Criminal Law Flashcards
When can an omission create criminal liability?
When the defendant has a legal duty and the ability to act.
- statutory duties (law enforcement)
- legal duty by contract
- status relationship
- voluntary undertaking to rescue that is abandoned
- failing to help after creating the risk
What are the categories of mens Rea?
- purposeful
- knowingly
- recklessly
- criminal negligent
What is purposeful in criminal law?
The conscious objective of the act is to bring about the prohibited result
What is knowingly for criminal law?
The D knows, with almost absolute certainty, that the act will produce the prohibited result
What is recklessness for criminal law?
The D is aware the conduct creates an unjustifiable risk, but ignores the risk and engages in the conduct anyway
What is criminal negligence?
D creates an unjustifiable risk without subjective awareness that they are doing so, but a reasonable person would have been aware of the risk.
What is specific intent?
The D intended to create a specifically prohibited harm - includes purposeful or knowingly.
Nullified by honest but unreasonable mistake of fact or voluntary intoxication
What is general intent?
Only requires a desire to do the prohibited act - includes reckless and negligent.
Nullified by an honest and reasonable mistake of fact
What is transferred intent?
When the defendant intends to produce a criminal result against one party, but harms another instead. The intent is transferred from the intended victim to the actual victim.
What is concurrence?
The act that caused the criminal result must be actuated but the requisite criminal state of mind.
What are the three tests for actual cause in criminal law?
- but for
- substantial factor
- acceleration
What are the elements of a criminal offense?
- Actus reus - voluntary criminal at
- mens Rea - state of mind
- actual cause
- proximate cause
What breaks the chain of causation for proximate cause in criminal cases?
Unforeseeable intervening events. Grossly negligent or reckless conduct. Independent/coincidental interventions, when not foreseeable.
What is murder?
Unlawful killing of a human being with malice.
How is malice established for murder?
- intent to kill
- intent to cause serious bodily injury
- depraved heart murder
What is depraved heart murder?
Unintentional killing resulting from
reckless of grossly negligent conduct
That creates an extreme risk to others
And demonstrates a wonton indifference to human life and a conscious disregard of an unreasonable risk of death or serious bodily injury
What is felony murder?
An intentional or accidental killing
Proximately caused
During the commission or attempted commission
Of a serious or inherently dangerous felony
What are serious or inherently dangerous felonies for felony murder?
- burglary
- arson
- rape
- robbery
- kidnapping
What felonies are not included for felony murder?
Felonies that are not independent of the killing. Felonies where the primary purpose is to cause serious physical harm.
-manslaughter
- aggregated battery
- aggregated assault
- mayhem
When does the felony begin and end for purposes of felony murder?
- Begins when the defendant could be convicted of attempt
- Ends when the defendant reaches temporary safety
What is the modern majority rule for co-felony responsibility for felony murder?
Limits felony murder to killings committed by co-felons. Exempts responsibility for killings committed by non-felons. Agency theory.
What is the common law rule for co-felon responsibility for felony murder?
Felony murder attaches to all felons for any homicide committed during a felony. Only requires proximate cause.
Redline limitation - co-felon exempt if police or victim kills a co-felon.
What is required for first-degree murder?
Premeditation and deliberation
What is premeditation?
The defendant must think about the act of killing.
Common law - can premeditate immediately
Modern majority - some time is required to think.
What is deliberation?
The defendant must make the deliberate choice to kill, requires rational thought
What is voluntary manslaughter?
An intentional killing mitigated by adequate provocation or other circumstances negating malice. Heat of passion.
What is adequate provocation?
Objective component - would lead a reasonable person to lose self control, reasonable person wouldn’t have cooled off.
Subjective component - must be causal connection, defendant must have been provoked and not cooled off.
What is involuntary manslaughter?
An unintentional killing resulting from unjustified risk creation (recklessness or gross negligence) that is not sufficiently to rise to the level of implied malice.
What is imperfect self defense?
An honest but unreasonable judgement of necessity to use homicidal self-defense or defense of others. Leads to voluntary manslaughter in many states.
What is misdemeanor manslaughter?
An unintentional killing that occurs during the commission of a misdemeanor that is malum in se, or of a felony that is not of the inherently dangerous type required for felony murder.
What is criminal battery?
Unlawful application of force
Knowingly, recklessly, or criminally negligent
What is aggravated battery?
- causes serious bodily injury
- with a deadly weapon
- against a special category of victim
What are special categories of victims for criminal law?
child, pregnant woman, police officer
What is assault at common law?
Attempted battery
What is assault under modern majority law?
Failed attempted battery (regardless of victim’s awareness)
Putting victim in fear of an immediate battery (victim must be aware)
What is aggravated felony assault?
- dangerous weapon
- intent to rape or murder
- protected victim