Federal Civil Procedure Flashcards
Well Pleaded Complaint Rule
A question of federal law must arise in P’s affirmative claim. Can have a state law question if the federal question is:
- actually in dispute
- demands federal judges expertise and ought to be resolved uniformly AND
- not so commonly present in state law actions to trample their jurisdiction
Diversity Jurisdiction
- Actions between citizens of different states AND
- Amount in controversy is greater than $75,000
(measured at time suit is filed)
Diversity Jurisdiction in Class Actions
- More than 100 persons AND
2. $5 million in controversy
Aggregations of Claims
P can bring multiple claims against D which will be aggregated to reach $75,000
Supplemental Jurisdiction
Allows a claim falling outside federal question or diversity jurisdiction to piggyback onto a claim that does fall within federal question jurisdiction or diversity.
- Does claim arise from the same transaction/occurrence?
- Is the anchor claim federal question?
- Is there good reason for the court to decline anyway?
Removal
D can remove from state to federal court if the case could have originally been filed in federal court.
Exception: D cannot remove if:
- federal jurisdiction would be grounded only in diversity action AND
- D is a citizen of state where P filed suit
If there are multiple Ds all have to agree to remove and it must be done within 30 days of when grounds for removal became apparent.
Residency
If party is a resident of the state where suit is filed, personal jurisdiction is constitutional. Corporations is a resident of states where incorporated and where it has its principal place of business.
Consent
Party can consent to personal jurisdiction by:
- appearing in court without objecting to personal jurisdiction
- If signed contract with choice-of-forum clause
- business appoints agents located in the state to receive process
Service
D is serviced with process while in state where suit is filed. Not constitutional if D is enticed or forced into state or D was in state to participate in a different legal proceeding.
Minimum Contracts
- D has minimum contract with the forum state (established if D causes harm in the state, does business, or has real property in the state)
- Claims against D arises from that contact AND
- Personal jurisdiction won’t offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice
General Jurisdiction
Business contracts must be so significant that the company, though not incorporated or headquartered in the state, is essentially at home there that personal jurisdiction is appropriate
Venue: All Ds Reside in Same State
District where any single D resides
Venue: Ds Reside in Multiple States
Location of harm
Transferring Venue
- Convenience: Could have been filed there in the first place and transfer is necessary for convenience of parties and/or witnesses
- Agreement
- Interest of justice: Court can dismiss in the interest of justice and transfer it to where it could have been filed.
Forum Non Conveniens
If the most convenient forum is not in the US, court cannot transfer, but can dismiss without prejudice so that P can refile in the proper country.
Contents of the Complaint
- Grounds for subject matter jurisdiction
- Statement of facts sufficient to show that P is entitled to relief
- Demand for judgment and the relief sought
Amending the Complaint
Party can amend pleading once as a matter of right within 21 days of serving it or within 21 days of serving an answer to a motion to dismiss.
After that party can amend with permission of other party or court.
Service of Process
Must include both the complaint and the summons and must be served within 90 days of filing the complaint.
Place of Service of Process
D is natural person
- Deliver to D
- Leave at D’s residence with a person of suitable age and discretion residing there
- Serve D’s registered agent
- Mail with letter requesting D waive in-person service
D is corporation serve with
- an officer
- a managing agent or general agent OR
- any other agent authorized by appointment or by law to receive service
Answer
D admits or denies P’s allegations and lists defenses they might have. For each allegation, D should specifically admit or deny, if failure to deny it is deemed admitted
Waiver of Defenses
If defenses aren’t raised in answer it is generally waived.
Exceptions:
- Failure to state a claim
- Failure to join necessary party
- Lack of subject matter jurisdiction
When to File Answer
If D was served with process, 21 days to respond
If D waived service, 60 days to respond
Preliminary Injunction
- Likelihood of success on the merits
- Irreparable harm
- Balancing of hardships on P and D
- Public interest AND
- Payment of security
Temporary Restraining Order
Can only be issued without notice if
1. Specific facts clearly show that immediate and irreparable injury, loss, or damage will result before the adverse party can be heard in opposition AND
2. The movant’s attorney certifies in writing any efforts made to give notice and the reasons why it shouldn’t be required
(expires within 14 days)
Permissive Counterclaim
If claim doesn’t arise out of the same transaction or occurrence underlying P’s claims against D, then D may file a permissive counterclaim but not required to do so
Compulsory Counterclaim
If claim does arise out of the same transaction or occurrence underlying P’s claim against D, D must file or forfeit the claim.