Evidence Flashcards
Harmless Error
The jury would have reached the same verdict even if the error hadn’t occurred, no substantial rights are affected.
Plain Error
An error that affects a substantial right of a party, or a serious mistake that affects the verdict.
Judicial Notice
Mandatory if
- Requested by the party AND
- Supplied with the necessary information
Judicial Notice Jury Instruction
Civil: must accept the fact as true
Criminal: may accept the fact as true
Preponderance of the Evidence
Civil standard used in some aspects of criminal cases (i.e. motion to suppress, involuntariness of confession)
Clear and Convincing Evidence
Criminally related civil actions (fraud, validity of deed or will) and to determine insanity in federal court (burden on D)
Beyond a Reasonable Doubt
Criminal standard in guilt phase
Logical Relevance
Has some probative value and has some logical tendency to prove or disprove a fact of consequence
Legal Relevance
Evidence must be helpful in deciding the case
403 Balancing Test
Exclude evidence if the probative value is substantially outweighed by
- the danger of unfair prejudice
- confusion of the issues
- misleading the jury
- undue delay
- waste of time OR
- needless presentation of cumulative evidence
Civil Case Character Evidence
Character evidence is allowed when character is an essential element of the cause of action
Criminal Case Character Evidence
Testimony about a pertinent good character trait must be raised by D. Then the prosecution may rebut with reputation or opinion evidence
Victim’s Pertinent Trait/Character
D may offer evidence of a victim’s violent character as circumstantial evidence that the victim was the first aggressor. Then the prosecution may rebut with good character of the victim or bad character of the D through reputation or opinion.
Homicide Cases Character Evidence
D may offer evidence that victim was the first aggressor, then the prosecution may offer evidence of the victim’s good character for peacefulness.
MIMIC
Evidence of character can be used for any purpose other than to show conduct in conformity with one's character. Motive Identity Mistake (absence of) Intent Common scheme or plan
Habit Evidence
Evidence of the habit of a person, or routine practice of an organization, is relevant to prove conduct in conformity with the habit.
Subsequent Remedial Measures
Inadmissible to prove negligence, culpable conduct, design defect, or the need for a warning.
Admissible to show ownership or control, impeachment, feasibility of precautions if controverted
Compromise and Offers to Settle
Evidence of an offer to settle a claim that is disputed about either validity or amount is inadmissible to prove liability.
Admissible to show bias or prejudice or to negate a contention of undue delay.
Payment of Medical and Similar Expenses
Evidence of offering to pay medical bills is inadmissible to prove liability for an injury.
Pleas, Plea Discussions, and Related Statements
A plea and any statement made during plea negotiations by D to a prosecutor will be inadmissible against D in a later proceeding.
Doesn’t apply to statements made by police.
Liability Insurance
Evidence that a person was/wasn’t insured is inadmissible to prove negligence or fault. Can be admitted to prove agency, ownership, or control, but limits of coverage are never admissible.
Rape-Shield Law
In civil or criminal proceeding involving alleged sexual misconduct, evidence offered to show the alleged victim’s sexual behavior is excluded.
Exception:
- consent (past sex with D)
- source of semen, injury, or other physical evidence
- evidence that is constitutionally required
Attorney Client Privilege
The client is the holder of the privilege and may refuse to disclose and prevent others from disclosing confidential communications made for the purpose of seeking professional legal advice or services. Lawyer may assert privilege on behalf of client.
Exceptions to Attorney Client Privilege
- future crime or fraud
- suits between attorney and client
- joint client exception (two clients hire the same attorney and are then involved in litigation with each other)
Psychotherapist Patient Privilege
Protects confidential communications between a licensed psychotherapist and a patient who is seeking diagnosis or treatment for a medical condition.
Exceptions to Psychotherapist Patient Privilege
- statements made regarding commitment proceedings
- statements dealing with court-ordered exams
- when the medical condition is part of the claim, i.e. malpractice suits
- future fraud or crime
Marital Communications Privilege
Can be asserted by either spouse and it applies in both criminal and civil suits. Protects confidential communications between the spouses during the marriage.
Exceptions to Marital Communications Privilege
- Crimes or intentional torts committed by one spouse against the other or a child
- Divorce proceedings/adverse civil proceedings
- Joint participation in a crime