Issues and Debates Flashcards
What is the argument around idiographic and nomothetic approaches in psychology?
The argument about whether we should focus on studying the individual, or groups in order to generate general laws that apply to most people
Define the idiographic approach to psychology.
Studying behaviour by focusing on the individual and emphasising unique, subjective experience, doesn’t seek to generalise results.
Define the nomothetic approach to psychology.
Concerned with establishing general laws based on the study of large groups of people.
What are the research methods used by a psychologist taking an idiographic approach?
Case studies, unstructured interviews
What are the research methods used by a psychologist taking a nomothetic approach?
Lab/field/natural/quasi experiments, correlational research, statistical and quantitative methods used to analyse data
What are the weaknesses of taking an idiographic approach to psychological research?
Can’t generalise, Can’t predict behaviour and then prevent/treat it, Lacks scientific rigour (likely to have researcher bias), time consuming
What are the benefits of taking an idiographic approach to psychological research?
Rich and detailed information/understanding, Can develop personalised treatments (CCT)
What are the strengths of taking a nomothetic approach to psychological research?
Can develop treatments/preventative measures + highly scientific
What are the weaknesses of taking a nomothetic approach to psychological research?
studying large groups à lose subjective experience.lots of use of experiments à lacking ecological validity
Often, how are idiographic and nomothetic approaches connected and used in Psychology?
On many occasions, idiographic research can generate ideas which can then be researched on a larger scale using nomothetic methods.
Give an example of an approach in Psychology that uses both idiographic and nomothetic methods.
Psychodynamic or cognitive
Give an example of a piece of idiographic research in Psychology.
Little Hans (psychodynamic/gender), Case studies KF, CW, HM (memory), Genie (attachment)
Which approaches only use nomothetic research?
Biological and Behaviourist
What is the nature nurture debate?
The argument about how much of a particular behaviour is a result of environment and how much is genetic – which has a greater contribution?
Define the nature view in the nature nurture debate.
The view that behaviour is a product of innate, biological factors present at the point of conception.
Define the nurture view in the nature nurture debate.
The view that behaviour is a product of environmental influences (anything outside the body) e.g. people, events, physical world
Which approach takes the extreme nature view?
Biological
Which approach takes the extreme nurture view?
Behaviourist
What are people who subscribe to the nature view called?
Nativists
What are people who subscribe to the nurture view called?
Empiricists
Which/Who’s ideas are ‘nature explanations’ based on?
Darwin, evolution
Which/Who’s ideas are ‘nurture explanations’ based on?
John Locke, born a blank slate
Define heredity. Explain which part of the nature nurture debate it relates to.
Heredity is the process in which traits are passed down from one generation to the next, links to nature
Often, what is the conclusion of any research involved in the nature vs nurture debate?
That we need to take an interactionist approach – nature and nurture overlap to shape human behaviour – separating it is too simplistic.
Give an example of a concept we have studied that takes an extreme nature view.
Bowlby – born programmed to form attachments
Give an example of a concept we have studied that takes an extreme nurture view.
Learning theory of attachment (conditioning)
Give an example of a nature-nurture interactionist concept we have studied.
Diathesis-stress model for Schizophrenia, Depression, OCD, violent offending
What are the strengths of taking an extreme nature view?
+ can identify biological cause à develop biological treatment
What are the weaknesses of taking an extreme nature view?
- ignores possible influence of other important factors (often reductionist)
What are the strengths of taking an extreme nurture view?
+ if behaviour is learnt it can be modified/unlearnt à possible therapies/behaviour modification techniques
What are the weaknesses of taking an extreme nurture view?
- ignores possible influence of biological factors (often reductionist)
What are the responsibilities of governments if all behaviour is a result of nurture? (implication of extreme nurture view)
All children (as this is when key learning takes place) need the same good quality start in life
What are the responsibilities of governments if all behaviour is a result of nature? (implication of extreme nature view)
Need to modify criminal justice system
What is the reductionism holism debate?
Whether we should explain behaviour at the lowest level of explanation possible, or whether we should take into account as many factors as possible when explaining a behaviour.
Define the reductionist view in the RvH debate.
We should break behaviour down into it’s most basic components, breaking down complex issues into simpler elements.
Define the holistic view in the RvH debate.
We should only try to understand a behaviour or individual by examining all possible influences including the subjective experience of the individual.
Explain what is meant by biological reductionism.
Reduce behaviour to a physical level, focusing on neurotransmitters, neurones or hormones
Explain what is meant by environmental reductionism.
Reduce all behaviour to a series of learnt building blocks so complex behaviours are just a chain of stimulus and response associations
Which approaches tend to be reductionist?
Biological, Behaviourist