Interpretation tips

Question 1

Introduction phrases

Answer 1

“These interpretations are both examples of the wider historical debate around…”
“The events of……rule needs to be considered in the context of…”
“Both offer interesting explanations for… but interpretation… is more convincing because it offers…..as the main reason for…., in comparison interpretation offers…..”.

Question 2

Interpretation A

Answer 2

Brief summary:
-“States that…”
Why convincing?
-“Convincing because” “This point is especially convincing as…”. “Supported by the fact that”.
Why not convincing?
-“However, this interpretation neglects to mention…”, “This is a simplification of the reality…”.
“Whilst there is some truth in this point, it must also be mentioned that…”, More emphasis/less emphasis should be given to this point as…”.
More/less convincing than A.

Question 3

Interpretation B

Answer 3

• Brief summary.
• Why convincing
• Why not convincing
• Why more/less convincing than A.

Question 4

Conclusion

Answer 4

Overall judgement on ruler.
“Overall, the rule of…. was a time of”- This context is essential to understand these interpretations.
“Interpretation…is more convincing because…”.

Question 5

Overall tips

Answer 5

Checklist:

• Focus on question throughout.
• Thorough an sustained evaluation on interpretations.
• Use detail and knowledge of historical context.
• Discuss wider historical context.
• Discuss wider historical debate around issue.

Process:

• Read both once, then once again making bullet points-4 or 5 per interpretation.
• Decide which you find more convincing using knowledge of period.
• Plan answer-bits of knowledge to support/contradict each.
• Write about both equally.