Historical Views of Mental Health Flashcards
What were old methods of Treating Disorders ?
- Restraining devices
- Trepanning: to let evil spirits out
- Psychosurgery: remove or change parts of the brain (lobotomy)
- Electro-conclusive therapy
What are Newer treatments of treating disorders ?
- Prescription drugs
- Talking cures
- Cognitive behavioural therapy
What 4 types of definition for abnormality did Stratton and Hayes identify ?
- Statistical Infrequency
- Deviation from Social Norms
- Failure to function adequately
- Deviation from Ideal Mental Health
How does Statistical infrequency define abnormality ?
- Behaviours which are statistically infrequent
- Rare is abnormal
- Implies there is a normal curve for behaviours
What is the problem with using Statistical infrequency to define abnormality ?
-Doesn’t take into account desirability (own choice)
How does Deviation from social norms define abnormality. ?
- Breaking society’s standard of norms
- Abnormal behaviour violates society’s rules
What are criticisms of Deviation from social norms defining abnormality ?
- Who decides the social norms ?
- Different cultures have different rules
- Social norms change over time
- Expectations of men and women differ
How does Failure to function adequately define abnormality ?
- Failure to experience the normal range of emotions or behaviour
- Includes:dysfunctional behaviour, personal distress, observer discomfort, unpredictable behaviour and irrational behaviour.
What is the problem with Failure to function adequately defining abnormality ?
- Someone has to observe the behaviour (subjective)
- Hard to agree on the boundaries that define ‘functioning adequately’ - leading to inconsistency
- Are such things only indicative of poor mental health? Lack of employment could be due to poor education.
How does Deviation from ideal mental health define abnormality ?
- People should possess certain characteristics in order to be normal
- Positive view of self
- Having self discipline, act independently
- Positive social interactions
What is the problem with Deviation from ideal mental health defining abnormality ?
- Very subjective
- How positive do you have to be to normal
- We will all deviate from good mental health at some points in our lives – grief, stress, anger, love – but this is normal behaviour, not abnormal
What did Rosenhan and Seligman 1989 add about Deviation from ideal mental health defining abnormality?
- Suffering – the person has negative consequences to their behaviour.
- Maladaptiveness – not fitting in with society and maintaining normal social contacts.
- Unconventional behaviour – something that wouldn’t be expected in society
- Irrationality in behaviours that others wouldn’t be able to understand
- Unpredictability/loss of control that is not what we would expect.
- Observer discomfort due to the behaviour
- Violation of moral standards – where behaviour fails to meet the standards set by society.
What is Cultural Relativism ?
-Acceptable in one culture but not in another
What is Maladaptive ?
-Not fitting in with society
Which 2 Methods are used to categorise Mental Health ?
- DSM-V
- ICD-10
What does ICD-10 tell us about Mental Health?
- Each disorder has a description of the main features, and any important associated features.
- Each disorder is then given a code.
What does DSM-V tell us about Mental Health ?
- DSM is a multi-axial tool.
- Clinicians have to consider if a disorder is from Axis 1 (clinical disorders) and/or Axis 2 (personality disorders).
- Then the general medical condition of the patient is considered, plus any social and environmental problems.
What are the positives of DSM-V and ICD-10 ?
- Both generally accepted to be valid
- Encourage consistency
- DSM = more holistic, considers different factors (the axes)
- ICD – publication can look at the individual as a whole
- Both are constantly being updated