Health, Illness and Society Flashcards
What are the characteristics of social anthropology?
Interdisciplinarity, holism, non-judgemental, disaggregative, cultural perspective, local and global interest, individuals/populations/groups/societies, methodological pluralism with innovation and sensitivity, comparative, historical, language/symbols/rituals/narrative
How is medical anthropology interdisciplinary?
Looks and bioscientific epidemiology, the construction of knowledge, the politics of science, norms and institutions, and globalisation
What were some of the earliest examples of medical anthropology?
Pre WW2, W.H.R Rivers looked at Medicine, Magic and Religion. Also Ackerknecht looked at ‘primitive medicine’/ethnomedicine
What is ethnomedicine?
Relating to disease that are products of indigenous cultural development
What are culture bound syndromes?
Locality specific problems such as Hikikomori (Japan), voodoo death, cannibal compulsion, agoraphobia (Western)
How did medical anthropology develop post WW2?
International public health and community health development. Kleinman used term ‘clinical anthropology’
What is the diversification of medical anthropology?
Organisationally/nationally-internationally/multi-disciplinarity/theoretically
What are the three health definitions?
Disease (medical experts view), illness (patients view) and sickness (society’s view)
What are diseases?
Abnormalities in structure/function of body organs or systems. Pathology, biomedically diagnosed and treated. Eg cystic fibrosis has both genetic and environmental factors, and is a biochemical dysfunction
What is Dingwall’s view of disease?
‘there are no…diseases in nature’ it is a social construction
What is Eisenberg’s view of illness?
Illness is experiences of disvalued changed in states of being/social function
What are illnesses?
People have illnesses where organs have diseases. Illnesses are the movement from independence to dependence. They are influenced by social and economic factors. Cystic fibrosis sufferers have the same disease but different illnesses due to different perspectives
What is Cassell’s view of illness?
Illness is why you go to a doctor and disease is what you have after visiting the doctor. You cure a disease but heal an illness
What is sickness?
The sum total of disease and illness in an individual. Also process for socialising disease and illness (worrying behavioural/biological signs are given socially recognisable meanings (Young)
In sickness, what are the social relations of, and responses to, ill health?
Patients associations, fundraising for research, shared metaphorical associations/stigma, discrimination against minorities/the vulnerable/dispossessed
What are possible examples of restricted categories (conditions that are not diseases and illnesses and sicknesses all together)?
Hypertension, mental health problems, hypochondria
When did homosexuality stop being viewed as a mental illness?
It was removed from the DSM III in 1980 and the ICD 10 in 1992
What are some different approaches in medical anthropology?
Medical ecology, cultural interpretive theory, and critical medical anthropology
What is medical ecology?
It discusses the determinants of disease and suffering: natural environment, social environment, systems approach and adaptation
what is cultural interpretive theory?
Semantic determinants of disease and suffering: culture, interpretation, social construction
What is critical medical anthropology?
Political-economic determinants of disease and suffering: power, resistance, global systems, ethics and rights, hegemony
What are some methods in medical anthropology?
Surveys, participant observation (ethnography) (important reflexive dimension), interviews (informal, semi-structured), focus group discussions, life histories, participatory/action research (essays/mapping/seasonal calendar)
What is applied medical anthropology?
Critical understanding of perspectives, for better management of ill health
What is health?
A human construct, not an empirical fact
What are the three models of health?
Medical (absence of disease etc (negative definition)), functional/sociological (can perform daily tasks), idealist (complete well-being in all areas (biopsychosocial))
What are other conceptions of health:
Balanced relationship to/between god, world of spirits, unconscious and constitutive elements. Being ‘normal’ (a commodity). May not bear any relation to one’s medical history
What is wellbeing?
The overlap of health, prosperity and happiness
What do health systems include?
Institutions (formal/informal), activities (clinical/non-clinical practices), skills, knowledge/beliefs/attitudes. These are interconnected but not necessarily integrated
How can health systems be understood?
In relation to society. They cannot be understood in isolation from other aspects of society. Medicine is important but not the sum total of all health care activities that take place in a health system
What are the three sectors of health care?
Popular (lay/common-sense/informal), folk (alternative/complementary/traditional/non-orthodox/non-conventional), professional (scientific/biomedical/formal/ orthodox/conventional/ western/allopathic)
What is the popular sector?
