dispositional explanations of obedience Flashcards
adorno et al 1950
authoritarian personality type- people have an extreme respect for an authority and more likely to be obedient over those who hold power
what are the features of an authoritarian personality type
conventionalism (clear willingness to adhere to socially imposed norms)
authoritarian submission-respect and obedience to those in authority
authoritarian aggression- hostility towards those who do not obey social conventions
rigidity- don’t appreciate others views and emotions
cynicism- display distrust towards others
destructiveness-desire for power and toughness- often relate to personal insecurities
comparison to milgram
significantly different
milgram disagreed that people behave obediently simply because of their innate traits and characteristics
conformist meaning
always do as told
conventional meaning
things that are normal, ordinary, and following the accepted way
dogmatic meaning
unwilling to change views even when wrong
elms and milgram
did milgrams experiment
pp did a personality test- questionnaire about personality- f scale
had brief interviews about the nature of their relationship with the parents and their attitude towards experimenter in milgrams study
findings of elms and milgram
In the obedient group they scored higher in authoritarian traits, they held the experimenter in Milgram’s original study in greater esteem and reported strained relationships with their Fathers in childhood.
stronger levels of authoritarianism amongst obedient pps
no evidence of connections of any other personality variables suggesting evidence was consistant with explanations of obidience in line with the influence of an authoritarian personality type
If this is true, then the situational explanation which Milgram supported may not be the only factor in obedience to social influence
dispositional meaning
adorno
a persons natural tendency/personality traits
situational meaning
milgram
based on a set of circumstances
those in high authority traits
respect and obedience to those in authority
belief in aggression towards those who don’t have the same conventional beliefs
project their own feelings of inadequacy, rage and fear onto a weak group
what is the f scale
measurement of autharialism relies on self- report data
why may the f scale be invalid
social desirability bias