Evidence Flashcards
In what proceedings do the federal rules of evidence not apply?
- Grand jury proceedings
- Preliminary hearings
- Warrant hearings
- Bail proceedings
- Preliminary questions regarding admissibility
- Sentencing
- Probation violation hearings
- Forfeiture proceedings
- Summary contempt
What’s required for an objection to a piece of evidence?
Timely objection and motion to strike that states a specific ground
What is the plain error doctrine?
A reversal may be granted without a timely objection if the error is highly prejudicial to substantive rights
What standard does the judge apply in preliminary questions of admissibility?
Preponderance of the evidence
What standard is used in preliminary questions of conditional admissibility?
There is sufficient evidence to support a finding that the preliminary fact does exist to find the evidence relevant
When must the judge conduct a hearing on the preliminary question away from the jury?
- Admissibility of a confession
- A criminal defendant requests
- Justice so requires
What is the rule of completeness?
If a party introduces a statement or part of a statement, an adverse party may require the introduction, at that time, or any other part or another statement that in fairness ought to be considered at the same time.
What is judicial notice?
A substitute for proof where the court accepts certain adjudicative facts as true without requiring formal presentation of evidence. Mandatory if requested and necessary info supplied.
For:
1. Facts commonly known in the territory
2. Easily verifiable facts
What’s the effect of a jury instruction on judicial notice?
A civil jury must accept the judicially noticed fact as conclusive
A criminal jury may, but is not required to, accept a judicially noticed fact as conclusive.
What are 3 main burdens of persuasion?
- Preponderance of the evidence - traditional civil standard, preliminary criminal matters
- Clear and convincing - insanity, criminally-related civil cases (like fraud)
- Beyond a reasonable doubt - criminal guilt
Are presumptions allowed in criminal cases?
Mandatory presumptions are unconstitutional. Can’t shift burden from prosecution to prove every element.
Permissive presumptions allow jury to presume one fact from another, these are permitted in a criminal case.
When is evidence relevant?
When it makes a fact of consequence to the action more or less probable.
What are the grounds for excluding relevant evidence under rule 403 balancing?
May be excluded if the probative value is substantially outweighed by:
1. Danger or unfair prejudice
2. Confusion of the issues
3. Misleading the jury
4. Undue delay
5. Waste of time
6. Needless presentation of cumulative evidence
What are the grounds for excluding relevant evidence under rule 403 balancing?
May be excluded if the probative value is substantially outweighed by:
1. Danger or unfair prejudice
2. Confusion of the issues
3. Misleading the jury
4. Undue delay
5. Waste of time
6. Needless presentation of cumulative evidence
What are the types of character evidence?
Reputation
Opinion
Specific acts
What are the civil causes of action where character is at issue?
- Defamation
- Negligent entrustment, hiring, supervision
- Immigration
- Child custody
- Entrapment (criminal defense)
What kinds of character evidence is admissible when character is an element of the cause of action?
All three - reputation, opinion, specific acts
When is character evidence for truthfulness admissible for impeachment?
Reputation or opinion evidence only, on direct
Civil and criminal cases
When is impeachment by prior bad acts admissible?
Specific acts relevant to truthfulness are admissible to impeach a witness by asking questions on cross-examination inquiring into the witness’s own prior bad acts bearing on truthfulness.
Conviction is not necessary. Extrinsic evidence is not allowed.
How can a criminal defendant offer testimony about their own pertinent good character? How can the prosecution respond?
Can offer with reputation and opinion.
Prosecution can test on cross with specific acts or call a witness to rebut with reputation or opinion.
How can a criminal defendant attack a victim’s pertinent character? How may the prosecution respond?
With reputation or opinion.
Prosecution can test witness with specific acts, may call a witness to rebut with reputation or opinion, or offer reputation or opinion on the defendant’s same trait.
What are the exceptions to the use of character evidence to show conduct in conformity?
- Defendant can open the door on their own character.
- Defendant can attack victim
- Prosecution can offer evidence to rebut self-defense in homicide
- Victim’s past sexual acts to show consent, other source of physical evidence, impeachment
- Evidence of similar crimes in sexual assault and child molestation cases
When can a prosecution offer evidence of a victim’s trait? How can the defendant respond?
In a homicide case, may offer reputation or opinion on the victim’s trait of peacefulness to rebut self-defense.
Defendant can presumably respond by testing and rebutting.
What is the rape shield law?
A broad rule that excludes any evidence offered to show the alleged victims sexual behavior, sexual predisposition, or sexual history.
When is evidence of an alleged victim’s past sexual act admissible?
When using specific acts to show:
1. Consent - past sexual acts with this defendant
2. Alternative source of semen, injury, or other physical evidence
3. Evidence that is constitutionally required - impeachment by bias, etc
When is evidence of a criminal defendant’s past sexual crimes admissible?
In a criminal case in which the defendant is accused of child molestation or sexual assault, specific acts by the defendant are admissible if they bear on stuff like propensity, likelihood, and disposition.
The same is true in a civil case.
When are specific acts admissible for purposes other than character evidence?
Motive
Intent
Absence of mistake
Identity (modus operandi)
Common scheme or plan
Knowledge
Oppportunity
Preparation