IER. Final Exam Flashcards
Introduction to IER
List and explain key reasons for the development of the global economy.
Technological advances:
Information and Communication Technologies (ICT). The development of ICT has revolutionised global communication, transport and trade. The Internet, mobile devices and advanced logistics systems have facilitated the flow of information, goods and services across borders, enabling seamless global trade and collaboration.
Transport infrastructure. Improvements in transport infrastructure, such as containerization and air transport, have significantly reduced the costs and time of international trade. These advances have fueled the development of global supply chains in which production is distributed across multiple countries, promoting economic efficiency and specialisation.
Production processes. Technological advances in manufacturing and manufacturing have led to increased automation, efficiency, and productivity, allowing countries to produce goods at lower costs and higher quality. This has made global trade more attractive and competitive, stimulating economic growth and development.
Economic policies:
Trade liberalisation: The removal of trade barriers such as tariffs and quotas has facilitated trade flows and promoted economic integration. International trade agreements such as the World Trade Organization (WTO) have played a critical role in reducing trade barriers and promoting global trade.
Financial integration: Liberalisation of capital markets and development of financial systems have made cross-border investments and financial flows possible. This has facilitated the movement of capital, technology and expertise, promoting economic growth and innovation.
Economic reforms: Many countries have implemented economic reforms such as privatisation, deregulation and market-oriented policies to improve their competitiveness in the global economy. These reforms increased economic efficiency and attracted foreign direct investment (FDI), promoting economic growth.
Geopolitical shifts:
Globalisation: The rise of globalisation has facilitated the interconnection of economies, cultures and societies around the world. This led to increased trade, investment and cultural exchange, shaping the modern global economy.
The rise of emerging markets: The emergence of new economic powers such as China and India has changed the global economic landscape. These countries have become major players in international trade, finance and technological innovation, challenging the dominance of traditional developed economies.
Regionalization: The formation of regional trading blocs such as the European Union and the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) has deepened economic integration within regions. These blocs promote trade liberalisation, investment flows and economic cooperation among member countries.
Introduction to IER
Explain the concepts of globalisation and internationalisation. What are the differences?
Internationalisation - The growing tendency of corporations to operate across national boundaries
■National enterprises versus International enterprises versus Multinational enterprises (MNEs)
■ Licensing and Franchising
■ Foreign Direct Investments (FDI)
Globalization - The worldwide movement toward economic, financial, trade, and communications integration.
Globalization implies the opening of local and nationalistic perspectives to a broader outlook of an interconnected and interdependent world with free transfer of capital, goods, and services across national frontiers. However, it does not include unhindered movement of labor and, as suggested by some economists, may hurt smaller or fragile economies if applied indiscriminately.”
Key Differences:
Scope:
Globalization has a broader scope, encompassing various aspects of global interconnectedness beyond business activities.
Internalization specifically focuses on a company’s expansion into foreign markets.
Drivers:
Globalization is driven by factors such as technology, trade liberalization, and cultural exchange on a global scale.
Internalization is driven by strategic considerations specific to a company’s desire to control, coordinate, and expand its operations in foreign markets.
Context:
Globalization is a macro-level phenomenon involving the integration of economies, cultures, and societies.
Internalization is a micro-level strategy used by individual companies to expand their operations internationally.
Introduction to IER
Discuss the most important positive effects of globalisation. Provide examples.
1. Decentralised Production: Different parts of a product can be manufactured in various regions of the world, facilitating decentralised production. The automotive industry is cited as an example of this practice.
2. Outsourcing Opportunities: Businesses, particularly in the United States, can distribute services such as call centres and information technology to countries with cost-effective labour, such as India.
3. Job Creation: Globalisation, driven by trade agreements like NAFTA, can lead to the relocation of manufacturing operations, creating more jobs in countries with lower labour costs and positively impacting national economies.
4. Improved Living Standards:Certain countries, like China and Vietnam, have experienced increased income from globalisation, contributing to poverty reduction and an overall improvement in living standards.
5. Lower Manufacturing Costs:Globalisation decreases the cost of manufacturing, allowing companies to offer goods at lower prices to consumers.
