Democracy and participation Flashcards
What are the 6 features of a democracy?
Participation Education Accountability Representation Legitimacy Scrutiny
What is a representative democracy?
Representative Democracy is where citizens choose others to represent them, making important decisions on their behalf.
Name a country where representative democracy is used.
UK
What are the advantages of a representative democracy?
- The people cannot be expected to have the time or interest to make important and regular decisions
- Representatives can educate the public on political issues
- Representatives ensure the interests of all sections of society (including minorities) are taken into account, and can be held accountable for their decisions
- Representatives are able to ‘aggregate’ the differing demands of people into a more coherent and politically logical programme
What are the disadvantages of a representative democracy?
- Representatives may distort peoples’ demands to suit their political preferences
- Representatives may not make make themselves accountable enough between elections and can only be removed by elections if they lose the respect of the people
- The electoral mandate of representatives is flawed, as voters have to accept or reject a whole manifesto, not being able to make clear which parts of it they oppose, and there is more information in this day and age for people to be able to make better decisions
- Representatives also have to decide whether to be ‘delegates’ for their constituents, merely putting forward their view, or using their best judgement to ‘represent’ their constituents (a concept called ‘Burkean representation’)
What is a direct democracy?
With direct democracy, the people take decisions themselves (e.g. show of hands at a public meeting) or referendums.
Name a country where direct democracy is used.
Switzerland
What is an initiative?
When the people can trigger a referendum by way of petition.
What are the advantages of a direct democracy?
- Gives weight to equal votes, unlike a representative system where the varying sizes of constituencies mean that votes do not all have equal value
- Encourages popular participation in politics by expecting people to take their duties as citizens seriously
- Removes the need for trusted representatives, as people can take responsibility for their own decisions
- Develops a sense of community and genuine debate
- The only true form of democracy (rule by the people), especially as parties and pressure groups are often run by elites pursuing their own agendas, not truly representing the people)
What are the disadvantages of a direct democracy?
- Impractical in a large, heavily populated modern state where decision-making is complicated
- Many people will not want to- or feel qualified to- take part in decision-making, so political activists decide what happens
- Open to manipulation by the cleverest and most articulate speakers, who will persuade people to support their viewpoint
- Will of the majority is not mediated by parliamentary institutions, so minority viewpoints are disregarded (e.g. 48.1% of people voted against Brexit)
- Politicians are (in theory) better informed than the average citizen about the many issues on which they must take a view
- Referendums, the modern-day example of direct democracy is expensive: e.g. the estimated cost of conducting the EU referendum has been put at £142.4 million.
- Politicians will only call referendums if they think they will win
- Referendums can be divisive and controversial, upsetting many
What is a pressure group?
An organisation with shared aims which seeks to influence policy through political means, without seeking political office itself.
BMA case study (ban on smoking in cars carrying children).
BMA’s purpose is to protect interests of doctors (has credibility with the government).
Contributred to the ban of smoking in enclosed public spaces in 2007.
First made case in November 2011 and other pressure groups such as Asthma UK supported.
Case made to House of Lords and a Labour peer introduced an ammendment to the 2014 Children and Families Bill which was passed by Lords and accepted by Commons.
Ban came into force in October 2015.
Showed willing ness to focus on an obtainable goal.
Patient, resourceful and willing to protect children as a vulnerable group.
Occupy London case study-
In October 2011 a group of protesters put up tents in front of St Pauls Cathedral.
Evicted by the order of the High Court 4 months later.
Protested about corporate greed.
Demonstations happened in other places such as Wall Street, NYC.
Drew some attention but not long lasting due to the harshness of authorities.
Their aims were broad and incoherent.
Lacked the capacity to channel its unfocused idealism into practical political activity.
Eight factors that help the success of pressure groups.
- Clear, obtainable goal
- Resources
- Public support
- Strategy and tactics
- Methods and approaches
- Government support/proximity
- Leadership
- Celebrity endorsement (Marcus Rashford- food poverty)
Name three examples of insider pressure groups.
- Trade Union Congress
- Amnesty International
- BMA
What are the features of insider pressure groups?
- Moderate and mainstream
- Broad public appeal
- Meetings + negotiations
Name three outsider pressure groups.
- Fathers for Justice
- Little Amal
- Extinction Rebellion
What are the features of outsider pressure groups?
- Lack of proximity to decision making
- Tend to be small but some are large
- Work more with public appeal
- Can be more ‘theatrical’- e.g. publicity stunts.
What are promotional pressure groups?
- Promote certain ideas, values and interests
- Tend to have open membership
- E.g. Greenpeace and Mind
What are sectional pressure groups?
- Protect/promote the interests of their members.
- Closed membership
- E.g. National Union of Teachers
Name a pressure group which frequently uses TV advertising.
WWF
Name a pressure group which has a democratically elected leader.
NFU
What is pluralism?
Many opinions are shared and many people are involved in decision-making.
Considered to be a good thing in democracy.
Dispersal of power.
What is elitism?
Few opinions are shared and few people are involved in decision-making.
Considered to be a bad thing in democracy.
Concentration of power.
Name three disadvantages of democracy.
Always a minority- ‘tyranny of the majority’
Leads to political polarisation
Could lead to weak governments.
Name three advantages of democracy.
Accurate and fair ‘representation of views’
Ideas can be expressed without fear
Works around the idead of cooperation and consensus.
Participation in the UK.
- Low level of political party membership
- Excluded groups from the franchise
- Low turnout in elections (around 70% in general and 35% in local)
- Young people less likely to vote
Education in the UK.
- Great number and variety of sources of information
- No national political education
- Media bias affects quality of information
- Disproportionate influence of media
Accountability in the UK.
- MPs are elected
- Lords aren’t elected however.
Representation in the UK.
- Wide range of parties
- Disparity in turnout in wards
- Only 650 MPs to represent the entire population
- Many MPs come from a similar ‘entitled’ background
- More pressure groups
- Too ‘London-centric’
Scrutiny in the UK.
- The process of law making
- MP voting records are open to the public
- Freedon of Information Act
What was turnout in the 2019 general election?
67.1%
What was the drop in voter turnout between 2017 and 2019 election?
1.5%