Ethics, ROC, Professionalism Flashcards
When was the RICS founded?
1868
Who and when was the royal charter granted?
By the Privy Council in 1881
How many levels of the RICS are there and what are they?
FRICS, MRICS, AssocRICS, Trainee/Student
What do you need to become a fellow of the RICS?
- Achieving FOUR of the fellowship characteristics (5 years or more MRICS, leadership role, professional/technical achievement, academic achievement or raising the profile of the RICS)
-A portfolio of professional achievement (incl CPD)
How is the RICS regulated?
The RICS is self-regulated and internally monitored.
Bye-laws determine how the RICS is regulated.
(not regulated by the Government or external parties)
Who manages and agrees the strategy for the RICS?
The Governing Council manage and agree the strategy for the RICS.
The regulatory board, audit committee and management board beneath the Governing Council execute the strategy.
What is the aim of the RICS?
- Qualify and equip their members to offer the highest standards of professional service
- Promote and enforce standards
- Lead solutions to the major challenges facing the built environment through professional expertise in the publics interest
Who is the RICS Chair of Governing Council?
Martin Samworth
Who is the current RICS Chief executive officer?
Justin Young
Who is the president of the RICS?
Ann Gray
Who is the RICS young representative?
Sunny-Thomas Obasuyi MRICS from BNP Paribas Real Estate UK
What do you know about the RICS?
Globally recognised professional body
Promote and enforce highest professional standards
Influence policy and embed standards to protect consumers and businesses
134,000 highly qualified trainees and professionals
What do the RICS standard documents do?
- Lay out the ethical, conduct and competence related standards for the profession.
^ As members and firms work to this standard they deliver confidence, transparency and professionalism.
What are the 5 benefits of being an RICS member?
- Status (confidence)
- Recognition (Promote professional)
- Market (Competitive advantage)
- Knowledge (Knowledge sharing)
- Network (Access to other professionals)
What are the new RICS Rules of Conduct?
Rule 1 - Members and firms must be honest, act with integrity and comply with their professional obligations.
Rule 2 - Members and firms must maintain their professional competence and ensure services are provided by competent individuals who have the necessary expertise
Rule 3 - Members and firms must provide a good quality, diligent service
Rule 4 - Members and firms must treat others with respect and encourage diversity and inclusion
Rule 5 - Members and firms must act in the public interest, take responsibility for their actions and act to prevent harm and maintain public confidence in the profession.
When did the previous Rules of Conduct change?
The new rules came into effect on 2 February 2022
The previous rules had been in place for members and firms since 2007.
Why did the previous Rules of Conduct change?
To provide a single document for clarity for RICS members and firms
Now a greater focus on clearer example behaviours, understanding evolving technology and tackling climate change.
What documents does the new ROC replace from the old ROC 2007?
The rules of Conduct October (global practice statement) 2021 will over haul the previous separate documents:
- Rules of conduct for members
- Rules of conduct for firms
- Global professional and ethics standards
- Appendix A of ROC now includes the professional obligations of members and firms.
Explain your understanding of Rule 1?
- RICS members and firms should not allow themselves to be influenced improperly through the acceptance of work referrals, gifts or hospitality.
- RICS members and firms must identify conflicts of interest and decline instruction if required
Explain your understanding of Rule 2?
- RICS members and firms must only act for clients where they have the necessary knowledge, skills and resources to carry out competently.
- Firms must supervise any employees undertaking work on their behalf (i.e. junior surveyor undertaking a complex valuation due to resourcing issues - suitably qualified surveyor should undertake this)
Explain your understanding of Rule 3?
- RICS members and firms must understand the clients instruction, requirement (i.e. timeframe) and objectives before acting on their behalf.
Explain your understanding of Rule 4?
- RICS expects its members to respect the rights of others and treat others with courtesy.
- Everyone is to be treated fairly, illuminating discrimination on age, disability, gender, pregnancy, race, religion, sexual orientation etc.
- RICS member and firms need to a adopt a no tolerance policy of bullying and harassment.
Explain your understanding of Rule 5?
- Members and firms are required to question practices and decisions that they suspect are not right (raise concerns with colleagues, senior management, clients, RICS)
- When making public statements ensure these do not undermine public confidence in the profession
- Complaints to be dealt with promptly, openly and professionally
(useful sense check, if our actions were brought to the media or public forum, would we be comfortable standing behind our actions?)
What are the professional obligations of members?
- Members must comply with CPD requirements (20 hours of CPD, 10 formal hours)
- Members must cooperate with the RICS
- Members must promptly provide all information reasonably requested by the standards and regulation board, or those delegated on their behalf.
What are the professional obligations of firms?
- Firms must publish a complaints handling procedure (incl an alternative dispute resolution provider approved by the RICS), and maintain a complaints log.