6.Access to a Variety of Goods: Consumers benefit from globalisation by gaining access to a wider variety of goods, contributing to an improved standard of living.
Introduction to IER
Discuss the most important negative effects of globalisation. Provide examples.
1. Job Loss in Developed Countries: Workers in developed nations may face job competition from lower-cost markets, leading to potential job loss and decreased job security.
2. Exploitative Working Conditions in Developing Countries: The rapid economic changes in developing nations may lead to deplorable working conditions, as seen in the example of the clothing industry in Bangladesh, where workers earn significantly less than their counterparts in developed countries.
3. Tragic Consequences: Incidents like the 2013 textile factory building collapse in Bangladesh, resulting in over 1,100 worker deaths, highlight the tragic consequences of poor working conditions associated with globalisation.
4. Child Labour Concerns: Globalisation may increase the negative impacts of child labour in poor countries, as employment opportunities for children may lure them away from schools, perpetuating a cycle of poverty.
5. Income Inequality:Globalisation may contribute to income disparity and inequality within societies. For example, while China has experienced remarkable economic growth, income inequality has also risen. Disparities between urban and rural areas, as well as between coastal and inland regions, contribute to income inequality challenges.
Trade and Trade Theories
What are the major causes for the rapid development of international trade? Give examples.
1. Differences in Technology-Advantageous trade can occur between countries if the countries differ in their technological abilities to produce goods and services. Ex:China and Germany can benefit from trade based on their respective comparative advantages. China, with its vast manufacturing capabilities, can produce consumer goods efficiently and at scale. Germany, with its advanced technology and precision engineering, can produce high-tech goods. Through trade, both countries can access goods that they can produce more efficiently than the other, leading to overall economic gains.
2. Differences in Resource Endowments-Advantageous trade can occur between countries if the countries differ in their endowments of resources. Ex:Ethiopia benefits from trading its abundant coffee resources for high-quality machinery produced by Germany. Germany benefits by accessing a crucial resource it lacks for its industries. Through trade, both countries optimise their resource utilisation and enhance overall economic welfare.
3. Differences in Demand-Advantageous trade can occur between countries if demands or preferences differ between countries. Individuals in different countries may have different preferences or demands for various products. The Chinese are likely to demand more rice than Americans, even if facing the same price. Canadians may demand more beer, the Dutch more wooden shoes, and the Japanese more fish than Americans would, even if they all faced the same prices.
4. Existence of Economies of Scale in Production-The existence of economies of scale in production is sufficient to generate advantageous trade between two countries. Economies of scale refer to a production process in which production costs fall as the scale of production rises. For example, China has a comparative advantage in producing textiles due to its large labor force and low labor costs. This has led to China becoming a major exporter of textiles to countries around the world.
5. Existence of Government Policies-Government tax and subsidy programs can be sufficient to generate advantages in production of certain products. In these circumstances, advantageous trade may arise solely due to differences in government policies across countries.
Example : Renewable Energy Subsidies:
Germany:Substantial subsidies for solar panels and wind turbines; Aiming to lead in the renewable energy sector
United States:Variable policies on renewable energy subsidies; May import solar panels and wind turbines.
Outcome: Advantageous Trade: Germany: Exports renewable energy technologies. United States: Imports to meet domestic demand.
Trade and Trade Theories
What challenges do countries face nowadays in their trade relations because of the COVID-19 pandemic and the Russia-Ukraine war? Provide examples.
Challenges Due to COVID-19 Pandemic:
Disruptions in Supply Chains: Lockdowns, restrictions, and disruptions caused by the pandemic have led to significant interruptions in global supply chains. This has affected the production and availability of goods and services.
Reduced Consumer Demand: Economic uncertainties, job losses, and changes in consumer behaviour during the pandemic have led to reduced demand for various products, impacting international trade.
Travel Restrictions: Restrictions on international travel have hampered the movement of people, affecting business travel, tourism, and the ability of companies to manage global operations effectively.
Logistical Challenges: Transportation and logistics have been adversely affected due to restrictions, leading to delays in the shipment of goods and increased transportation costs.