Self-help. Consult with other lay people. 70-90% of all healthcare. Mainly provided by women/older people. Cults of affiliation/self-help groups/therapeutic communities (Hearing Voices Network)
What is the folk sector?
Healers/therapists. Not part of ‘official’ medical system. Sector/technical to sacred experts. Specialised skill. ‘Traditional medicine’. Some becoming increasingly professional, eg acupuncture, aromatherapy, herbalism, reflexology
What is the professional sector?
Medical/paramedical professionals in a legally sanctioned healing system
How can biomedicine be seen as a cultural system?
Varies cross-culturally and intra-culturally. Randomised controlled trials. Hierarchical, specialist oriented, individual case-centred. Increasingly dominant. Medicalisation (non-medical problems become defined/treated as medical problems eg social anxiety etc)
What are similarities across medical systems?
Therapy managing groups. Explanatory models. Medical pluralism with separate use, hierarchy of resort or simultaneous use. Syncretism. Ritual
What are types of ritual?
Calendrical/cosmic cycle (rites of reversal: convival/saturnalia), transformative (rites of passage), misfortune
What are the characteristics of rituals?
Punctuate life. Performative acts (physical/emotional/cognitive elements). May indicate/create social transition. Elements often synthesised-shared/collective/powerful symbols
What is the transformational power of ritual?
Two functions: expressive and creative. There are three stages: separation, transition-liminality, incorporation. Example of going into hospital used to explain these three stages
What are the 6 stages of going to the doctor described by Byrne?
Establish rapport, discover why patient has come, verbal/physical examination, both parties consideration of patients condition, doctor details treatment and further tests, termination of consultation, usually by doctor
What does Katz discuss?
Ritual in the operating theatre: separation (scrubbing up), transition (cutting open-silence and concentration), incorporation (jokes/release of tension). Ritual certainty inspires confidence
What are the three bodies in the mindful body?
The individual body (phenomenologically experienced). The social body (relationships among nature, society and culture). The body politic (artefact of social and political control, including regulation/surveillance)
What is a problems that the concept of the mindful body causes?
It problematises Cartesian dualism
What is phenomenology?
The study of consciousness and object of direct experience. Discussed by Husserl/Heidegger/Merleau-Ponty. Ontology: study of being or ‘what is’. Epistemology: study of knowledge
What is the phenomenology of health?
Study of direct experience of health. Linked to experience of body and senses. Heidegger talks about the ‘transparency of the body’
What is embodiment?
Condition of bodily experience. Body understood to be: material, means of expression/representation, locus of practice and experience. Moving away from ‘biological essentialism’. The ‘lived body’-bodily experience is not fixe but lived
What is sensorial anthropology?
How sensations are experienced phenomenologically, interpreted culturally, and responded to socially
What is empathetic experience and pain in Yap?
Techniques such as massage are used to sense pain. Empathy is a complex phenomenon (tactile, intersubjective and multi-sensory
What are the advantages of sensorial anthropology?
Can help us understand more about: popular health cultures, pharmaceutical practice, use of particular foods, drugs and substances, the ways cultures experience distress, healthcare systems
What are illness narratives?
They shape the interpretation and analysis of experiences. They are based on cultural beliefs and explanations. The ‘wounded storyteller’
What does Fran, say about illness narratives?
Restitution (culturally preferred/clinically encouraged). Chaos (anti narrative. Depp illness). Quest (learning. can be passed on)
What are lay explanations for ill health?
Diverse/fluid. May have different concerns to folk/professional sector. May be patterned by socio-economic position, age, gender, religion, ethnicity, geography
What are sites of illness aetiology?
Individual (sin/breach taboos/soul theft/weak immune system). Natural world (germs/behaviour/humoural imbalance/fate). Social world (sorcery/witchcraft/evil eye). Supernatural causes (punishment from God/spirit/ancestor)
Who talks about witchcraft, oracles and magic among the Azande?
Evans-Pritchard who talks about questions of rationality
Why do people believe things like witchcraft, oracles and magic are deficient?
Not based on sufficient evidence, not held critically or are held ‘unreflectiviely’, and called ‘beliefs’, not ‘knowledge’
What is Koro?
It was a small scale epidemic in west Africa, which led to somatisation
Where do ideas about illness aetiologies come from?
Rationality, personal experience, ‘media’, magazines, advertising, identity, culture, social structure (moral prescription to ‘be well’), position
What do Davidson et al talk about?
