general Flashcards
What are the 4 pillars of medical ethics?
Beneficence- duty to ‘do good’
-goes beyond doing no harm, encourages to actively help
-should update skills and knowledge
-consider patient’s individual needs
-in line w patient’s expectations
-so, req patient centred care
Non-maleficence- duty to do no harm
-should not cause harm by actions or neglect
-if treatment causes more harm than good, shouldn’t be considered
-should consider patient safety and comfort
Autonomy- respect patient’s rights to make decisions about their healthcare
-cannot impose treatments of interventions w/out informed consent
-instead, enable patients to make informed decisions
-decisions should be free from coercion and pressure
-only exception is when patient deemed unable to make autonomous decision
Justice- to treat all people equally and equitably under law and in society
-compatible w law, patient’s rights, fair and balanced
-ensure no one’s fairly disadvantaged
-determines how resources are split, complicated by limited funds
What is utilitarianism?
Actions that cause the most happiness and pleasure for the most amount of people are ethical
What is deontology?
States actions can be determined as right or wrong depending on if they follow a set of rules, rather than the consequence of the action
-holding drs to rigid prof standards and guidelines (GMC)
What is consequentialism
‘Ends justify the means’
What is holistic/patient-centred care?
Has 5 key principles:
-personalised care: Focus on individual HUMAN patient (face2face consultation)
-empathy: build human connection and better understanding
-informed consent: seek patient’s voluntary, informed and understood consent (respects autonomy and protects from medical paternalism)
-continuity of care: prefer to see a doctor they already know and trust, easier for dr to identify on changes, improved healthcare outcome
-patients as partners in care: patients enabled and educated to be involved in decisions affecting their own care
what is capacity
-capacity is ability to give consent
Requires:
-understanding information
-retain information
-weigh up to make a decision
-communicate decision
-Gillick competency - used to decide whether child is mature enough to make decisions
What is Gillick competency?
Used to decide whether child is mature enough to make decisions ab their own health (under 16)
If patient is gillick competent parents can say no but will still go thru
What is consent?
-when patient gives permission before receiving medical treatments
-voluntary, informed, patient has capacity
-given in 2 ways: verbally, written
-consent is not needed in: emergencies, patient has severe mental health conditions, poses a wider risk
-implied consent in direct care - patient is aware that a Doctor will share information about them to other individuals in the healthcare team to provide the patient with the best possible care
What is confidentiality?
-key to building strong doctor-patient relations
-patients under-report symptoms/ avoid seeking med help if they think info isn’t confidential
-sometimes required to break confidentiality: severe harm to themselves or others
What does the GMC teach
-General medical council - regulatory body for medical professionals in the UK
-Oversees education, training, practise of doctors
-Ensure standards are met to maintain patient safety and public trust in the medical profession
-Good medical practice, published by the GMC, outlines principles doctors must follow:
-Patient centred care
-Maintaining professional competence
-Effective communication
-Ethics and accountability
-Continuous professional development
-Important because
-ensures patient safety and wellbeing
-provides ethical framework
-encourages accountability
-maintains public trust in the profession
-guides professional devp
What are the NHS values
-Working together for patients
-Respects and dignity
-Commitment to quality of care
-Compassion
-Improving lives
-Everyone counts
What are the Fraser guidelines?
Outline the scenario in which advice can be given to a child about contraception and sexual health without parental consent
What are virtue ethics
Aim to act as virtuous person, rather than according to guidelines or according to results
4 cardinal virtues
prudence - using reason and intellect to decide what’s right and wrong
justice - treating everyone fairly
fortitude - being courageous in face of danger, acting in high pressure emergency situation
temperance - restraint of personal wants, putting patient desires above and team before ourself
Empathy
understanding and sharing a patient’s feelings
cognitive (rather than emotional) empathy
What are each uni’s different teaching style
-Keele and BARTs use problem-based learning
-Cardiff uses case-based learning
-Leicester is more integrated????
What is euthanasia?
How can you categorise it?
Euthanasia - ending a patients life who is suffering from an incurable/painful disease OR in a irreversible coma
Active - acting person deliberately intervenes to end someone’s life
Passive - person causes death by withholding/withdrawing treatment necessary to maintain life
Voluntary - carried out at request of person who dies
Involuntary - patient wants to live but killed anyways (manslaughter/murder)
ILLEGAL in the UK - life imprisonment
Passive euthanasia seen as part of palliative care, tech not regarded as euthanasia
-patients go to dignitas in Switzerland to be euthanised
What is assisted suicide?