Tariff and Trade Policy Uncertainties: Governments may implement protectionist measures or change trade policies in response to the economic challenges posed by the pandemic, creating uncertainties for businesses engaged in international trade.
Challenges Due to Russia-Ukraine War:
Geopolitical Tensions and Sanctions: The conflict between Russia and Ukraine has led to geopolitical tensions, and several countries have imposed sanctions on Russia. These sanctions can impact international trade and economic relations.
Energy Supply Concerns: Russia is a significant exporter of natural gas and oil. The conflict has raised concerns about the stability of energy supplies, affecting countries dependent on Russian energy exports.
Disruption of Regional Trade: The war has led to disruptions in regional trade flows, particularly in Eastern Europe. Businesses may face challenges in accessing markets and maintaining stable trade relations in the affected regions.
Currency Volatility: Geopolitical tensions can lead to currency fluctuations, affecting the costs and prices of goods in international trade. Businesses may face challenges in managing currency risks.
Uncertainty for Investors: Geopolitical conflicts create uncertainty for investors, impacting investment decisions and potentially leading to a slowdown in economic activity.
Trade and Trade Theories
What are the major disadvantages of international trade for different economic actors? Give examples.
Impediment in the Development of Home Industries: International trade has an adverse effect on the development of home industries. It poses a threat to the survival of infant industries at home. Due to foreign competition and unrestricted imports, the upcoming industries in the country may collapse.
Economic Dependence: The underdeveloped countries have to depend upon the developed ones for their economic development. Such reliance often leads to economic exploitation. For instance, most of the underdeveloped countries in Africa and Asia have been exploited by European countries(Congo was exploited by Belgium: King Leopold II’s rule led to brutal exploitation for rubber extraction, causing significant loss of life)
Political Dependence: International trade often encourages subjugation and slavery. It impairs economic independence which endangers political dependence. For example, the Britishers came to India as traders and ultimately ruled over India for a very long time.
Mis-utilisation of Natural Resources: Excessive exports may exhaust the natural resources of a country in a shorter span of time than it would have been otherwise. This will cause economic downfall of the country in the long run.
Deterioration of Environment: Higher levels of production can often negatively influence the quality of environment, e.g. due to pollution, soil and water contamination etc. This happens especially in low developed countries, where there are no clean technologies implemented.
Import of Harmful Goods: Import of spurious drugs, luxury articles, etc. adversely affects the economy and well-being of the people.
Storage of Goods: Sometimes the essential commodities required in a country and in short supply are also exported to earn foreign exchange. This results in shortage of these goods at home and causes inflation. For example, India has been exporting sugar to earn foreign trade exchange; hence the exalting prices of sugar in the country.
Danger to International Peace: International trade gives an opportunity to foreign agents to settle down in the country which ultimately endangers its internal peace.
World Wars / Trade Wars: International trade breeds rivalries amongst nations due to competition in the foreign markets. This may eventually lead to wars and disturb world peace.
Hardships in times of War: International trade promotes lopsided development of a country as only those goods which have comparative cost advantage are produced in a country. During wars or when good relations do not prevail between nations, many hardships may follow.
Trade and Trade Theories
What are the major advantages of international trade for different economic actors? Give examples.
Optimal use of natural resources: International trade helps each country to make optimum use of its natural resources. Each country can concentrate on production of those goods for which its resources are best suited. Wastage of resources is avoided.
Availability of all types of goods: It enables a country to obtain goods which it cannot produce or which it is not producing due to higher costs, by importing from other countries at lower costs.
Specialisation: Foreign trade leads to specialisation and encourages production of different goods in different countries. Goods can be produced at a comparatively low cost due to advantages of division of labour.Example:(Middle Eastern countries:Oil production; Germany and Japan:Automibile industry etc.)
Advantages of large-scale production (economies of scale): Due to international trade, goods are produced not only for home consumption but for export to other countries also. Nations of the world can dispose of goods which they have in surplus in the international markets. This leads to production at large scale and the advantages of large scale production can be obtained by all the countries of the world.