The ‘prevention paradox’
How does industrial capitalism affect health?
Production: self denial/control/discipline/rationality. Consumption: irrationality/indulgence/pleasure seeking/release
What is the significance of lay explanations?
Help determine ‘health seeking behaviour’, stigma and explanatory models, form core part of much medical anthropology
What is health seeking behaviour?
Determined by health knowledge/beliefs, triggers to consult (Zola-cultural differences in reporting triggers), access issues.
What are barriers to consultation?
Fear, previous experience, symptom severity, access costs, stigma etc
What is the illness iceberg?
75% of UK experience symptoms in two week period, but much less consult a doctor (Scambler et al-health diaries study)
Why have explanatory models been criticised?
For individual focus/hiding power relationships, and ignoring social processes
What sort of health statistics are generally higher in poorer countries?
Under 5 mortality estimates, maternal mortality estimates, estimated TB incidence rates, malaria rates, life expectancy at birth (lower) , absolute poverty
What is critical medical anthropology?
Critical theory and ethnographic methods to look into political economy of health in specific contexts
How are AIDS and other illnesses similar to problems in history?
“Distributions of AIDS and tuberculosis-like that of slavery in early times-is historically given and economically driven”
How did ideas of HIV first start to come about?
First thought to be a zoonotic disease. Believed to have started in central Africa, then move to the West until a global pandemic occurred. There has now been a shift in focus from individual behaviours to wider social and cultural settings (individual risk behaviour to situated risk)
What are the problems with individual risk?
or does it mean problems of situated risk? Read up and correct this
Victim blaming, overly simplistic, deterministic, focus on the exotic, underpinned by racist or classist assumptions. There are immodest claims of causality
How did Acéphie explain AIDS?
‘multitaxial modes of suffering’ including structural violence
What does the embodiment of inequality lead to?
Social misery
What is biomedicine?
Common model of medical anthropologists employed by health professionals or medical researchers to uncover ‘local beliefs and practices’ , eg reasons for vaccine refusal
What is the aim of biomedical research in anthropology?
To overcome barriers to effective health interventions
Hoe does Scheper-Hughes critique clinically applied medical anthropology?
Compared ‘today’s’ and ‘earlier’ anthropologists. Anthropology is hand-maiden of clinical medicine. There is overemphasis on ‘local culture’ as a ‘problem’. Ignoring/downplaying wider field of social power relations in which ‘culture’ is embedded/how politics structure meaning/possibility biomedicine may be a cultural product
What are implicit assumptions of anthropology and biomedicine?
Biomedicine is qualitatively different and superior as it is objective, based on measurable ‘facts’ and is socially/culturally neutral
What is the anthropology of biomedicine?
Removes brackets. Biomedicine is a cultural phenomenon. It is one form of ethnomedicine rooted in particular cultural and historical settings
What themes in the study of biomedicine can be seen as a form of ethnomedicine?
Historical contextualisation, biomedical discourse, practices and clinical settings, biomedical artefacts and material culture, questioning biomedical homogeneity and universality, globalisation and its consequences, doctor-patient interactions
What are key characteristics of biomedicine?
Empiricism, proximalism, physicalism, generalisability, modernism, reductionism
What is the biomedical model of sickness?
Confined to individual bodies, attributed to malfunctioning of basic material building blocks of bodies, assumes ‘truth’ uncovered by microscope/test tubes. Focuses on ‘cure’ rather than ‘healing’
What does Martin say about studying biomedical discourse?
Unmask cultural assumptions hidden behind accounts of reproductive biology. Ideas shape ideas about how reproduction works and can have important ‘knock-on’ effect
What is an example of studying practices and clinical settings
Quality and outcomes framework in UK general practice-phased out as costing NHS too much money to implement
How is biomedical homogeneity and universality questioned?
Different roles in medical practice. International variations in biomedical practice. ‘Doctors’ different clinical specialists
What is an example of cultural differences in biomedicine in Japan?
3x more beds than UK. Appointments are seen as disrespectful. Surrogate patients-family/friends take over interactions with doctor. Attitudes to cancer is not to tell the patient
What are some consequences of globalisation?
India=major supplier of health professionals to the developed world. International migration of health personnel (10.3% doctors registered in uk qualified in India). Migration of doctors is a heavily debated topic
What are the two types of doctor-patient interactions?
