EQUITY Flashcards
Describe INTRINSIC VALUE
Value based on fundamental characteristic: 1. Future cash flow 2. Risk operating 3. Risk financial 4. Growth rate 5. Discount rate
What is the best available estimate of intrinsic value according to efficient market theory
Market price
What does Rational Efficient Markets theory say about Intrinsic value, who said it?
Grossman Stiglitz Market price does not reflect intrinsic value Investors would not incur analysts costs otherwise
What is “Perceived mispricing”
Perceived Mispricing = Estimate of True Value - Market Price Perceived Mispricing = True mispricing + error in Estimate of True Value Consists of two components: 1. True mispricing =(unobservable) True Value - Market Price 2. Error in estimate of Intrinsic value = Estimate of True Value - (unobservable) True Value
Going concern
A company that will Continue operations for the foreseeable future in a value-maximizing manner and maintain an optimal capital structure
Liquidation value
Financial distress eliminates human capital, Goodwill etc Liquidation value = Fire sale of all assets and company dissolved Orderly liquidation value=orderly sale of assets. Liquidation value assumes the company is dissolved and assets liquidated
Fair market value
Arms length transaction between knowledgeable willing parties.
True mispricing
Difference between intrinsic value (true price) and market price = V - P
What does convergence from market price to intrinsic price yield?
Realized: Excess risk adjusted return Abnormal return Alpha
INVESTMENT VALUE
- Unique value 2. Particular buyer 3. Premium to Fair Market Value
Mnemonic for equity valuation process
UFSCA Understand the business Forecast performance Select valuation model Convert forecasts to valuation Apply valuation to draw conclusions
What accounts for difference between “going concern” and “liquidation” value?
- Going concern has Human capital that adds value by operating the business 2. Liquidation value is the value by selling all the assets of the business. 3. The value obtained in a liquidation increases with the time available to liquidate assets
Reasons for appraising a private business
- Transactional (e.g. Sale or IPO) 2. Tax (e.g. Estate purposes)
Describe HHI
Herfindahl-Hirschman Index 1. Measures Market Concentration 2. Sum of squared market shares 3. Large values for proposed mergers attract regulatory scrutiny
What are Porters 5 forces?
SERB Substitutes Supplier power Entrants Rivalry Buyer power Substitutes
Describe Porters three generic strategies? What do they show?
They describe strategies for above average performance through competitive advantage Cost leadership - lowest cost produce with sector level quality Differentiation - unique product or service that attracts premium Focus - within a target segment. Establish advantage through cost leadership or differentiation
What are the main components of high quality earnings?
- Adequate - cover the cost of capital 2. Sustainable - Persistant and Recurring
Describe pro-forma adjustments to income statement to assess earnings quality
Exclude non recurring items, e.g. exclude one-off expenses
Issues with non-recurring expenses
Subjective. Reduce operating expense. May be abused.
Describe how a simple regression is used to test for earnings persistence
- Do past earnings model future earnings? Earns(t+1)=a + B.Earns(t) + err
Explain how earnings can be broken down into a better regression model
Break earnings into: 1. Cash Flow 2. Non discretionary accruals 3. Discretionary accruals
Explain the effect of accruals and cashflow on earnings persistence
Greater Accruals are negatively correlated with persistence, lead to lower earnings quality Increased Cashflow is positively correlated with increased persistence. Receivables are a form of Accruals
Which type of accrual is more easily manipulated?
Discretionary “abnormal” accruals.
What accelerates mean reversion of earnings?
Higher discretionary (abnormal) accruals.
What are the main types of earnings manipulation?
- Revenue recognition 2. Expense capitalisation
Provide 3 examples of manipulation of Revenue Recognition
- Bill and hold 2. Channel stuffing 3. Heavy discount
What is the implication of receivables growing faster than revenue
- Receivables is a form of accruals. 2. Revenue manipulation. 3. Check trend of increase in Days Sales Outstanding (DSO)
What is the formula for Days Sales Outstanding
DSO=(avg Receivables x 365) / Revenue
The proportion of X vs Y in earnings indicates Z
X=Cashflow Y=Accruals Z=Warning of low quality earnings.
What does consensus earnings tracking indicate?
Low quality earnings
Warning signs of earnings quality from X such as falling Y and rising Z
X= Data inconsistencies Y= capacity utilisation Z= Sales
Earnings quality is also affected by X transactions such as a large Y to a Z
X=Related Party Y=SALE Z=Subsidiary
What does a trend of increasing DSO imply? What changes the implication?
- A problem collecting receivables 2. Deteriorating quality of receivables (debtors) If trend is in line with industry it may be due to providing looser payment terms than before to compete.
Current operating expenses can be manipulated to increase current earnings by?
- Capitalising part of current expense to increase non-current assets. 2. Depreciating non-current assets into the future.
Falling X with rising Y indicates Z
X=Asset Turnover Ratio (revenue / assets) Y=Net Income and non-current assets Z=Capitalisation (reduction) of operating expense to increase non-current assets and increase net income.