Stability in prices: International trade irons out wild fluctuations in prices. It equalises the prices of goods throughout the world (ignoring cost of transportation, etc.)
Exchange of technical know-how and establishment of new industries: Underdeveloped countries can establish and develop new industries with the machinery, equipment and technical know-how imported from developed countries. This helps in the development of these countries and the economy of the world at large.Example: South Korea shared technical expertise with Vietnam, supporting industrialization. Impact: Facilitated the growth of manufacturing and technology sectors.
Increase in efficiency: Due to international competition, the producers in a country attempt to produce better quality goods and at the minimum possible cost. This increases the efficiency and benefits to the consumers all over the world.
Development of the means of transport and communication: International trade requires the best means of transport and communication. For the advantages of international trade, development in the means of transport and communication is also made possible.Example:Panama Canal: Facilitates maritime trade by providing a shortcut for ships traveling between the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans.
International cooperation and understanding: The people of different countries come in contact with each other. Commercial intercourse amongst nations of the world encourages exchange of ideas and culture. It creates co-operation, understanding, cordial relations amongst various nations.
Ability to face natural calamities: Natural calamities such as drought, floods, famine, earthquake etc., affect the production of a country adversely. Deficiency in the supply of goods at the time of such natural calamities can be met by imports from other countries. Example: Turkey 2023 earthquake etc.
Other advantages: International trade helps in many other ways such as benefits to consumers, international peace and better standard of living.
Trade and Trade Theories
Explain the reasons for international trade based on classical theories of international trade. Provide pros and cons/strengths and weaknesses of the theories.
Adam Smith’s Theory of Absolute Advantage
Adam Smith’s 1776 book, “The Wealth of Nations,” introduced the notion of absolute advantage as a basis for international trade. Smith argued that countries should specialize in producing the goods they can produce more efficiently than other countries and export those goods in exchange for goods that other countries can produce more efficiently. This specialization allows each country to enjoy a higher standard of living than if it tried to produce everything itself.
David Ricardo’s Theory of Comparative Advantage
David Ricardo’s 1817 book, “On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation,” refined the concept of absolute advantage by introducing the idea of comparative advantage. Ricardo recognized that even if a country is absolutely more efficient at producing all goods, it can still gain from trade by specializing in the goods in which it has a comparative advantage, meaning it can produce those goods at a lower opportunity cost compared to other countries.
Pros and Cons of Classical Theories of International Trade
Strengths:
Focus on efficiency and specialization: Classical theories highlight the economic benefits of trade through specialization and the pursuit of comparative advantage.
Universality: The concepts of absolute and comparative advantage apply to all countries, regardless of their level of development or resources.
Simplicity: Classical theories are relatively easy to understand and explain, making them accessible to policymakers and the general public.
Weaknesses:
Static perspective: Classical theories provide a static view of trade, focusing on the allocation of resources at a given point in time. They do not consider the dynamic effects of trade on innovation, technology, and growth.
Neglect of non-economic factors: Classical theories primarily focus on economic gains from trade, overlooking non-economic factors such as culture, politics, and environmental considerations.
Limited applicability to modern trade: Classical theories have been criticized for their assumptions of perfect competition, free mobility of labor, and constant returns to scale, which may not fully reflect the realities of modern international trade.
Trade and Trade Theories
Explain the reasons for international trade based on the factor endowment theory of international trade (H-O). Provide pros and cons/strengths and weaknesses of the theory.
Reasons for International Trade (H-O Theory):
Factor Abundance: Countries have different factor endowments, such as labor, capital, and natural resources.
Comparative Cost Differences: Countries will specialize in and export goods that use their abundant factors, leading to lower production costs.
Trade Imbalance: Countries will import goods that use factors in which they are relatively scarce, taking advantage of comparative cost differences.
Pros/Strengths of H-O Theory:
Explanatory Power: Provides a logical explanation for why countries trade based on differences in factor endowments.
Predictive Value: Can predict patterns of trade based on relative factor abundance.
Empirical Support: Some empirical evidence supports the theory, particularly in explaining trade patterns between developed and developing countries.
