an FBT;
“The rent at which the holding might reasonably be expected to be let on the open market by a willing landlord to a willing tenant taking into account all relevant factors”.
Relevant factors include:
- Terms of the tenancy
- Location of the holding
How is an AHA rent review conducted?
- Review tenancy agreement.
- Serve a s12 notice (no earlier than 12 and no later than 24 months before review date).
- If agreement cannot be reached before notice expiry date, parties can apply to the President of the CAAV & RICS and Chair of ALA for appointment of an Arbitrator.
- Arbitrator will conduct the rent review inline with s12 and Sch 2 of the Act!
What does productive and related earning capacity mean?
Productive capacity = productive capacity of the holding on the assumption that it’s in occupation of a competent tenant practising a system of farming suitable to the holding.
Related earning capacity = in light of the productive capacity, what a competent tenant practising such a system of farming could reasonably be expected to profit from farming the holding.