ELSI Flashcards
Roe v Wade
- abortion decision based on viability (24w) and right is based on right to privacy/autonomy
- states can’t make laws forbidding abortion prior to viability
Planned Parenthood v Casey
- allowed states to institute several restriction under “undue burden” test
- permissible restrictions: waiting periods, parental notification, restrictions of public funding
- undue burdens: life of mother, spousal consent
TRAP Laws
- Targeted Restrictions of Abortion Providers
- doctors that practice must have admitting privileges in hospitals within 30 miles, and others
“Script Laws”
mandatory counseling required when someone elects to have an abortion that may spread inaccurate information
Dickey-Wicker Case
no federal funding for work in which embryos created, destroyed, or put at risk
Moral Behaviors
influenced by personal values or belief system
Ethical Behaviors
influenced by deliberate consideration and may utilize professional standards
Professional Codes/Standards
provide guidance but are not binding
2 Ethical Theories of Genetic Counseling
- Ethic of care: based on value of interpersonal relationships
- Principle-based ethics: moral reasoning and analysis; core principles of autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice
Ethical Issues in Research
- privacy, data sharing, and interest of family
- return of results
- commercialization issues
- multiple uses of samples
- withdrawal from research
Nuremburg Code
- list of ethical precepts for research
- attempted to define how one does research ethically with human subjects
Components of Ethical Research
- voluntariness (informed consent)
- experiment should yield results for the good of society and should not be unnecessary
- animal experimentation should have already been done (if applicable)
- reduce risk, pain, suffering
- death or disabling injury should not occur
- degree of risk taken should not exceed benefits
- appropriate facilities and resources that protect experimental subjects
- person conducting research should be qualified to do so
- subjects can always withdraw
- must be willing to suspend research if in best interest
Tuskegee Syphilis Study
- study of African American sharecroppers, 2/3 had syphilis
- attempt to see natural history of disease but subjects were poor, isolated, and uninformed about what was going on; were not treated
- study created outrage and distrust of medical community
Willowbrook
- institution for children with DD/ID
- children purposely exposed to hepatitis to see course of disease and how inoculation worked
- caused harm to a vulnerable population
U.S. Experiments in Guatemala
- deliberately exposed subjects with STIs
- subjects included prisoners, soldiers, prostitutes, mental patients
- attempted to study ability of penicillin to prevent/treat infection but no useful information obtained
Common Rule
- federal policy for human research subjects protection
- sets up IRB and its format/function
- provides additional protections for vulnerable populations (children, prisoners, pregnant women and fetuses, individuals with impaired decision making)
Clinical Equipoise
- question in equipoise generally in doubt
- equally likely that one outcome is true or other true
- in absence of equipoise, other, less preferable approaches may be used to compare alternatives
Therapeutic Misconception
- patients may assume that participating in research is in their best interests
- patients may feel that agreeing to participate is a quid pro quo for receiving treatment
Autonomy
- respect for this based on recognition of intrinsic value of each individuals
- confidentiality (except for mandatory reporting for NBS, communicable disease, birth defects, child abuse)
- truth telling
- voluntariness
- informed consent (full disclosure, establishing capacity)
Decision-Making Capacity for Minors
- cannot give consent but must give assent
- exception is emancipated minor (pregnant, financially independent, married)
Decision-Making Capacity for Mentally Ill
- not permanently incapacitated
- may temporarily lose capacity due to mental illness but can regain it
Beneficence
- professional acts in best interests of patient
- required to do good
- balanced against paternalism
Nonmaleficence
- restrictions on behavior as opposed to actions that promote behavior
- protects individuals, do no harm