Cons/Weaknesses of H-O Theory:
Homogeneous Factors Assumption: Assumes factors of production are homogeneous within each category (e.g., all labor is the same), which oversimplifies real-world complexities.
Neglects Technological Differences: Ignores technological differences between countries, which can significantly impact production efficiency.
Static Nature: H-O theory is static and doesn’t account for changes over time, such as technological advancements or shifts in factor endowments.
Ignores Non-factor Determinants: Disregards non-factor determinants of trade, such as government policies, transportation costs, and economies of scale.
Doesn’t Explain Intra-industry Trade: Struggles to explain the phenomenon of intra-industry trade, where countries exchange similar types of goods within the same industry.
Trade and Trade Theories
Explain the reasons for international trade based on the country similarity theory of international trade. Provide pros and cons/strengths and weaknesses of the theory.
Reasons for International Trade (Country Similarity Theory):
Consumer Preferences: Countries with similar income levels and preferences are more likely to demand similar types of goods.
Product Quality and Standards: Countries with similar income levels often have similar standards for product quality and safety, facilitating trade between them.
Geographical Proximity: Countries with similar income levels and preferences are more likely to be geographically closer, reducing transportation costs and making trade more feasible.
Pros/Strengths of Country Similarity Theory:
Consumer-Centric Explanation:Focuses on consumer preferences, providing a consumer-centric explanation for trade patterns.
Intuitive Logic: The idea that countries with similar income levels and tastes will trade more is intuitively logical and aligns with observed trade patterns in certain industries.
Reflects Real-world Observations: The theory aligns with the observation that countries with similar income levels often engage in significant trade, particularly in industries catering to consumer preferences.
Cons/Weaknesses of Country Similarity Theory:
Neglects Comparative Advantage: Doesn’t explicitly consider comparative advantage or factor endowments as determinants of trade, overlooking other important factors.
Static Nature: Like some other classical theories, it tends to be static and doesn’t account for changes over time, such as evolving consumer preferences or shifts in comparative advantage.
Not Universally Applicable: The theory may not apply universally to all industries or types of goods, as factors other than consumer preferences also influence trade.
Trade and Trade Theories
Explain the reasons for international trade based on the new trade theory of international trade. Provide pros and cons/strengths and weaknesses of the theory.
Reasons for International Trade (New Trade Theory):
Economies of Scale: Countries engage in international trade to exploit economies of scale by producing larger quantities for both domestic and export markets.
Product Differentiation: International trade allows countries to access a wider variety of differentiated goods and services that may not be available domestically.
Imperfect Competition: Imperfect competition provides opportunities for firms to expand their market share by engaging in international trade, where they may face less competition.
Pros/Strengths of New Trade Theory:
Expands Scope of Traditional Theories: NTT expands the scope of traditional theories by considering factors such as economies of scale and imperfect competition, which were not adequately addressed in classical theories.
Explains Intra-industry Trade: Unlike classical theories, NTT can explain the phenomenon of intra-industry trade, where countries trade similar types of goods within the same industry.
Product Variety and Consumer Choice: Recognizes the importance of product variety and how international trade contributes to greater consumer choice through the availability of differentiated goods.
Cons/Weaknesses of New Trade Theory:
Data Requirements: NTT often requires detailed data on firm-level behaviour and product differentiation, making it challenging to apply in certain contexts where such data may be limited.
Less Prescriptive: While NTT provides insights into why trade occurs, it is less prescriptive about policy recommendations compared to classical theories.
Doesn’t Explain All Trade Patterns: NTT may not explain all trade patterns, and other factors, such as comparative advantage and factor endowments, still play a role in certain industries.
First mover andvantage and economies of scale
The reason for trade: economis of scale, specialisation, greater variety for lower prices
+ nations may benefit from trade even withour absolute advantage
+
Trade and Trade Theories
Explain the reasons for international trade based on the international product life-cycle theory of international trade. Provide pros and cons/strengths and weaknesses of the theory.
Reasons for International Trade (IPLC Theory):
Introduction Stage: New products are introduced in the home country where they are developed. Initially, there is minimal international trade as the product is unique to the home country.