Mutualistic and paternalistic
What are mutualistic interactions?
Patient-centred. Involve listening, reflecting and clarifying. More often if the patient is younger, higher class, higher educated, or with high experience with their condition
What are paternalistic interactions?
Doctor-centred. Involve closed questions and the disease model. More often used if patient is older, lower class, lower education, or have less experience with their condition
What are limitations of seeing biomedicine as ‘just another ethnomedicine’?
Acts more powerfully on many conditions. Has a reflexivity enabling paradigm shift. Product of socio-historical milieu. However, there are medically unexplained symptoms (Moatz et al), and mental illness with the cultural assumptions of ‘normal’
What is the social context of ‘pathological’?
There is controlled abnormality-rites of reversal
What does Hugh-Jones say about medicines, drugs and foods?
They are commonalities linked with communication and expression of social values
Why are medicines so popular?
Efficacy, detachable from context (allow power to help self), and metaphoric and metonymic qualities (affections, gifts, parental responsibility)
What are meanings behind medicines?
Metaphors-make sense of the world. Concreteness-make sense of and convey illness. Metonyms-draw on other kinds of connections. Retain partial connection to culture, ideas, and knowledge that produced them
What is the placebo effect?
Important way in which meaning influences work of medicine. More to medicine than pharmacological properties-symbolic dimensions
What are 3-arm clinical trials?
Involve three groups-medication with active ingredient, placebo, and no intervention
What makes a placebo work?
(Moerman) physicians enthusiasm and confidence, appearance of the medicine including branding, patients adherence, culture and national identity
What are case studies of placebos?
The physical properties of medicines in India and antiretroviral medicines in Zambia
What is pharmakon?
Remedy and poison, reflected in users’ accounts permeated with feelings of both attraction and repulsion. Ambiguity
What is ‘the pharmaceutical person’ (Emily Martin)?
Poison aspects often displaced. Side effects and adverse effects
What are cyborgs?
Half organism, half machine/artefact/technology/tool
What problems occur when medicines travel?
Appropriation and indigenisation
What is the social life of medicine?
Acquire meaning through social relationships
What are the three overlapping ways anthropologists ‘handle’ medicines?
Populist (sympathetic and celebrates capabilities), enlightened (doubts capabilities, critical, false consciousness), pragmatic (participation and engagement to create knowledge)
What is the oxygen case study?
Pharmakon-like properties. External ‘lung’ as cyborg. Following oxygen through industry from local market
What is the case study of access to ARVs in Uganda an example of?
Power, control and pharmaceiticalisation
What is personhood?
What a constitutes a person can be constructed differently cross-culturally
What is the western notion of the body?
Individual, autonomous whole. Separation between mind and body (Cartesian dualism). Mind rules the body in a healthy person
What are composite persons/bodies?
In Luo in Kenya. Healing is restoring balance and openness to outside influences. Different models of worms (Luo model and biomedical model) and different boundaries and processes of life
What are cross-cultural notions of parenthood?
Partible personhood in Melonesia (Stathern) and the fractal person (Taylor)
What is possession?
Discussed by Boddy (Zar cult-‘cult of affliction’) and by Ong (spirit possession in a multinational factory)
What is the Máori river system?
It was granted legal personhood
What is biomedicine and bounded body?
Disease=boundary infringement. Prioritise physical over mental illness . Ethical and legal personhood complications with stem cells due to status of embryos and immortalised stem cell lines
How can personhood can be partial/potential?
Prisoners, and when in persistent vegetive state
What are health interventions?
Activity promoting behaviour improving mental/physical health or discourages/reformed risky behaviour. In or out of formal research or formal ‘health’ context
What are forms of research?
Quantitative research, qualitative research, ethnography
What is qualitative research?
Empirical, reductionist, ‘facts’, objectivity, validity, generalisability, reliability. Eg descriptive/analytic studies, experiments, surveys, case control and cohort studies, experiments, and RCTs. Eg afterlife of a malaria vaccine trial
What is quantitative research?
Holistic, understanding, empathy, subjectivity, rapport, role of researcher, reflexivity, naturalism, generalisability, replicability, reliability, triangulation. Eg observation, interviews, focus groups, existing materials, participant-observation, semi-structured interviews, existing materials
What are ethnographies?
Methodology-written product
What is the case studies of tobacco control?
Fresh Smoke Free North East. WHO’s Framework Convention on Tobaccon Control