A lower X expense than industry average indicates Y
X=Depreciation Y=increases current net income at expense of future net income
Problematic related party transactions include X and Y
X=shifting company resources to another entity Y=Propping practices - related entities boost profits
Earning quality warnings include mischaracterisation of Cash flow from X as Cash flow from Y
X=financing e.g overdraft Y= Operations
False earnings persistence and masked X can be achieved by classifying Y as Z
X=decline in operating income Y=non recurring income Z=recurring income
What are the two approaches to company forecasting?
- Top-Down 2. Bottom up
Describe Top-Down forecasting
- International macroeconomic forecast 2. National macroeconomic forecast 3. Industry / Sector forecast 4. Asset forecast 5. Company forecast
Describe bottom-up forecasting
- Aggregate company forecasts to give sector / industry forecasts 2. Aggregate sector / industry forecasts to give macroeconomic forecasts.
Contrast absolute vs relative valuation models
- Both are based on going concern 2. Absolute valuation models 2a. Look for intrinsic value 2b. Includes all Present value models 2c. Asset based models - sum of the market values of all components 3. Relative valuation models 3a. Look for comparable assets (that are fairly valued) 3b. Based on ratios 3c. Price multiples 3d. Earnings multiples 3e. Enterprise values
Describe sum of the parts valuation
- Break-up value / private market value 2. Each business unit valued individually as a going concern 3. Company value is the sum of these.
What does trend in market share indicate?
Competitive Advantage
Sources of company information
Company report Regulators Filings 3rd Parties
What is a conglomerate discount applied to? When is a Conglomerate discount applied?
- Applied to sum of the parts or break up value 2. Due to compensate for: (A) lack of focus (B) Inefficient capital allocation (C) Endogenous factors e.g. the company performs poorly and acquires other companies to improve performance
Explain Conglomerate Discount How does it arise?
- Does not exist 2. Merely flawed measurement A. It arises for endogenous reasons when an underperforming business acquires companies with unrelated business. B. For example on divestment because: - its non-core sale is not damaging (to it) since it does not rely on core business. - it can be fairly valued separately. - its sale price implies a higher break up value than the going concern value of the entire business.
Which valuation model is preferred when financial data is difficult to obtain?
Relative valuation models
What is the formula for Holding Period Return on Equity
HPR=(Price at end of holding - Price at start + Dividends over holding period) / (Price at start)
Holding period return for equity can be broken down into X and Y
X= Price appreciation return (P1-P0)/P0 Y= Dividend return = D/P0
What is the difference between RHPR and EHPR?
- RHPR=historical, past information, the realised HPR 2. EHPR=forward looking holding period return. E.g. future price and dividend
Explain Required Rate of Return
- Minimum compensation for all risk assumed over the period. 2. Opportunity cost of investing in this asset vs a different asset with similar risk.
What is the formula for Expected Alpha? Two other names for expected alpha are X and Y
Expected Alpha=Expected Return - Required Return X=ex ante Alpha Y=expected abnormal return
Describe one of the problems with annualising short HPR
The return may not be realistic for an entire year
What is the formula for realized alpha Realized alpha is also called X
Realised Alpha = HPR - Required Return X= ex post alpha
What are the two components of expected (HPR) return for an asset mispriced from intrinsic value?
- Return from convergence of P to V 2. Required return
What is the formula for return from convergence of price to value
(Vo - Po)/Po
How is EHPR calculated
- Required rate + 2. Return due to convergence
Rearrange GGM to estimate Required Return
Vo=Po=Dn/(Rr-g) (Rr-g)=Dn/Po Rr=(Dn/Po)+g
What is the internal rate of return
Discount rate that makes the PV of all future cashflows equal to the current Price
Critique the statement: “no equity investor needs to understand valuation models because real-time market prices for equities are easy to obtain online”
- Infers all investors believe market prices reflect all relevant information and intrinsic value. (Strong EMH) 2. Active investors do not believe all relevant information is reflected in market prices. 3. Grossman-Stiglitz paradox: if investors do not bother to obtain and analyse information the market pricing mechanism is less reliable. 4. Rational Efficient Markets formulation: investors would not incur costs of gathering data and analysis if there was no possibility of being rewarded. 5. Market prices are not available for private companies 6. Market prices are stale for illiquid stocks 7. Market prices are less reliable for smaller companies with low analyst coverage.
Grossman - Stiglitz paradox
If investors do not gather and analyse information then market efficiency is reduced, which makes it attractive to gather and analyse information stocks because this could reveal mispricing.
Rational Markets Hypothesis
- Grossman-Stiglitz 2. Investors would not rationally incur cost of gathering information unless they expected to be rewarded by higher gross returns
What type of valuation can trigger a spin-off or divestiture?
A break-up value higher than the going concern value
Why is true intrinsic value unobservable?
Because 1. You cannot have full knowledge of all risks 2. There is uncertainty in any forecast