distraction, cognition Flashcards
distraction and intake
Robinson et al., (2013) meta-analysis
* Immediate and delayed increase in intake after distracted food consumption (e.g. distracted at breakfast means may also eat more at lunch- link to memory)
* Paying attention to food linked to reduced intake and enhanced food
memory. (attending meant reflecting on food and other tasks)
- Principles of ‘Attentive’ eating may be important for weight-loss
interventions.
1. Eating devoid of distractions
2. Prompting memory recall of food previously consumed
3. Being aware of food consumed
4. Enhancing memory of food consumed
attention and consumption
Robinson, Kersbergen & Higgs (2014)
* 48 overweight and obese women
* Fixed lunchtime meal
* Focussed attention condition vs. control condition
* Outcomes:
* Consumption of snack food at free eating session later that day
* Memory of meal.
Results:
- Snack consumption 30% lower in focused condition
- Memory for the meal was NOT improved.- more research needed on this memory mechanism explanation
distraction on SSS?
Brunstrom & Mitchell (2006) distraction study - Part 2
* Desire to eat, pleasantness and intensity ratings for Jaffa Cakes and for two
uneaten foods, measured before and at 3 time points after consuming 5
Jaffa Cakes.
* Non-distracted participants showed a reduction in desire to eat the Jaffa
Cakes in comparison to uneaten food (SSS).
* Distracted participants maintained a desire to eat all foods.
* Is distraction important in the context of obesity?
so distraction disrupts sensory specific satiety
the limited cognitive capacity theory:
(Boon, Stroebe, Schut & Ijntema (2002)
▫ Disinhibited intake occurs in restrained eaters if
there are limitations on their cognitive
capacity (demanding tasks), regardless of
emotional component
- if we ask dieters to do somehting when eating, they are more likely to eat as their cognitive resource is taken up so they dont hold their cognitive boundary
▫ High restrained eaters ate more when distracted
compared to unrestrained eaters.
cognition, distraction and intake
- Distraction and intake
- Dieters report higher levels of preoccupying
cognitions than do non-dieters - Associated with deficits in the functioning of working
memory components
cognitive control of teaing- relapse
Abstinence Violation Effect (AVE):
Defined as the negative emotional and cognitive reactions (e.g., guilt, shame, and hopelessness) that occur after breaking a period of self-imposed abstinence (such as dieting or avoiding binge eating). attributions we make to this break affect relapses!
Mentioned in the context of bulimia nervosa and dieting, it suggests that experiencing a lapse can significantly impact success in maintaining dietary goals. (Marlatt & Gordon, 1985)- negative attributions affect relapse rates
Cognitive Dissonance and High-Risk Situations:
Relapse can result from the mental discomfort of conflicting thoughts, such as wanting to maintain a diet but failing to do so. High-risk situations (e.g., stress, social pressure or a buffet) increase the likelihood of this conflict.
Internal, Stable, and Global Attributions:
When individuals attribute their relapse to personal, unchangeable, and all-encompassing factors (e.g., “I am incapable of change”), it amplifies the sense of failure. This is summed up as the mindset of “All is lost,” leading to further lapses- Grilo & Shiffman,
1994)
restraint and working memory
- Poorer recall on a phonological similarity task (phonological
loop) and slower planning times on the Tower of London Task
(central executive; Green & Rogers, 1998). - Evidence of deficits in performance on tasks targeting CE and
PL (particularly phonological store; Vreugdenberg, Bryan &
Kemps, 2003) - Mediating variable of body concern
- Partially mediated by preoccupying thoughts about food,
weight and body shape, but not by BMI or depressed affect
(Kemps, Tiggemann & Marshall, 2004)
USE OF EMA
- EMA involves repeated sampling of an individual’s
behaviours in their natural environment. - Electronic diary or phone app.
- Record responses when feeling a particular way, in
response to an event, or at predetermined intervals
▫ Lots of data
▫ Aims to minimise recall biases
▫ Useful in understanding ‘in the moment’ thoughts,
feelings and beliefs and can provide insights into
individuals experiences.
Randle et al (2023)
* N = 10 studies
* Evidence of within person changes in appetite and affect
accompany temptations and lapses, and are observable in the
moments precipitating a lapse
* Negative abstinence violation effects apparent following a lapse
* Employing coping strategies during temptations is effective for
preventing lapses
* EMA helps to identify real-time opportunities for intervention and
support.