Design and spec Flashcards
Tell me about your preperation of the design and specification of a building project from outline proposals to compeltion of the design and specficiation process.
I have recently been involved with the specification design and delivery of a cyclical redeocration project. The outline proposal was developed from a detail condition survey of the scheme, which reommendations were then included within a report. A significant item was to replace the timber walkway balustrades. However, due to budget constraints and leaseholder S20, the client requested their repair rather than replacement. I completed a detailed survey of all balustrades and quantified the different repairs required. I then specified the type of materials, treated softwood, fixings and decoration requirments.
Talk me through your experience of the specification process, including detailed knowledge of the main methods of specification.
I have been involved with different projects through the entire design and specification process. The process can be intitated at RIBA Stages 0 and continues at 5. For example, in my case study intital design requirements were determined at the strip out stage where a descrptive specifcation of elements meeting building regulations were discussed. For example the requirement of fire compartmentation to the hall and acoustic requirements to the party wall. I would then develop a performance specification that could be issued to the contractor outlining exact materials, methods and standards to be completed. During the project I was completed a prescriptive specifiction of the fire curtain for the contractor to implement that would meet the requirements of buildng regulations part B.
How have you dealt with the design and specifiction process, and its relevance and importance to the procurement and execution of the contract selected for the building works?
I have been involved with projects that have been procured through different contracts. I have developed specifications for fire door sets that are descriptive so that the works can procured through a JCT MW with contractors design to allow for the specialsied contractor to procure materails that met performance requirements.
How have you managed the design process to incorporate design works by other in the specification?
With reference to Hillcrest, the project involved elements of asbestos removal and replacement of meters and electrical services. At my appointment, I informed the client that specialist consultants should be appointed to design the areas around these elements. I appointed an M&E and Asbestos consultant from our internal approved consultant list. I communicated with them and met them onsite to ensure that the objectives/brief was understood. A plan of work and M&E spec was developed that I included within my overall specification.
Hillcrest Fire Remedial WorksWhat materials did you specifiy for the compartmentation to the gas services in the duct?
I specified a gyproc shaft system that would meet the 30 minute fire resistance requirement. I also included a FD30s intumescent grills and mainteance hatches.
Hillcrest Fire Remedial WorksHow did you deal with the ventilation and what guidance a part from the building regulations did you follow?
To address the ventilation within the riser we introduced an intumescent grill at the top of the riser and at the bottom of the riser. We then allowed for the floor slab to core drilled to allow for natural ventilation. I referred to BS 6891 table 6 which outlined a requirement for the grills to be 0.05m2.
Hillcrest Fire Remedial WorksHow did you design access into the duct for mainteance purposes?
To ensure that mainteance access was available to to all of the risers, I specified that a FD30 maintence hatch was installed at high and low levels.
Hillcrest Fire Remedial WorksDid you check the duct where the pipework went into individual flats or other areas?
The view of the gas services were obstructed by the asbestos insulation board within the cupboard. As I was unable to prescribe firestopping works to be priced exactly, I included a schedule of rates within the specification for a range of firestopping works for the contractor to price. I also included within the specification an item for the CA to inspect all areas once asbestos had been removed and new services had been installed.
Hillcrest Fire Remedial WorksWhat building regulations did you comply with?
All works related to firestopping and the new riser fire doors were compliant with building regulations. Riser doors to FD30 and firestopping to maintaint the 60min compartment line. The electrical components of the project would all be self certified. Approved document B.
Wigston Close, Structural worksHow did you incorporate the structural engineers’ requirements into your specification?
I included the structural eningeers requirements as an appendix to my specification document. I then ensured that all prescriptive standards for materials and workmanship were included in my document.
Wigston Close, Structural worksWhat if any immediate work did you specify?
Due to the wall being deemed as a dangerous structure, immediate works involved decanting residents, proping the walls with accrow props and steel beams and hording the external wall to secure the property.
Wigston Close, Structural worksWhat were the additional items that you added to the specification?
Additional items included adding decorations and floor covering to the specifiction.
What is the difference between a performance and a prescription specification?
Performance specifcation - also known as openPrescriptive specification - also known as closedPerformance provides more freedom to contractor to achieve the desired end goal, therefore potentailly finding best value for money. Typically used on straight forward projects.Prescriptive specification sets out exactly what will be expected from the contractor at the end of the project. This enables the client to be sure of what they will get for their investement. Often used in projects where specialist systems are requried.
What type of specifcation did you use in your case study?
The specification used for St Francis house was a mixture of performance and prescriptive. I used presriptive methods for elements that required building regulation control i.e. inuslation, acoutsic plaster board and structure.
What is the defintion of an adaptable dwelling under building regulations part M?
