Freud's theory of personality linked to aggression Flashcards
Id
driven by thanatos and libido
unconscious desires
driven by the pleasure principle
Ego
balances Id and Superego
Superego
learnt
a persons moral compass
works on the morality principle
punishes the ego through guilt
rewards ego with pride for moral behaviour
thanatos
the death instinct
drive for death, aggression, destruction and violence
libido
life instinct/ lust
conscious
everything that we are aware on/ mental processes
uconscious
part of the mind that influences behaviour, but it cannot be accessed
defence mechanisms
negative feelings are displaced onto something else, to prevent hurting a person
used by the unconscious mind to reduce anxiety
when is the superego formed
at the end of the phallic stage of development
what does Blackburn (1993) argue about the superego
if the superego is deficient then criminality is inevitable
as the id is not properly controlled and we are going to give into our urges and impulses
how does a weak superego develop
same-sex parent absent during phallic stage of psycho-sexual development
fail to internalise the moral values of the same sex parent
consequence of weak superego
Id will dictate behaviour
No longer know right from wrong
aggression- impulses/ urges from id need satisfying
what causes an excessively strong superego
same-sex parent is overly harsh
consequences of an excessively strong superego
an individual is cripples by guilt and anxiety
commits crime in order to satisfy the superego’s need for punishment
as aggressive urges are not acceptable
causes of a deviant superego
if the child internalises the morals of a criminal or deviant same sex parent
Bowlby (1944) - main ideas
child is asocial and motivated by pleasure seeking and self-destructive impulses
if a child is raised in a dysfunctional family, it may cause long term damage to their psyche
the ability to form meaningful relationships in adulthood was dependent on the child forming a warm, continuous relationship with a mother-figure
Bowlby (1944) - consequence of not forming a maternal bond
forming the affectionless psychopathy personality type
Bowlby (1944) - results
interviewed 44 juvenile thieves
14 had affectionless psychopathy
12 had experiences prolonged separation from their mothers during infancy
only 2 in the non criminal group had experienced similar seperation
issues with Bowlby’s research
researcher bias
his preconceptions of what he expected to find may have influenced the response of his interviewees
cause and effect can be questioned
what do psychodynamic theories believe about anxiety
anxiety will weaken the ego
leading to a dominant id or superego
3 types of defence mechanism
displacement
rationalisation
sublimation
displacement
satisfying an impulse
could explain lashing out on a stranger in the street instead of attacking a work boss
rationalisation
explaining behaviour in a rational and acceptable way when it is actually very negative
offenders may use this to justify criminal behaviour
could explain why an offender feels no remorse
sublimation
id’s urges are acted upon but transformed into something socially acceptable
ego doesnt consider guilt
could explain why people commit lesser crimes
e.g. petty theft instead of the heinous crime they unconsciously wish to commit
deterministic
suggests individuals have no control over their offending behaviour - no free will
as defence mechanisms are determined by the ego’s response to unconscious conflicts
should individuals be punished for a crime that they have no free will over?
falsifiability
the ability of something to be able to be proved false
nearly impossible to yest freud’s theory - not falsifiable
gender bias
freud’s theory suggests girls have a weaker superego than boys - under less pressure to identify with the same-sex parent due to lack of castration anxiety
males show more criminal behaviour than females - contradictory
only 4% of UK prisoners are female
subjectivity
may be subjective what is morally right or wrong, as people have different morals
reductionist
only focusses on childhood expeiriences and features a person may be born with
genetics, biological structures and environmental factors may have an influence
opposing research - superego formation
if children are raised by a deviant parent then go on to commit crime, this could be due to genetic inheritance instead
opposing research - Lewis (1954)
could not establish a causal link between maternal deprivation and criminal behaviour
interviewed 500 young people
why is the assessment of childhood experiences difficult
retrospective information
rely on self-reported information - open to distortion, development and minimisation of events