Disruptive Behavior Disorders Flashcards
Core Features of Disruptive Behavior Disorders (DBD) (2)
(1) Age-inappropriate actions and attitudes that violate family expectations, societal norms, and personal or property rights of others
(2) Problems in the self-control of emotions and behaviors
2 diagnoses of Disruptive Behavior Disorders
Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD), Conduct Disorder (CD)
-> High relation with each other
Dimensions of Disruptive Behavioural Disorders
Covert (e.g. alone) ↔ Overt (e.g. with others)
Destructive (e.g. property/aggression)↔ Non Destructive (e.g. substance, angry)
-> Overt-destructive = high risk for later psychological problems/functional impairments
Sibling conflict, hostility, and negativity uniquely predict …
greater emotional and behavioral problems over time
Conduct Disorders = very … group of individuals with the disorder
heterogeneous
Study (Lindheimet al., 2015):
Study looking at diff combination of symptoms of CD + how severe it is.
Results? (2)
(1) There are certain combinations of 2 symptoms that are more severe than certain combinations of 3 symptoms
(2) If cutoff stays 3, we might be missing some high severity people who happen to be right below the cutoff
-> Limitations of DSM-5 and categorical cutoffs
Name of characteristics of ‘with limited prosocial emotions’ specifier
Callous andunemotional (CU) traits
How many youth with CD have significant CU traits?
Very small subset: 2% to 6%
When youth have CU traits, CD is characterized by … (3)
(1) Earlier onset
(2) More severe and more instrumental aggression
(3) Insensitivity to punishment (don’t rly work with operant conditioning → which makes it hard to treat)
Is there a questionnaire/assessment for CU traits? (2)
(1) Inventory of Callous-Unemotional Traits – Frick, 2004
-> Common measure of CU traits
(2) Clinical Assessment of Prosocial Emotions (CAPE1.1) – 2020
-> Semi-structured interview (need multiple information sources)
Can you have CD and ODD
YES they can be diagnosed at the same time (DSM-5)
If you have CD, do you also have ODD most of the time?
Nearly 50% of all children with CD have NOT been diagnosed with ODD
(-> ~50% of children with ODD do NOT progress to more severe CD)
Social causation theory def
Stress of poverty leads to an increase in childhood psychopathology
Social selection theory def
Families with genetic predisposition (bigger diathesis, more biological risk) drift down towards poverty
Great Smoky Mountains Study: Explain Design
- Longitudinal study of epidemiology of childhood psychiatric disorder
- Significant positive association between poverty and disruptive behavior
- Sample included a significant number of Indigenous youth, many of whom lived on a reservation
- Partway through the study, a casino opened on the reservation
- Brought more economic prosperity to the pple living there - changed the conditions of poverty
=> Naturally-occurring experiment
Great Smoky Mountains Study: Explain the 4 groups
- Persistently poor: Before reservation poor, even with stipend poor
- Ex-poor: Crossed threshold, had more money
- Never poor: Always doing fine
- Newly poor (excluded because of small number)
Great Smoky Mountains Study: theories being tested
Naturally-occurring experiment allowed for test of 2 competing theories:
-> Looked at changes in disruptive behavior across time (before vs after opening of casinos & introduction of stipends).
-> Tested social causation vs selection theory
Great Smoky Mountains Study: Results?
Youth whose families were no longer poor due to the stipend from the casino reported DECREASE in disruptive behaviors
-> Results support social CAUSATION theory
(also, mean of disruptive behavior always lower in rich, always higher in poor)
Why is Poverty Associated with Disruptive Behavior Problems?
(Great Smoky Mountains Study)
Follow-up analysis examined possible mediators of the association between increase in income and decrease in behavioral symptoms
=> Found that increased parental supervision FULLY mediated relationship
Among girls, … is more common than physical aggression
=> BUT COMPARED TO BOYS: …
- relational aggression
- girls engage in slightly more relational aggression than do boys, but the difference is SMALL and NOT MEANINGFUL
Correlates of ODD/CD
(1) Verbal deficits
(2) Lower Academic functioning -> Potential stressor/trigger for mood-related symptoms
(3) Antisocial Personality Disorder
(4) Low Family functioning
(5) Peer problems
Boys with conduct problems are 3 to 4 times more likely to die before the age of …
30
More health risks: Personal injury, substance abuse, sexually transmitted infections
Risks for CD/ODD later on in INFANTS (3)
(1) Difficult temperament: Fussy, irritable, hard to soothe
(2) Higher in negative emotionality lower in positive affect
(3) Lower in behavioral inhibition/effortful control
Two diagnostic challenges in CD/ODD when talking about preschoolers
If we look at DSM-5 criteria: no way 3yo meet some of these: Truancy, staying out all night
=> Some diagnostic criteria are more oriented for teens