Civil Procedure Flashcards
What are the 3 ways to establish subject matter jurisdiction in federal courts?
- Federal Question
- Diversity
- Supplemental
What is the well-pleaded complaint rule?
For federal question jurisdiction, the federal law must arise in plaintiff’s affirmative claim, not a defense.
When can a court assert jurisdiction over a state law claim that raises a federal issue?
If the federal question is:
- necessarily raised
- actually disputed
- substantial
- capable of resolution in federal court without disrupting the federal-state balance
What is diversity jurisdiction?
Complete diversity
Over $75,000
When does minimal diversity apply?
Class actions over 100 people and $5 mill
Only need a single plaintiff diverse from a single defendant
What is the citizenship of an individual?
Where they reside and intent to remain
What is the citizenship of a corporation?
- state of incorporation
- principal place of business - nerve center, where the directors sit and control business
What is the citizenship of an unincorporated association?
Citizenship of every member
What is the citizenship of a representative of an incapacitated party?
The citizenship of the the incapacitated party, not the representative
When can claims be aggregated for the purposes of meeting the amount in controversy requirement?
One plaintiff can aggregate multiple claims against a single defendant, even when not related.
Cannot aggregate multiple claims against multiple defendants.
What is supplemental jurisdiction?
Allows SMJ for a claim that does not have federal question or diversity jurisdiction, when related to a claim that does.
When does supplemental jurisdiction apply?
- When the claim is related - arises from the same transaction/occurrence
- When the anchor claim is a federal question
- If anchor claim is diversity, then only if the claim is not by plaintiff against joinded party (stacked or 3rd party defendant) —> no sneaky plaintiff
- If there isn’t a federalism issue or other compelling reason to deny supplemental jurisdiction
What is removal?
D can remove from state to federal court if the case could have originally been filed in federal court.
All defendants must agree.
What is the home state defendant rule?
D cannot remove for diversity if the case was originally filed in their home state.
What is the timeline for removal?
D must remove within 30 days of when the grounds for removal became apparent.
If diversity, D must remove within 1 year of filing.
What are the steps for personal jurisdiction?
- Authorization for jurisdiction in state statute - long arm statute, etc.
- 14th amendment due process concerns
When is personal jurisdiction constitutional under due process?
- Residency
- Consent or waiver
- Service
- Minimum contacts
- At home general jurisdiction
What is the test for minimum contacts?
- D has minimum contacts with the forum state
- The claim against D arises from the contacts
- PJ will not offend the traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice
Where is venue appropriate?
- If all defendants reside in the same state —> a district where any single defendant resides
- The district where a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred, or the property that is the subject of the action
- If nothing else, then the district in which any defendant would be subject to personal jurisdiction.
When can the venue be transferred?
- convenience
- agreement of the parties
- interest of justice (if improper)
What is forum non conveniens?
If the most convenient forum is not in the US, the court cannot transfer, but will dismiss without prejudice so that the plaintiff can refile in the proper country.
What are the steps of Erie Analysis?
- Apply Constitution or federal statute, if valid and on point.
- must not abridge, enlarge, or modify any substantive right
- If not, apply ordinary practices, unless it would lead to unfairness or forum shopping.
- if there’s an issue, apply state law so that the law is the same regardless of whether federal or state court
What must the complaint include?
- Grounds for SMJ
- Statement of facts that are sufficient to show that P is entitled for relief
- must be plausible - Demand for judgement and relief sought
How long does a party have to amend a complaint or answer?
21 days after serving
One amendment by right, then whenever with the consent of the court.
When can a party amend a complaint?
Once as a matter of right
More if permission of opposing parties or court
When will an amendment to a complaint adding a claim relate back to the original filing date?
When the claim arises from the same transaction or occurrence.
When will an amendment to a complaint adding a new party relate back to original filing date?
- the new claim arises from the same transaction and occurrence
- the new party knew of the suit soon enough to not be prejudiced
AND - the new party should have expected to be named, but for a mistake in identity
Who can serve process and when?
Anyone at least 18 and not a party
Must be served within 90 days of filing complaint
How can process be served to a natural person under the federal rules?
- deliver to defendant
- leave at defendant’s usual abode with a person of suitable age and discretion who resides there
- serve the defendant’s registered agent
- mail with a letter requesting the defendant waive in person service
How can process be served to a corporation, partnership, or association?
- deliver process to an officer
- deliver process to a managing agent or general agent
- deliver process to any other agent authorized by appointment or by law to receive service
When is service sufficient for due process?
When the plaintiff took action that was reasonably calculated to inform the defendant of the action against them
How long do you have to file an answer to a complaint?
21 days after service with process
60 days after waiving process
14 days after a motion is denied, if first response was a motion
How can a defendant respond to a complaint?
- Answer - admit or deny allegations, assert defenses
- Motion for a more definitive statement
- Motion to strike
- Motion to dismiss
What defenses are not waived if not included in the answer?
- failure to state a claim on which relief can be granted
- failure to join a necessary party
- lack of SMJ
What is required to get a preliminary injunction or temporary restraining order?
- notice to the adverse party
- likelihood of success on the merits
- irreparable harm
- balance of hardships
- public interest
- payment of security
When are counterclaims compulsory?
When they arise out of the same transaction or occurrence.
Forfeited if not filed.
When are cross claims permitted?
When they arise out of the same transaction or occurrence underlying one of the plaintiff’s claims.
What is an impleader?
A defendant bringing a claim against a person not already a party
When is an impleader allowed?
Must allege that the third party is responsible for all or some of the liability.
Mist file within 14 days of answer, or else get permission from the court