Dwellings that have some features of a fully accessible dwelling such as wider doors but with some omissions. Allowing for the property to be adapated to meet the requirments of the occupants over time.
What is the purpose of Adaptable dwellings?
Occupants who do not require accesible apartments are relcuctant to live in them, this allows for the property to be used and adapted easily.
Warley HillHow did you apply building regulations to the design of the entrance?
External landing with a minimum width of 1200mmLight outside entrance with motion detecotrMinimum clear width opening of 850mmAccesible threshold - level threshold
Warley HillHow did you apply the building regulations to the circulation areas and the door widths?
All doors had a clear opening of 900mm Clear width of hall or landing 900mmLocalised obstructions (radiators) not in front of door ways
Warley HillHow did you apply building regulations to the design of the habitable areas
Minimum clear space in front of kithcen appliances of 1200mmOpener in living room 1200mm above floor level750mm free space to either side of bed
Warley HillHow did you apply building regulations to the design of the bathroom
Door opened outward into the hallwayShower had potentaial for level access adaptationAccess zones for basin and WC
Warley HillHow did you apply building regulations to the desing of the services?
All sockets, stopcocks, controls between 450 and 1200mm above floor level and 300mm away for wallConsumer switches mounted between 1300a nd 1450mmHnadles to windows located at 450mm and 1400mm from floor levelWireless thermostat controls
Warley Hill, Office RefurbWhat was the relevant building regulation and how was it applied to the specification of the polypearl porcuct?
The relevant building regulation is Part L. It required the improvement in thermal performance of the existing elements to have an improved U-value of 0.55 W/m2.k. The polypearl system improved the U value to 0.23.
Tottenham Feasibility Why did you present a range of different options to solve the security issues?
There were leaseholders within the blockClient asked for a range of options relating to costOptions that included the renewal or modifcation of door entry systemThe was scope to re-arrange the bin store within the car park to solve the issue subject to costClient wanted to present options during S20 process
Tottenham Feasibility What options did you present to your client?
Installing a manual swing gate on the existing propertyInstalling a automatic swing gate on the existing boundary lineInstalling a cantilever gate system on now boundary to maximise spaceMoving the boundary line to incorporate a parking space that was currently outside the existing wall
Tottenham Feasibility How did you determine the space outside the existing boundary belonged to your client?
I procured the title plans from the land registry which outlined that the space outside existing boundary was included within the clients freehold
Tottenham Feasibility Were there any regulatory issues you encountered?
Neighbour had an easement through the car parkClient ahd to follow the S20 processPlanning would also be required due to nature of works
Tottenham Feasibility What issues did you encounter with your suggestions
Any automated gate would need to be interegrated with existing entry systemI attendted site with a specclist contractor to determien whetehr it was feasibleDue to age and current condition of system, it could nto be intergratedTherefore, there was a signifcant cost to renew the system
Explain your understanding of the RICS Design and Specification Guidance Note 2013
Provides professional practitioners with best practice guidance relevant to the tasks and processes of design and specification (small to medium projects)Guidance covers; Roles of the lead consultantManagementCommon considerations (compliance, sustainability, safety)Design Process Management Documetnation (documents, NBS, standardsiation)Design Process (RIBA)Specifciation and preperationLegilsative complianceConstruction stageComissionin/Occupation
What should be included in a client brief?
Statement of the problem they want to solveAddress of propertyVulnearble residents/ contact detailsHazards/Asbestos RegisterInstruction f services they want to includeAccess provisions
What is a client brief?
The purpose of a client brief is to provide a firm foundation for the initiation of the project. It is a formal statement of the objectives and functional and operational requirements of the finished project.It should be in sufficient detail to enable the integrated project team to execute the specification and detailed design of the work and is therefore an essential reference for the team
You mention technical standards, name some?
Architects Journal Guidance & ArticlesBritish Standards BRE Digests and Good Repairs Guides English Heritage Journals and Guides
Explain your understanding of the RIBA Works Stages 2020
0- Strategic Definition (clients business case and strategic brief are assessed)1-Preparation and Brief Developing the detail of the brief to ensure that everything needed for the design process is in place.2-Concept Design Getting the concept right and ensuring it meets the clients requirements.3-Spacial Coordination spatially coordinate the design before detailed design is prepared.4- Technical Design Developing the information to manufacture and construct.5-Manufacturing and Construction Building gets built6- Handover PC cert, Insurances, release of 2.5% retention, H&S (O&M) 7-Use Building is in full use until its end of life.
What sustainable considerations do you make during the design stage?
Depends on the projectFuture proof the building? Working to upcoming changes? Local sourced materials Waste management plan (no longer compulsory)uPVC Windows made from recycled plastics etc. Re-Use materials where possible
What considerations would I advise my client of if they were replacing windows?
