Ethics, Rules of Conduct & Professionalism Flashcards
Why do we have a Complaints Handling Procedure?
- May protect your firm’s reputation and prevent future complaints.
- Allows the complainant to be heard
How can a complaint be received?
Four main routes in which a complaint can be received:
- Email/Internet
- Telephone
- In Person
What makes an effective Complaints Handling Procedure?
- Fit for purpose (Reflect size and structure of the business)
- Made available to all staff
- Understood by all staff
- Readily be shared with complainants or potential complainants
- Regularly reviewed at senior level
- Ensure a firm has the ability to manage all complaints efficiently
- Agreed with PII/Brokers/Providers
- Provide details of access to independant redress if firms cannot resolve the complaint
- Carefully record all complaints or potential complaints at the earliest opportunity and ensure that they are appropriately selected.
Complaints Handling Procedure
Who does it protect?
Protect your firm’s reputation and prevent future complaints.
Complaints Handling Procedure
What are the two stages?
STAGE I
- Complaint received in writing
- Dealt with by complaints handler
- Confirm receipt within 7 days
- Full response or update 28 days
STAGE II
- Unable to agree a solution
- Independent redress provider
- Consumer Clients / Business Clients
- Resolution - further action / training for firm
Complaints Handling Procedure
What independent redress providers are available?
- The Property Ombudsman Limited
- Property Redress Scheme
Complaints Handling Procedure
I have issued a complaint to your firm and I am dissatisfied with your response, what is your next course of action?
- Pass on to our line manager
- The issue was still resolved, it would then go to his manager (Group Manager)
- It keep going up to Chief Executive and if not resolved the complainant could go to independent redress (Property Ombudsman)
Complaints Handling Procedure
What ADR solutions are available?
Mediation
Conciliation
Arbitration
PII
What is it?
- It ensures that should a firm face a claim, it is protected from financial loss that it cannot meet from its own resources.
- Protects the insured member or firm against the consequences of its liability to pay damages to third parties for breach of professional duty
- Ensure that the firm’s clients do not suffer from financial loss, which the firm cannot meet.
What are RICS standards for a PII Policy?
The insurance must be adequate and appropriate having particular regard to:
- An ‘each and every’ claim basis
- Ensure your policy is written on a full civil liability basis
- The minimum level of indemnity based on the firms turnover in the previous year (Estimated for new firms)
PII
Who does it protect?
- The firm/surveyor against claims made by clients or third parties.
PII
Where can you buy it?
RICS has a list of approved insurers on their website.
PII
What are the minimum levels/excess?
Turnover in previous year: Min. level of indemnity:
£100,000 or less £250,000
£100,001 to £200,000 £500,000
£200,001 to £500,000 £1,000,000
Maximum level of uninsured excess:
Limit of indemnity: Max. uninsured excess:
Up to and including £500,000 < of 2.5% or £10,000
Over £500,000 2.5% of the sum insured
PII
What are the requirements for run-off cover?
- Should a firm cease to trade, the RICS requires firms to obtain fully retroactive run-off cover.
- The requirement is for a limit of £1,000,000 in all for a period of 6 years.
PII
Are you aware of the relevant case law?
Hart v Large
Merret v Babb
What was the case Hart v Large?
RICS Home Survey Standard March 2021:
- Mr Large was found negligent in the advice he gave about damp and damp proofing
- He was negligent in failing to advise the Harts not to proceed with the purchase without a Professional Consultant’s Certificate.
- Had Mr Large given the appropriate advice, the Harts would not have proceeded with the transaction
Mr Large should have been clear on the report about the scope of inspection including limitations, caveats and actions available to the client. He should have recommended further investigation.
What was the case Merret v Babb?
It was a landmark test case which held that, following the insolvency of his former employer, Mr Babb was personally liable for a mortgage valuation (Advice given) carried out several years earlier.
Employees will be particularly vulnerable if their firm or company:
- is insolvent has otherwise ceased trading and has no run-off cover
- is under-insured and cannot meet the full claim
- is unable to pay the excess due under the policy
- is unable to obtain indemnity from their professional indemnity insurers as a result of a coverage dispute
PII
What is the latest update on FIRE?
Since 2020, insurers have imposed a blanket safety exclusion on PII terms provided due to concern following high profile fire safety failures.
- Under the new terms, insurers are not permitted without specific dispensation to exclude fire safety claims on a property four storeys or less.
PII
What is the latest update on CYBER?
There is a new regulatory requirement for for insurers to clarify the cyber cover provided in PII policies
PII
What is the latest update on ASSIGNED RISK POOL?
