Intro Flashcards
1
Q
What is science
A
- Bordens & Abbott: a set of methods used to collect information about phenomena in a particular area
- Harrington: an interconnected series of concepts and conceptual schemes that have developed as a result of observation, experimentation and are fruitful of further experimentation.
2
Q
Scientific explanations are:
A
- Empirical (show me the data and controlled)
- Rational
- Testable
- Parsimonious: simple explanation first
- General
- Tentative
- Rigorously evaluated
3
Q
Other types of explanations
A
- pseudoscientific
- common sense explanations
- belief-based
4
Q
Pseudoscientific explanations
A
- Konrad and Lorenz (ethnologist), Sigmund Freud, William McDougall
- aggression is an instinct
- tautology: circular explanation
- aggressive behaviour stems from aggressive instinct, and aggressive instinct causes aggressive behaviour
5
Q
Methods of inquiry
A
- Tenacity
- Intuition
- Faith
- Authority
- Rational
- Empirical
6
Q
Method of tenacity
A
Based on beliefs, habits or superstitions
Belief perseverance
7
Q
Method of intuition
A
Hunch or gut feeling
8
Q
Method of authority
A
- only useful in early stages of research
- from experts
- common in history
9
Q
Rational method
A
- from rationalism
- based on logic
- used in philosophy
- essential in planning of research
10
Q
Empirical method
A
- based on data
- what this course is about
11
Q
Eastern European tradition
A
- dialectic thinking/reasoning (Kant, Hegel, Marx, Engels)
- a method: thesis, antithesis, synthesis
- an explanation for historical: sometimes explains changes in science
12
Q
Dialectic Changes (group selection theory)
A
- early years (thesis): group selection theory
- later years (antithesis): kin selection theory
- modern perspective (synthesis): multi-level selection
- illustrates the move from polarized stances to an even middle
13
Q
Persistence of theories: popper
A
- falsifiability: falsification of scientific data/theories; main method of verification
- his philosophy in science: critical rationalism, falsification
- rejects: classical empiricism, observationalist, or inductivist approach
14
Q
Persistence of theories: Kuhn
A
- paradigms
- theories persist and endure time in unjustified ways sometimes (lack of supporting counter evidence)
- Kuhn: theories die with their theorists
- cause: the massive life-long investment, financial investment, and time and money spent convincing granting agencies etc
15
Q
Persistence of theories: imre lakatos
A
- research programs important in the context of falsification (not theories or hypotheses)
- progressive research programs
- degenerating research programs
- synthesis of popper’s empirical validity focus and Kuhn’s perspective on conventional consistency and persistence