- Firms must ensure all previous and current professional work is covered by professional indemnity cover (must meet RICS approved standards).
- Firms with sole principal need to make appropriate arrangements for their work to continue in the event of death/ inability to work.
- Firms must co-operate with the RICS
- Firms must promptly provide all information reasonably requested by the standards and regulation board, or those delegated on their behalf.
- Firms must display they are regulated by the RICS (in accordance with RICS policy)
- Firms must report to the RICS any matter that they are required to report under the Rules for Registrated Firms.
How do you demonstrate Professional Behaviour throughout your work / instructions?
- Act honestly and with integrity
- Provide a good and diligent service
- ask myself if I would be happy for my actions / advice to be made public.
What are the RICS requirements for registration of a firm?
- inform RICS of your new practice
- appoint a responsible principle for all RICS communication
- register with the RICS for regulation of the firm by the regulatory board
- professional indemnity insurance
- client money handling procedures
- RICS Valuer registration scheme
- complaints handling procedure, complaints log and complaints handling officer
- logo kit from the RICS
- if sole practitioner - future of business
- CPD logged on online RICS system
- staff training plan
- online annual return each year
- business plan
If you were unsure on whether proceeding with an action or instruction is ethically correct, how would you come to a decision?
I would used the ethics decision tree.
What is the professional and ethical standards decision tree?
Decision making framework to deal with ethical dilemmas
What is the purpose of the ethics decision tree?
Helps RICS members to deal with ethical dilemmas by asking several questions
What are the stages of the ethics decision tree?
- Check you have sufficient facts on the issue
- is it legal?
- in line with ROC?
- Have you consulted the right people?
- clear reasoning for the decision?
- Informed decision?
- Happy for actions to be made public?
Why do the RICS take disciplinary action?
To protect the public interest and safeguard the reputation of the profession.
What can trigger a disciplinary procedure?
- Complaint made to the RICS
- Allegation by a client or 3rd party
- Information received or established by the RICS
Who creates Rules about the exercise of disciplinary powers?
Royal Charter and Bye-Laws authorise the Standards and Regulation Board to make Rules about the exercise of disciplinary powers.
Do you know of a recent disciplinary hearing?
David Laurent didn’t comply with RICS’ requirements in respect of CPD and did not complete and record at least 20 hours of CPD on the RICS CPD portal.
Hearing took place June 2023 - outcome:
Regulatory Compliance Order
- Fine of £300
- Contribute £100 towards the cost of investigation and agree to publication of a summary of the Order for a period of 12 months.
When might a RICS rule of conduct be breached?
- Breaches of professional behaviour (rule of conduct - 1, 2)
- Breach of CPD
What is the first step of disciplinary action and can you explain the process?
Step 1 is a formal investigation undertaken by the head of regulation.
Following investigation they can initiate one of the four following actions if disciplinary required:
- Serve a fixed penalty notice
- Make a regulatory compliance order
- CPD sanctions
- Refer to a disciplinary panel for consideration under the disciplinary rules.
What is a fixed penalty?
Fine and/or caution issued by RICS when a Regulated Member breaches the Rules.
What is a regulatory compliance order?
Used for less serious case:
Procedure to ensure future compliance with the standards. This may include a fine, caution or conditions on the membership of the Regulated Member.
What is the procedure and action by a regulatory tribunal?
Used for more serious breaches
Head of regulation can consider a hearing from a disciplinary Panel, drawn from the independent Regulatory Tribunal.
The Disciplinary Panel will conduct a hearing to hear the evidence supporting the allegations and determine the outcome.
They may:
- Impose sanctions ranging from a fine to expulsion
- Can determine costs against Regulated Members.
What are the penalties of a regulatory tribunal?
- Issue a compliance order
- Impose an unlimited amount of fine per breach (must be proportionate to offence)
- Impose conditions on future continued RICS registration
- Expulsion from membership or remove a firm
- Require a publication of the results of the hearing in the RICS modus, local news etc.
What is a CPD Sanction?
- Place an obligation on a member to follow the CPD requirement.
In respect of negotiating a fee what should be avoided?
- Price fixing
- Aggressive fee cutting
- Collusion with competitors
How should a fee be agreed?
Fees should be market based and on an ad-hoc basis with clients
You can entre into fee negotiations with a client after submitting an initial proposal
Where should a referral fee be stated?
Terms of engagement
What act should be considered when dealing with referral fees?
Bribery Act 2010
What should be included within Terms of Engagement?
Must state in writing:
- Clients agreement to the proposed fee basis
- payment of expenses (and calculation)
- a copy of the firms complaints handling procedure is available upon request
What 3 steps should you follow when considering Terms of Enagagement?
- Check professionally competent
- No conflicts of interest or personal interest
- Confirm TOE in writing and get written approval from the client before starting work on the instruction.
What checks are required for agency work?
