existence of god and revelation Flashcards
quote against the first cause argument
“the universe is just there that’s all”- bertrand russell
who was the inventor of the design argument?
william paley
who was the inventor of the design argument?
william paley
what is the design argument?
the universe’s design is so complex that it must have a designer so that designer must be god
what does the design argument consider proof that god exists?
the world’s existence is proof of god
what is ockham’s razor?
argument that god is the simplest answer to why we are here
what does regularity mean in ockham’s razor?
the universe is regularly ordered that there has to have been a cosmic designer
what does probability mean in ockham’s razor?
although the design argument doesn’t necessarily prove the existence of god, it is more likely than not
what are the strengths to the design argument?
- explains that the world has some purpose
- makes sense to say that the designer is god because the world is very complex and god is omnipotent
what are the weaknesses to the design argument?
- why is a stone more designed than a watch if both were created by god?
- just because something looks designed doesn’t mean it is
- perhaps god designed the universe so that He no longer had to exist
- why design something that’s not perfect and free of suffering?
- must the designer be god?
- design can be explained by natural selection
who was the inventor of the simplicity, regularity, order idea
richard swinburne
how can darwin’s theory contradict the design argument?
the theory of natural selection could explain the appearance of design without a designer
what did john stuart mill say against the design argument?
said that nature was fundamentally cruel and questioned why god (who was all-loving) would make a world which consisted of such suffering
what did david hume say against the design argument?
the design argument doesn’t necessarily have to lead to the classic christian definition of god
quote in support of the design argument
“in the absence of any proof, the thumb alone would convince me of god’s existence” - isaac newton
quote against the design argument
“the aesthetic argument for theism becomes more persuasive when it renounces all claims to proof and appeals to a logical probability” - f.r tennant
who was the inventor of the first cause argument?
thomas aquinas
what is the first cause argument?
suggests that everything in the universe has a cause but the chain of cause and effect can’t go on forever so it has to have started somewhere. there was a first uncaused cause, which is god
what are the strengths of the first cause argument?
- true that everything has a cause
- confirms to the theist that the cosmos has a purpose
- big bang is supported by the first cause and vice versa
what are the weaknesses of the first cause argument?
- we don’t know that the uncaused cause is god , could be anything
- we have limited knowledge
- if everything needs a cause, what caused god?
- belief doesn’t prove anything but merely puts god in the place of the uncaused cause
what is the fallacy of composition and whose idea was it?
just because we have mothers, doesn’t mean the universe has to have one - bertrand russell
what is the argument from miracles?
only god can break the laws of nature and science so the presence of miracles tells us that god exists because god is the only one outside of nature
what are miracles?
an impossible event, usually good, that cannot be explained by nature of science and thought to be an act of god
what are the two types of miracles?
- events that break natural laws and can’t be explained
- happy coincidences
what is the principle of credulity?
if someone says something has happened, it probably has
what is the principle of testimony?
its reasonable to believe that the experiences of others are exactly as they repeat them
who invented the principles of credulity and testimony?
richard swinburne
what are the objections to miracles?
- could be lucky coincidences
- maybe the necessary scientific evidence hasn’t been discovered yet
- don’t miracles show god’s favouritism?
- miracles remove the need for faith if god just chooses randomly
what are the strengths to miracles?
- may solve the problem of evil as god does not intervene because he cannot or because he is bound by the laws of nature
-the principles of credulity and testimony
what did david hume say about miracles?
while miracles may exist, there isn’t enough evidence supporting it so its more reasonable not to believe them