Growth Stage: As the product gains acceptance, demand increases, and production expands. International trade begins to grow as the home country starts exporting the product.
Maturity Stage: The product reaches maturity, and standardised production processes are established. Production becomes more cost-effective, leading to increased international trade, with exports from the home country and the establishment of foreign production facilities.
Decline Stage: The product becomes mature and faces declining demand in the home country. The home country may reduce production, but international trade may continue if the product finds new markets abroad.
Pros/Strengths of IPLC Theory:
Predictive Value: The IPLC theory helps explain the evolving patterns of international trade, especially for products with distinct life cycles.
Innovation Focus: It highlights the role of innovation and technological advancements in driving international trade.
Strategic Decision-Making: Businesses can use the IPLC theory to make strategic decisions regarding when and where to invest in production facilities or enter new markets.
Cons/Weaknesses of IPLC Theory:
Assumption of Home Country Innovation: The theory assumes that innovation originates only in the home country, which may not be accurate in today’s globalised and collaborative research environment.
Neglect of Non-Traditional Products: The IPLC theory is more applicable to traditional manufactured goods and may not effectively explain the trade patterns of services or rapidly evolving industries like technology.
Changing Dynamics: In a fast-paced global economy, the life cycle of products may be shorter, and the theory may not capture the dynamic shifts in international trade patterns.
+: was good for explanation of 1960s-1970s American economy.
-: doesn’t explain trade now. Products are produced in various countries and are introduced in multiple countries simultaniosly
Trade and Trade Theories
Explain the reasons for international trade based on the theory of competitive advantage of nations. Provide pros and cons/strengths and weaknesses of the theory.
Reasons for International Trade (Competitive Advantage of Nations):
Reasons for International Trade (Competitive Advantage of Nations):
Factor Endowments:: Nations trade to leverage their unique factor endowments, exporting goods and services for which they have a comparative advantage based on their resource endowments.
Demand Conditions: Access to a demanding domestic market encourages firms to improve their products, making them competitive in international markets.
Related and Supporting Industries: Industries benefit from the presence of a strong supporting infrastructure, and nations can specialise in industries where a supporting network exists.
Firm Strategy, Structure, and Rivalry:: Nations engage in international trade to expose their firms to global competition, encouraging them to improve strategies, structures, and efficiency.
Pros/Strengths of Competitive Advantage of Nations:
Holistic Approach: The model takes a holistic approach, considering multiple factors that contribute to a nation’s competitive advantage, making it comprehensive.
Dynamic Perspective: Recognizes the dynamic nature of competitiveness and emphasises the role of continuous improvement, innovation, and adaptability.
Policy Implications: Provides policymakers with insights into the importance of creating a conducive environment for industries to thrive, focusing on factors beyond labour and resources.
Cons/Weaknesses of Competitive Advantage of Nations:
Complexity: The model can be complex and may require detailed data and analysis, making it challenging to apply universally.
Static Assumptions: While it recognizes the dynamic nature of competitiveness, the model may still be criticised for not fully capturing rapid changes in global markets and technology.
Empirical Challenges: Empirical testing and validation of the model can be challenging due to the multitude of factors involved and the need for comprehensive data.
Trade and Trade Theories
Which theory explains international trade in the clearest and most complex way? Explain your opinion.
Trade policy
Give and explain arguments for trade protectionism. Provide some empirical examples.
Protect sunrise industries-Barriers to trade can be used to protect sunrise industries, also known as infant industries, such as those involving new technologies. This gives new firms the chance to develop, grow, and become globally competitive.
Protection of domestic industries may allow them to develop a comparative advantage. For example, domestic firms may expand when protected from competition and benefit from economies of scale. As firms grow, they may invest in real and human capital and develop new capabilities and skills. Once these skills and capabilities are developed there is less need for trade protection, and barriers may be eventually removed.
Protect sunset industries
At the other end of the scale are sunset industries, also known as declining industries, which might need some support to enable them to decline slowly, and avoid some of the negative effects of such decline. Example: For the UK, each generation throws up its own declining industries, such as ship building in the 1950s, car production in the 1970s, and steel production in the 1990s.
