Educational Policies Flashcards
- Marketisation policies
Name 6 different marketisation policies
- Open Enrolment
- Formula Funding
- League Tables
- Grant Maintained Schools
- City Technology Colleges
- Specialist Schools
Name 6 different compensation policies
- Education Action Zones
- Excellence in Cities
- Sure Start
- Education Maintenance Allowance
- Pupil Premium
- The Aim Higher Programme
What do grant maintained Schools do?
(Marketisation Policies)
- Schools funded directly by central government –> higher funding.
- Have local management meaning individual head teachers and governing bodies could decide what to do with the schools budgets.
- Provided choice –> diversity, and competition –> get better results in certain subjects –> other schools encouraged to improve grades.
What is the evaluation for Grant Maintained schools?
(Marketisation Policies)
Fitz –> Schools taking government funding and not spending it on improving education but making the environment more attractive and appealing to attract m/c parents and students. This is a method known as covert selection, as w/c students and parents are then put off applying.
What do City Technology Colleges do?
(Marketisation Policies)
- Financed by central government and private industry.
- Subject specific to math, science and technology.
- Provides choice for parents –> bigger selection of different school types to choose from.
- Provides competition for schools –> Other schools have to improve their maths, science and technology grades.
What do Specialist Schools do?
(Marketisation Policies)
- The schools focus on a specific subject and specify in it.
- People send their children there for that specific subject, as staff tend to be more trained in that subject area, therefore they will get better grades in it.
- Provides choice –> parents send children who have an interest in the subject.
- Provides competition –> Other schools need to improve grades in those subjects.
What does open enrolment do?
(Marketisation Policies)
- Provides choice as it creates parentocracy (Miriam David) –> Parents given right to choose where to send their children.
- Parents aim to send their children to the best performing schools, providing competition as all schools compete to attract pupils.
What is the evaluation for open enrolment?
(Marketisation Policies)
- Leech and Campos –> selection by mortgage, move closer to best schools for better chance to get in.
- Bartlett –> best schools become oversubscribed so they select the preferred students through cream skimming (m/c students are chosen), or silt shift (w/c students get offloaded).
What is the role of formula funding?
(Marketisation Policies)
- Funding depends on student numbers.
-Popular schools rewarded, less popular schools given the inventive to improve. - Creates competition –> parents want children to go to the top performing schools.
What is the evaluation for formula funding?
(Marketisation Policies)
- Ball and Whitty –> The middle class schools are given more funding due to more students, so they are able to improve results through staff training, resources etc, so get higher on league table and then get more students due to this. The working class based schools begin with a disadvantage and therefore get stuck in the opposite cycle.
- This creates a reproduction of class inequality.
What are the roles of league tables?
(Marketisation Policies)
- Local and national league tables of schools based on national standardised test results based on the national curriculum.
- Parents provided with the information –> providing choice to choose which school to send their child to.
- Competition intensified between schools as schools are encouraged to improve exam results to improve their league table position.
What is the evaluation for league tables?
(Marketisation Policies)
- Ball, Bowe and Gerwitz: privaledged/skilled choosers –> m/c parents, semiskilled/ disconnected choosers –> w/c parents.
- Gillborn and Youdell –> creates an A-C economy in which schools categorise their children in an educational triage of 1.) pass anyway (m/c), 2.) potential to pass (m/c), 3.) hopeless cases (w/c). The schools put their time and effort into those guaranteed to pass.
How would the Education Maintenance Allowance improve education?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Aimed to widen further education access.
- Introduced in 2004, providing a weekly allowance to 16-19 year olds in low income families who remained in education.
- The money was supposed to be used on travel and resources.
- Pilot studies found that staying on rates increased by around 6% with EMA.
How does EMA compensate for deprivation?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Material deprivation –> Money for resources and transport.
- Cultural deprivation –> Aspiration
What is the evaluation of EMA?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Machin and Vignoles –> had positive impacts but didn’t target the poor alone, students who were disadvantaged chose low income courses.
- Whitty –> EMA encourages w/c to stay in education till 18, but they are discouraged into further education due to tuition fees.
How would Pupil Premium improve education?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Provided extra money for students eligible for free school meals. –> The money went straight to the school, not pupil.
- Aimed to encourage schools to attract and work harder for poorer pupils with the aim of reducing social inequalities in education.
How would Pupil Premium compensate for deprivation?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Material deprivation –> Helps with those who need additional support with funding for their education.
What is the evaluation for Pupil Premium?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Ofstead –> headteachers using pupil premium funds for other reasons such as funding school trips for m/c students rather than funding w/c students education. 1 in 10 headteachers actually used pupil premium to support disadvantaged students.
- Pupil premium –> not enough to encourage schools to take on more disadvantaged pupils due to concerns about league table positions.
How would the Aim Higher Programme help to improve education?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Provided information and activities designed to encourage children to consider the benefits of higher education.
- Geared towards children whos parents had not undertaken Higher Education courses.
How does the Aim Higher Programme compensate for deprivation?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Cultural deprivation –> Reduces class gap going to university, more w/c going to university.
What is the evaluation for the Aim Higher Programme? (Compensatory Policies)
- McKnight, Glennerster and Lupton –> Participation in further education increased significantly under labour, however there was still a significant class gap in continuing full time education.
How does Education Action Zones improve education?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Established in lowest performing inner city areas to encourage to improve the motivation and attainment levels of pupils.
- Included initiatives such as homework and breakfast club.
How does Education Action Zones compensate for deprivation?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Material deprivation –> Provides things and resources for the lower classes that the middle classes already have such as breakfast club and homework.
What is the evaluation for Education Action Zones?
(Compensatory Policies)
- Trowler –> Compensatory policies aren’t the answer, do not reduce inequality of educational opportunity. Inequality in society will always be reflective in education, the only way to fix would be a redistribution of wealth.