The RICS has a market facility ARP for if you are unable to obtain PII.
PII
What is the latest update on RETIREMENT?
If you are a member who has ceased trading or retired the RICS requires you to maintain PII run-off cover.
- The run-off requirement of RICS requires partners (including members of limited liability partnerships) and directors of a firm to ensure run-off is maintained for ex-partners, directors, consultants and employees.
- Claims can arise at any time up-to 15 years after the work was undertaken by a member
You set up your own business but you decide to go off on a skiing holiday for 2 weeks, you break your leg and the doctors say you must have complete bed rest and no access to emails or work phone, what do you need in place to cover this situation?
A Locum agreement
You see that a colleague is having some unwanted attention from a male colleague and it has happened a few times, what action if any would you take and what is this?
Consider this as a potential form of workplace harassment. I would go and speak to the male colleague and tell him its not acceptable behavior, I would also report to my senior.
How many different types of RICS document statuses are there
- Rules of conduct for members and firms, updated Feb 2022
- International standards
- RICS Professional Statements
- RICS Guidance Note
- RICS Code of Practice
- RICS jJurisdiction Guide
What is the status of a RICS professional statement; who does it apply to ?
Mandatory
- RICS Trainees
- Members
- Regulated Firms
What information is required by the RICS for registration and in the annual return?
- Type of business and staffing details
- Statutory regulated activities - such as for financial services
- Nature of clients
- Complaints handling procedure and records
- Professional indemnity insurance certificate
- Whether the firm hold clients’ money
How do you keep up to date with current affairs and topic issues?
On mailing list, office discussion, CPD email group, magazines and publications etc
Why do you want to become chartered ?
- Gold standard in my profession
- Offers guidance and support from RICS
- Designation will help my career
- I am committed to lifelong learning
- I want to give back to the up and coming surveyors
What are ethics?
Moral principles that govern an individuals behaviour
Why are ethics important?
- Act as an anchor to appropriate behaviour and ensure consistency and clarity in the market.
- Allows us to provide the best service for the client and recognise the wider public.
What does it mean to act ethically as a Chartered Surveyor?
Acting ethically means complying with standards and ensuring that you are acting on behalf of your clients best interests.
What are the three types of due diligence?
- Simplified Due Diligence – Where you determine the business relationship is low risk of money laundering/terrorism
- Enhanced Due Diligence – for high risk customers and transactions with greater threat to financial sector
- New Customer Due Diligence – doing the checks to ensure your client is who they say they are.
What are the three benefits of regulation for firms?
C-P-S
CPS:
- Confidence - for client as regulated firms are monitored by RICS regulation
- Professionalism - firms have to provide clear, impartial and expert advice
- Security - firms have to have recognised CHP, access to ADR and PII cover
Why doe firms have Terms of Engagement; what should be included in Terms of Engagement?
- Creates a contract with the client and clear definition of what is expected and on what terms etc.
- Sets out the proposed fee basis, payment of expenses and that a copy of the firm’s complaints handling procedure is available upon request.
How would you close down a practice?
- Inform the RICS
- Inform clients and arrange for them to be handed over to a new firm
- Return any clients’ money
- Set-up professional indemnity run-off cover for a minimum of 6 years
- Retain a copy of client files and record for a minimum of 6 years
How long should files be kept for?
A minimum of 6 years before disposing and destroying them securely (although can be sued for negligence for up to 15 years)
What do the new rules state about the use of the RICS logo and designation?
Guidelines for the personal use of the RICS logo and designations by RICS-qualified professionals
With effect from 1 April 2019
- Use of the RICS logo has been restricted to members and regulated firms only
- The ‘regulated by RICS’ designation must be displayed clearly to ensure visibility
- Prescribed text that must be included in the terms of engagement
- Companies are only allowed to use ‘chartered surveyor(s)’ designation in trading name and not company name
How would you limit the risk of working with a client or contractor who may be financially unstable?
Screening process:
- Dun & Bradstreet credit check
- Company search (Account information from Companies House)
- Internet search (Client website for additional information judgement on reliability)
You are a junior surveyor and have been working for a company for six months. You’re given a project that is far above your level ofcompetency, and you are concerned that you may make mistakes due to inexperience. You’re also keen to make a good impression andhave been looking for work that will challenge you and develop your skills. What ethical issues does this situation present?
- Competency
- Honesty
- Taking Responsibility
- Competency is relevant because you lack the level of competency required for the job.
- Honesty and taking responsibility are relevant because you must tell the truth and take ownerships of the decision to inform your senior colleagues.