Protect strategic industries
Barriers may also be erected to protect strategic industries, such as energy, water, steel, armaments, and food. Example:The implicit aim of the EUs Common Agricultural Policy is to create food security for Europe by protecting its agricultural sector.
Protect non-renewable resources
Non-renewable resources, including oil, are regarded as a special case where the normal rules of free trade are often abandoned.Example:For countries aiming to rely on oil exports lasting into the long term, such as the oil-rich Middle Eastern economies, limiting output in the short term through production quotas is one method employed to conserve resources.
Deter unfair competition
Barriers may be erected to deter unfair competition, such as dumping by foreign firms at prices below cost.
Save jobs
Protecting an industry may, in the short run, protect jobs, though in the long run it is unlikely that jobs can be protected indefinitely.Example:The U.S. implemented tariffs on steel and aluminium in 2018 to protect domestic producers and preserve jobs in those industries.
Help the environment
Some countries may protect themselves from trade to help limit damage to their environment, such as that arising from CO2 emissions caused by increased production and transportation.Example: The European Union imposes restrictions on imports that don’t comply with its environmental standards.
Limit over-specialisation
Many economists point to the dangers of over-specialisation, which might occur as a result of taking the theory of comparative advantage to its extreme. Retaining some self-sufficiency is seen as a sensible economic strategy given the risks of global downturns, and an over- reliance on international trade.
In addition to the economic arguments for protection, some protection may be for political reasons.
more examples
Some real-world examples of protectionism are the EU Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) for protecting domestic farmers in the EU, the Banana War which lasted for 20 years where the EU imposed tariffs on the imports of Bananas from Latin America, and the USA’s use of tariffs on the imports of Tyres from China.
Trade policy
Give and explain arguments against trade protectionism. Provide some empirical examples.
Misallocation of resources
It leads to global misallocation of resources, as it supports inefficient producers and in certain cases (tariffs and quotas) consumer surplus is scarified.Example:The U.S. maintains tariffs and quotas on sugar imports to protect domestic sugar producers.This protectionist policy can lead to overproduction of sugar domestically, even in regions where it may not be the most efficient use of resources.
The danger of retaliation and “trade wars”
Continuous protectionist measures by a country might lead to retaliation of other countries and they might also put protectionist measures on the imports.Example: the Banana War which lasted for 20 years where the EU imposed tariffs on the imports of Bananas from Latin America, and the USA’s use of tariffs on the imports of Tyres from China.
The potential for corruption
Putting administrative controls might also lead to corruption.
Increased costs of production due to lack of competition:
Constant protection to the domestic producers and lack of competition propagates inefficiency and lack of initiative to control cost.
Higher prices for domestic consumers
As we can see due to tariffs and quotas domestic consumers end up paying more.
Increased costs of imported factors of production
Imported goods become expensive which might also lead to imported inflation.
Reduced export competitiveness
Continuous protection to domestic industries (such as subsidies) might make them inefficient in terms of cost and technology. In the long run they might become uncompetitive in the exports market.
Trade policy
What are the most common instruments of trade protection in the XXI century? Give examples based on trade policies of different countries.
Tariffs: Tariffs are taxes levied on imported goods. They raise the price of imported goods, making them less competitive with domestically produced goods. Tariffs are a relatively straightforward way to protect domestic industries, but they can also raise consumer prices and lead to retaliatory tariffs from other countries.
Example: The United States has imposed tariffs on a variety of goods from China, including steel, aluminum, and solar panels.
Quotas: Quotas limit the quantity of goods that can be imported. They are similar to tariffs in that they make imported goods more expensive, but they can be even more effective at protecting domestic industries because they prevent foreign producers from flooding the market with their goods. Quotas can also be more difficult to enforce than tariffs.
Example: The European Union has imposed quotas on the import of cars from Japan.
Subsidies: Subsidies are government payments to domestic producers to help them compete with foreign producers. Subsidies can be given directly to producers, or they can be provided in the form of tax breaks or other incentives. Subsidies can distort competition and make it difficult for foreign producers to compete.
