Families & Households Flashcards
How does Pilcher describe modern, western childhood?
The ‘Golden age’ of childhood.
What is the main feature of Pilcher’s ‘Golden age of childhood’?
Separateness - childhood is a clear and distinct life stage, characterised as innocent and happy, with an exclusion from paid work and different dress.
What quote demonstrates Wagg’s disagreement with Pilcher?
“Childhood is socially constructed. It is, in other words, what members of
particular societies, at particular times and in particular places, say it is. There is no singular universal childhood, experienced by all. So, childhood isn’t ‘natural’ and should be distinguished from mere biological immaturity”
What evidence was found by these sociologists to support the idea that childhood is a social construction, as they take responsibility at a younger age?
1) Punch (2001)
2) Holmes (1974)
Punch (2001) found rural Bolivia that children worked from the age of 5
Holmes (1974)for not letting a child do something found in a Samoan village being
too young was never a reason
Other than taking responsibility at a younger age, how else did Benedict argue that children in non-industrial societies are treated differently?
- Less value is placed on children showing obedience to adults.
- Children’s sexual behaviour is often viewed differently.
How do sociologists argue that childhood is becoming ‘globalised’?
International humanitarian and welfare agencies have exported and imposed on the rest of the world western norms of what childhood should be. For example campaigns against child labour, or concerns about street children.
What three stages of childhood did Aries identify throughout history, in his comparison of art across time?
Middle Ages 10th – 13th Century
- The idea of childhood did not exist - no separation between them and adults socially or legally, with children working from an early age.
The Cult of Childhood 13th Century onwards
- This is when the modern view of childhood starts to emerge. Schools started to specialise in education just for the young, reflecting the influence for the church where children were seen as the ‘creatures of god’. Additionally there is a growing distinction between children’s and adults clothing, and handbooks on childrearing start to emerge
The Century of the Child 20th Century
- We are now in a world that is obsessed with childhood and Aries calls this ‘the century of the child’.
Which sociologist criticises Aries for saying childhood did not exist in the middle
ages, arguing instead that the notion of childhood was ‘different’.
Pollock
What reasons can be given for the changing position of children in society over time?
Laws restricting child labour and excluding children form paid work
The introduction of
compulsory schooling 1880
The growth of the idea of children’s rights
Declining family size and lower infant mortality rates
Children’s development became a subject of medical knowledge
Laws and policies that apply specifically to children
What is industrialisation, and how has it lead to the position of children in society changing?
Industrialisation is the shift from agriculture to factory production and has brought about many of those changes as modern industry needs an educated workforce and so compulsory schooling is needed.
What quote demonstrates DeMause’s ‘march of progress’ view?
“The history of childhood is a nightmare from which we have only recently begun to awaken. The further back in history one goes, the lower the level of childcare, and the more likely children are to be killed, abandoned, beaten, terrorised and sexually abused”
Which two sociologists other than DeMause hold a ‘march of progress’ view on childhood?
Aries and Shorter
Who argues that childhood has become ‘toxic’ and what points do they make to support this?
Palmer (2010):
* Junk food
* Computer games and social media – the ‘electronic village’
* Intensive marketing to children
* Long working hours of parents
* Growing emphasis on testing in education
Which perspectives would argue that childhood is based on conflict/ inequality?
Marxists and Feminists
What evidence is there for children being treated differently based on ethnicity?
Brannen (1994) – Asian parents were more likely than other parents to be strict toward daughters
Bhatti (1999) – found izzat (family honour) could be a restriction on the behaviour of girls
What evidence is there for children being treated differently based on gender?
Hillman (1993) – boys are more likely to be allowed to cross or cycle on roads, use buses, and go out after dark
Bonke (1999) - Girls do more domestic labour especially in lone parent families – 5x more than boys
What evidence is there for children being treated differently based on class?
Poor mothers are more likely to have low birth-weight babies – this is linked to delayed physical and intellectual development.
Working class children are more likely to suffer from hyperactivity disorders and conduct disorders.
Children born into poor families are far more likely to die in infancy, suffer long standing illness, be shorter in height, fall behind at school and be placed on child protection register.
What 5 forms of adult control do child liberationists think children need to be freed from?
Neglect and abuse
Control over children’s space
Control over children’s time
Control over children’s bodies
Controlover children’s access to resources
Who calls the inequalities between adults and children ‘age patriarchy’?
Gittins (1998)
What two strategies did Hockey & James (1993) find that children use to try to resist their status of ‘child’?
- Acting up
- Acting down
What do opponents of child liberationism argue?
Critics of the child liberationist view say that some adult control is needed over
children and it is justified as children cannot make rational decisions.
They also say that whilst a child does remain under adult supervision they are not as powerless as the liberationists claim, e.g. acts such as Children Act and UN convention on the Rights of the Child establishes that children have the legal right to be protected and consulted
What did Postman (1994) argue about childhood?
that it is disappearing at a ‘dazzling’ rate. He says the boundary between childhood and adulthood is becoming increasingly blurred.
How does Opie (1993) criticise Postman (1994)?
They argue that unsupervised childhood games, songs and rhymes still exist.
How does Jenks (2005) criticise Postman (1994)?
Jenks argues childhood is now undergoing a further change as we move from modernity to postmodernity. In modernity adults’ relationships were more stable but in postmodernity relationships are less stable e.g. divorce is more likely to occur.