You have a contract with a client. Halfway through the work, your firm changes its terms of engagement, charging more for certain services.When the contract is complete, your finance department bills the client, who pays promptly. Six months later you notice that they billed themat the new rate instead of the old one. Which of these possible responses are in accordance with the RICS Rules of Conduct?
Contact the client and explain the error, apologise, and arrange for the extra payment to be reimbursed.
You are one of two RICS members working on a project. It comes to your attention the other member is invoicing the developer for a number of days’ work when you know he was not at the site. What ethical issues does this situation present?
The case raises all of these concerns:
- As per ‘honesty/deception’, your colleague is not being honest.
- As per ‘Clients best interests’ this goes against the client’s best interests
- As per ‘acting in a way that promotes trust in the profession’, this threatens to undermine trust in the profession.
- As per ‘whistleblowing’ this raises the question of whether you should blow the whistle.
If your client asked you to lower your fees because of their limited funding, what would you do?
The client would have to pay the required price for the level of service required or reduce the scope of works involved. I could consider if the scope of work could be reduced however on the client request i would not just lower my fees.
How do you know you are competent?
(SKATE)
SKATE
- Skills
- Knowledge
- Attitude
- Training
- Experience
Can you advise somebody as an individual?
- If you have the correct insurances in place
- So long as there is not a conflict of interest
If faced with a situation that you felt was unethical, how would you proceed?
Using the decision tree:
- Do I have sufficient facts?
- Is the matter legal?
- Is it in line with RICS Professional and Ethical Standards?
- Have I consulted with appropriate people?
- Do I have clear reasoning in reaching my decision?
- Would I be content for my actions to be made public?
If answered no to any of the above, I would not proceed with the situation alone and would consult senior staff with direction on how to proceed.
What are the CPD requirements?
- Qualified/MRICS member – 20 hrs per year, min 10 hours formal
- Student member – 48 hrs per year (Min 24 formal)
What is the difference between formal and informal training?
Formal has a learning objectives and a defined learning outcome, I could reference the CPD decision tree for further guidance.
What is a complaints handling procedure?
A procedure to allow and define the procedure for clients to raise a complaints. This may include ADR and relevant timescales for the process.
What options are available if you couldn’t resolve the complaint?
- Property Ombudsman
- RICS Dispute Resolution
- Escalation etc
What is the property ombudsman?
- Free, Impartial & Independent
- Independent government approved body who provides redress to consumers whose complaints are considered on a case by case basis.
- They are not regulators and have no authority to take legal action or dictate action.
Where would you find the RICS requirements for professional indemnity cover?
- Professional indemnity insurance requirements
- Regulation Document Version 9 with effect from 1 April 2022
In relation to professional indemnity insurance, what is the minimum limit of indemnity for turnover under £100,000 (in the preceding year)?
£250,000. This is dependent on predicted turnover based on the previous year’s turnover
The RICS defines 3 levels of cover:
- up to £100,000 = £250,000
- £100,001 - £200,000 = £500,000
- £200,001 + = £1,000,000 of cover
How many years after an instruction has been completed can a Professional Indemnity claim be made?
15 years (Limitations Act)
What type of cover would you need to cover a claim brought after a firm or member ceases to trade?
Run-off cover
In general, what cover do you need?
PII - Public Indemnity Insurance
PLI - Public Liability Insurance
ELI - Employers Liability Insurance
BI - Building Insurance (Own premises)
When closing down a practice what sort of insurance should you take out?
Run off cover
- Run off cover must also be held for a minimum of 6 years for a limit of £1million.
According to the PII Policy Document, if your firm turned over £137,500 in the previous year, what is the minimum level of insurance required this year?
£500,000
What if the loss exceeds the cover provided by the PII insurance?
The professional / firm is liable for the difference – in assets etc
How long should run off cover be around for?
Contract under hand = 6 years, a deed - 12 years, 15 years under the limitations act
How can you avoid the chance of claims?
- Keep full and detailed records of meetings, conversations etc
- Record recommendations and advice given
- Use proper letters of engagement, scope of services and terms of engagement
- Don’t advise on a specialism outside your field of experience
- Use RICS guidelines
- Avoid poor management and excessive workloads
What is meant by the term ‘maximum level of uninsured excess’?
The part of each claim the firm must pay itself
What should you do in case of a potential claim on your PII?
Must notify insurer in the event of:
- An actual claim
- A written or verbal threat of a claim
- Any circumstance that the firm has reason to believe may result in a claim
- Any complaint notified via the firm’s CHP
What year did the Money Laundering Regulations come into force in the UK?
1994