Example: The United States government provides subsidies to farmers.
Anti-dumping duties: Anti-dumping duties are taxes imposed on goods that are imported at less than their fair market value. They are designed to protect domestic industries from unfair competition from foreign producers who are dumping their goods on the market.
Example: The United States has imposed anti-dumping duties on imported washing machines from China.
Voluntary export restraints (VERs): VERs are agreements between a foreign producer and the government of an importing country to limit the quantity of goods that can be exported. VERs are less common than other forms of trade protection, but they can be effective in protecting domestic industries.
Example: Japan imposed VERs on the export of automobiles to the United States in the 1980s.
Trade policy
What prevails today – free trade or protectionism? Explain your opinion, based on 4 convincing arguments.
In today’s globalized economy, both free trade and protectionism continue to play significant roles in shaping international trade policies. While there is a general trend towards free trade, protectionism remains a prominent force, particularly in certain industries and countries.
Free Trade’s Economic Benefits: Free trade advocates emphasize its positive impact on economic growth, consumer welfare, and global efficiency. By removing trade barriers, countries can specialize in producing goods and services where they have a comparative advantage, leading to lower prices, improved quality, and wider consumer choices. This increased efficiency translates into overall economic gains.
Globalization and International Cooperation: Free trade is a cornerstone of globalization, fostering economic interdependence and cooperation among nations. Trade agreements and institutions like the World Trade Organization (WTO) facilitate the exchange of goods, services, and capital, promoting cross-border collaboration and knowledge sharing. This interconnectedness can lead to technological advancements, innovation, and overall economic progress.
Competition and Innovation: Free trade encourages competition between domestic and foreign producers, driving innovation and efficiency. In a competitive market, businesses must constantly strive to improve their products, processes, and services to stay ahead of the curve. This competitive pressure stimulates innovation, leading to higher-quality goods at lower prices.
Consumer Welfare and Choice: Free trade expands consumer choice by providing access to a wider range of products and services from different countries. Consumers can benefit from lower prices, better quality, and diverse options, leading to increased satisfaction and overall consumer welfare.
Trade policy
Explain the reasons for and consequences of the economic war between the US and China.
Causes of the Trade War:
Intellectual Property Theft and Technology Transfer: China’s unfair trade practices, including intellectual property theft and force technology transfer threaten high-wage jobs and high-value-added manufacturing in the U.S.
China’s Economic Model and State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs): China’s economic model, characterised by state control and support for its globally dominant SOEs challenges fair competition in the global market, affecting international trade norms.
Protectionist Policies and Violation of WTO Commitments: China’s protectionist policies and unwillingness to give market access for its own companies. It leads to uneven playing fields, hindering global trade norms and creating economic tensions.
Exchange Rate Policy and Undervalued Renminbi:China’s devalued exchange rate imposing an import tariff and export subsidies. It Influenced global trade flows, posing challenges for trade partners and competitors.
Consequences of the Trade War:
Tariffs and Consumer Impact: Tariffs raised prices and negatively affected American consumers.
Ineffectiveness of Phase-One Trade Deal: The Phase-one trade deal failed to reduce China’s tariffs and non-tariff barriers. Deal was unable to address key issues and potential harm to other countries.
Reshaping Global Trade Dynamics: The trade war is reshaping global trade dynamics, with companies relocating and supply chains adjusting. The trade war’s consequences extend beyond bilateral relations, impacting the structure of global trade.
+
An economic conflict between China and the United States has been ongoing since January 2018, when U.S. President Donald Trump began setting tariffs and other trade barriers on China with the goal of forcing it to make changes to what the U.S. says are longstanding unfair trade practices and intellectual property theft. China retaliated with imposing more tariffs on the US. When Biden’s administration came into power, they started cooperating with Taiwan, South Korea and Japan, which also had an aim of decreasing China’s power. Biden’s strategy is to cut the exports of microchips in China. Trade war greatly affected businesses in the US as China’s main export consists of intermediate goods and the tariffs on them are paid by importers. Consumers are also greatly affected as with lesser international competition home companies can increase prices and not develop the technology.