In this, physician gives patient the means to take lethal medication themselves
What is assisted dying
Sub term of assisted suicide
Only used in the context of a patient who’s already dying
History and legalities of euthanasia/assisted dying? In UK, in other countries
Legalities:
-2015: House of Commons rejected bill to allow those in last 6 months be prescribed med to administer themselves
-2018: UK Supreme Court ruled legal permission no longer needed to withdraw patients in permanent veg state (BMA and RCP published guidance)
-2019: Paul Lamb living with chronic pain renewed but for right to die
-2019: Mavis Eccleston cleared of murder and manslaughter after giving husband prescription med he needed to overdose
-2019: Paul Newby lost High court case challenging assisted dying
-2020: joint enquiry into assisted dying
-2021: BMA adopted neutral stance on euthanasia
CURRENT:
Introduction of Terminally Ill adults (End of Life) Bill
Proposes giving terminally ill adults right to chose to end own life
-Must be over 18
-Have mental capacity, clear, settled, informed wish, no coercion or pressure
-expected to die within 6 months
-witnessed and signed declarations
-satisfy 2 doctors
-High court judge would have to rule
-must be administered by patient themselves
MPs voted in favour of this bill, passing first stage in the Commons
Euthanasia legal in Netherlands, Colombia, Luxembourg, Belgium, Canada, Spain, New Zealand and some parts of Australia
Assisted suicide legal in certain areas of the US
Arguments for and against euthanasia
FOR:
-no matter level of palliative care, always some patients whose illness causes intolerable suffering
-autonomy: patients have right to chose to end life inadequate symptom control
-many patients currently travel to Switz Dignitas
-inc public support in assisted dying, democracy, moral norms change
-do as you wish as long as its not harming others?
-safer deaths
-clearer end of life legal framework (double effect- pain relief may shorten life)
-Death with Dignity in US state Oregon, no inc deaths or poorer n of end of life care
AGAINST:
-non maleficence - do no harm (both for in against, killing vs suffering)
-worry that law may extend to children or vulnerable groups
-risk of sending out message that that falls short of certain conditions isnt worth preserving
-patients have autonomy, but doctors have right to reject treatment
-govt in better position to determine affect of laws on country, regardless of mass view
-vulnerable people may feel pressure, safeguards won’t be able to remove this pressure
-do the pros outweigh the cons
What is palliative care?
Improves quality of life of patients experiencing life-limiting illnesses
Works to manage pain and other distressing symptoms
What is end of life care
Care surrounding last year of your life
What is abortion
-Medical process of ending a human pregnancy so it doesn’t culminate in the birth of a baby
-Can be through medication or surgical procedure
-Legal under The Abortion Act
-Can only be carried out in first 24 weeks
-2 doctors must decide it’s less damaging to the patients mental and physical health
-Legalised to take second pill at home to prevent risk of miscarrying on journey home
Arguments for and against abortion
FOR
-almost all done within first 3 months, foetus cannot exist independently outside womb, so not living organism and not murder
-fertilised eggs in IVF thrown away or destroyed if not implanted but that’s not murder
-in case of rape, forcing women to have child may be more damaging
-keeping it legal prevents deaths and complications from secret abortions
-abortion may be necessary to keep woman alive
AGAINST
-human life begins at conception making abortion murder
-child could be adopted and should not be punished by being aborted
-abortions can cause psychological distress
-child could have been very important to society
Challenges faced by the NHS
Ambulances
Backlogs
Care
Doctors & Dentists
Challenge of ambulances in NHS
-Measure of performance is response times
-4 categories of ambulances responses:
Immediate response to life threatening condition (under 7 mins to reach)
Serious condition requiring urgent transport/treatment (under 18 mins to reach)
Urgent problem, req transport and treatment in acute setting (2hrs)
Non-urgent problem, req transportation (3hrs)
-Ambulance wait times are significantly higher, especially category 2 BUT even category 1… these are serious and req timely treatment
-Impacts patient safety
(BHA article: avg waits for heart attacks and strokes rise to 42 mins, still missing increased waiting time targets, worst region was East Midlands at 1hr, so important for heart attacks and strokes, each min counts, risk of permanent brain/heart damage)
Reasons:
-unprecedented levels of demand post-Covid
-post 2010 cuts to community services have inc pressure on emergency services, treating w more acute issues
-shortage of paramedics, left to find better work-life balance
-A&E wait times, emergency depts overcrowded, slows down ambulance crews, must wait with patients until space becomes available
Attempts to solve:
-Govt allocated 150 mil, 3% pay rise to incentivise retention
Challenge of backlog on NHS
-Due to decision to suspend elective treatment during covid 19 pandemic
-initial drop in waiting lists but steep increase in 2020
-Large list, people have been millions waiting for 18 weeks, some for over a year
-Much greater than pre pandemic levels
-Hidden backlog (people who haven’t put themselves on waiting list due to backlog/had appts cancelled)
-Waiting times in A and E severely increased, taking more time to treat emergency patients
Cancer waiting times
Target time between referral from GP to consultant is 2 weeks (90%)
However is significantly less
Blamed on
-COVID pandemic
-severity of conditions patients are presenting with
-longer ambulance wait times
-Changes in wider community health provision