I would determine determine the property arcitype (flat/house)Advise that houses non-conservation not require planning I would assess the locality (conservation, Listed)Blocks of flats require planning for change of window type.Conservation/ listed require planning (listed building and conservation) areas act 1990
What is MMC? (Modern Methods of Construction)?
Off-site construction methodsControl of sustainability, materials and constructionOff-site Volumetric ModulesOn-site MMC methods Off-site Penalised Systems Off-site Hybrid Systems
What do you include in a feasibility study?
Includes 6 sections 1- Introduction2- Background information 3-Requirements4-Evaluation5-Conclusions6-Receommednations
Explain what is included in a specification?
PreliminariesPreambleSpecification/Materials and Workmanship clausesSOW/Sor and Bill of QuantsDrawings/Schedules
What is a Preamble?
The interpretation / Explanation documentDescription of the parties to the contract Description of Competence Background Summary of Negotiations Tendering Procedure Objectives
What are the Preliminaries ?
Description of the project to allow cost assessment and to specify general conditions and requirements for execution The Site (description, access, parking) The WorksContract Conditions (rectification, payments, insurance, collateral warrantees)Management of the works (working hours etc.) Security, health and safety Site set up and welfare
Explain Fire Door sets?
A door set is a complete unit consisting of a door frame and a door leaf or leaves, supplied with all essential parts from a single source This means that a fire door set is supplied as a complete unit from one manufacturer, so is;Fully fitted up and finished, direct from the manufacturer Fitted with all compatible components and glazing, andPre-essembled in the factory
Explain conservation areas, what statutory consent do you need?
A special consent known as ‘conservation area consent’ is required for the ‘substantial demolition’ of any building in a conservation area, and it is a criminal offence to demolish (or substantially demolish) one without consent.
What works require conservation consent?
Single storey extensions that extend more than 3 metres beyond the back wall of the house (or 4 metres in the case of a detached house) Extensions at the back of a house with more than one storey. Any extensions at the side of a house.Window and door & roof replacement (change of material)
What is a listed building?
A building is listed when it is of special architectural or historic interest considered to be of national importance and therefore worth protecting.As the term implies, a listed building is actually added to a list: the National Heritage List for England.
Explain how you appoint a structural engineer or sub consultant?
Internal List of Approved Consultants Check insurances and previous experience with them Brief them on requirements Check terms and conditions and fee Obtain clients approval and instruct in writing
Explain the types of asbestos and the types of survey?
CHRYSOTILE (white) AMOSITE (Brown) CROCIDOLITE (Blue) Management Survey - Identify and manage (advised)Refurbishment and Demolition - for works at risk of disturbance
What is licenced and unlicenced asbestos?
Most higher risk work with asbestos must only be done by a licensed contractor but any decision on whether particular work is licensable is based on the risk. Licensed work is explained at ‘Licensable work with asbestos’.Non- Licenced - sporadic, low intensity, control, short duration
Explain the advantages of a prescriptive specification.
Prescriptive specifications give the client much more certainty about the end product when making investment decisions (such as when they appoint the contractor), and place a greater burden on the designer to ensure proper installation rather than the contractor.
What is building control? And when is it relevant?
Building control ensures design and regulation standards are met - building regsPut up a new building.Extend or alter an existing one.Provide services and/or fittings in a building such as washing and sanitary facilities, hot water cylinders, foul water and rainwater drainage, replacement windows, and fuel burning appliances of any type.
What would you do if a contractor got to site and recommended swapping a product you have specified?
BS Standard check Statutory affects / planning? Guarantee difference? client approval?Issue a CI design change?
Name some British Standards you have referred to in your specifications?
BS7974- Fire Safety Principles to the designBS 476- Fire testing requirements BS 7913: 2013- Conservation and Hisotric Buildings
What are the different stages of the design process?
0- Strategic Definition (clients business case and strategic brief are assessed)1- Preparation and Brief (Developing the information that the design team will need to commence the design process) Feasibility Studies 2- Concept Design (The concept design represents the design team’s initial response to the project brief)3- Spatial Coordination (Design in which the client’s Spatial Requirements and the spaces required for any Building Systems – such as structural and building services engineering aspects, including grids, risers and plant rooms – have been determined and fixed to allow Stage 4 to progress without any further iterations.)’4- Technical Design (..involves the preparation of all information required to manufacture and construct a building)5- Manufacturing and Construction (Comprises the manufacturing and construction of the Building Systems in accordance with the Construction Programme agreed in the Building Contract)6- Handover PC cert, Insurances, release of 2.5% retention, H&S (O&M) 7- Use Building in use