Double Effects Flashcards
The action or the deed itself
The matter of human act
The object chosen is a good toward which the will deliberately directs itself.
It can be good, bad or indifferent
Object chosen (Means)
It is the objective of the act
The reason or the intention for doing an act.
Intention (End)
The external considerations of time, place, manner
This answers when, where how or how much.
Can enhance the goodness or badness of a human act but do not render an evil act good and can even render a good act evil.
Circumstances
Is the rule of thumb in naturally good actions.
Too much of good thing is evil.
In so far as evil is concerned, however, even small amount of it is evil.
Moderation
Used in analysis of the moral aspect of controversial human acts
Commonly to evaluate medico-moral problems
Other name: voluntary indirect principle
Principle of Double Effect
Purpose of the agent
finis operantis
purpose of the action
finis operis
An action results in more consequences or effects than what is originally intended or expected
unintended or involuntary
Aware of consequences will ensue, YET do not include in deliberate planning
unintended but foreseen consequences
when we never know what particular effect will be caused by our action
unintended & unforeseen consequences
WHAT IS ONE’S MORAL RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCS OF HIS/HER ACTION
NO moral responsibility
moral responsibility REGARDING THE UNINTENDED BUT FORESEEN CONSEQUENCES
ONE IS MORALLY RESPONSIBLE FOR THESE CONSEQUENCES
Four conditions for a valid application of the PRINCIPLE OF DOUBLE-EFFECT
- the nature of the ACTION (means) is itself morally good, or at least morally indifferent.
- The agent intends (end)
the good effect and precede the evil effect or
At least be simultaneous with it - The good effect outweighs the bad effect in circumstances sufficiently grave to justify causing the bad or at least equal to bad effect
- Intention of the agent should be
directed towards the good effects, never to the evil effect
that the action in question is thought to have two effects: a good one (intended) and a bad one (merely foreseen).
Double Effect