(TOEs)
- Compliance with s18 of the Estate Agents Act 1979
- Money Laundering Checks (Money Laundering Regs 2017)
How does your firm undertaken COI checks?
- Emailing staff to enquire about any individual involvement
- Searching the Council’s files database
- Declaring any personal interests in property at
the time of joining the organisation, and throughout
What is the cooling off period for TOEs?
The Consumer rights act allows for a cooling off period of 14 days from the date of agreement.
What is section 18 of the Estate Agents Act 1979?
Section 18 requires agents to give clients information before entering into a contract for agency work including strict details of commission and fees for services other than estate agency work.
When would you decline an instruction? Give me 3 examples?
- Not competent to undertake the work
- Do not have sufficient facts on the issue
- Client won’t sign TOEs or complete AML checks
- Conflict of interest or a personal interest
- Professional indemnity insurance liability cap cannot be agreed
- Advice is for a friend or on a pro bono basis (free of charge for a charity) and PII won’t cover work carried out on a personal basis.
- Potential Client is included in UK Governments sanctions list
- Would you be content for your actions to be made public?
If you are considering whether to act for a client, what RICS guidance could you use?
The ethics decision tree sets out a framework for considering whether to act for a client.
When can a conflict of interest arise?
When a member or firms independence and impartiality is threatened due to a conflict between two clients.
Examples include -
- Financial interest
- Personal interest
- Commercial relationships
- Acting on both sides of a transaction
How do you handle a conflict of interest? (Three steps)
- Conflict Avoidance (Y v N)
- (If proceeding) Written advice to both parties
- Conflict Management (information barrier)
What is conflict avoidance?
When you determine if the conflict is irresolvable because your impartiality is compromised and if so you do not accept the instruction
What is written advice to both parties (COI)?
If wish to accept an instruction set out in writing following 3 points:
- Disclose nature of conflict (facts and how firm intends to manage this)
- Be Clear - ensure both parties can make their own decision (advise to seek independent advice if required)
- Request confirmation form both clients of their informed consent that the firm can act in accordance with the proposed procedure.
What is conflict management?
When the instruction is accepted and steps are agreed and put in place to manage the conflict.
i.e. information / ethical barrier with the written agreement of all parties
What is an information barrier?
Physical and/or electronic separation of individuals (or groups of individuals) within the same firm that prevents confidential information passing
between them.
Tell us about the RICS Professional Standard on COI?
- Dated 2017 came into effect January 2018
- Previously a Professional Statement
- States a member must not advise or represent a client where doing so would involve a conflict of interest or a potential conflict of interest (unless you have informed consent)
What is informed consent?
Informed consent is consent given willingly by a party who may be affected by
a Conflict of Interest.
Subject to that party demonstrating they understand:
- there is a COI or potential COI
- the facts known by the RICS member / firm that are significant in the COI
- the nature of the conflict
- that the conflict may effect advice provided by the firm or their ability to act fully in the interests of a client.
When should an RICS member or firm seek informed consent?
When a member or firm is satisfied that proceeding despite a COI is in the interests of all those who are or may be affected and is not prohibited by law
What are the three types of COI defined?
- Party conflict
- Own interest
- Confidential information conflict
What is a party conflict?
- A party conflict relates to work on the same or related instruction for 2 different parties.
e.g. acting on behalf of 2 businesses with the same interests such as competing supermarkets
What is an own interest conflict?
Personal interests conflict with their clients
e.g. financial (shares in a company), commercial or personal relationship
What is a confidential information conflict?
Obligation to provide information to a client might conflict with another clients requirements to keep the same information confidential
What is the main reason for Conflicts of Interest Checks?
To make sure there is nothing in the way of our professional duty to advise and act for clients objectively without impacting other clients, 3rd parties, or our own interests
Why is Conflict of Interest checks important?
Helps maintain our integrity and public confidence in the profession
Why is it important to record decisions made?
For auditing purposes and in case of future investigations
What is confidential information?
Private information (electronically, physically or verbally)
An RICS firm / member’s duty of confidentiality is…
Continuous and ongoing, it applies to past, present and future clients.
COI document places an obligation on firms to…
- Keep records for any decisions made / measures taken
- obtain informed consent (if proceeding)
- Ensure client has full understanding of potential COI including risks and facts
- Must accept that conflict may affect the ability to act in their best interests
How would you seek informed consent?
Use the sample form at the end of the COI 2018 document and consider / amend this.
What do you do if you don’t believe the client has a sufficient understanding of the conflict disclosed?
- Suggest they seek independent legal advice
- Decline the instruction
What happens if a conflict arises during an instruction?
Obtain informed consent before proceeding with duties that could cause a conflict.
What is there is an information barrier already in place?
Client still needs to provide informed consent
How would you ensure an information barrier is in place?
- Separating where people site in offices,
- restricting access to emails and files