Decision Making Flashcards
What is reasoning?
involves coming to a conclusion based on given premises which we assume to be true
What is decision-making?
involves making a judgment among a set of options, choosing a specific course of behavioral actions from among many possibilities
What is a prerequisite to decision making?
Reasoning
What is rationalism?
the belief in a priori truths, where knowledge is gained through deduction
What is empiricism?
the belief in a posteriori truths, where knowledge is gained through induction
Describe the two broad approaches to reasoning.
- Deductive reasoning: Applying known truths to draw certain conclusions.
- Inductive reasoning: Generalizing from observations to make informed guesses.
Give an example of deductive reasoning.
Premise 1: All mammals are animals.
Premise 2: A dog is a mammal.
Conclusion: Therefore, a dog is an animal.
Give an example of inductive reasoning.
Observation: All the swans I have seen are white.
Conclusion: Therefore, all swans are probably white.
What is a syllogism?
a form of reasoning where a conclusion is drawn from two premises. It typically consists of three statements: two premises and one conclusion.
What are categorical syllogisms?
a type of deductive reasoning that uses quantifiers such as “all,” “some,” or “none” to make statements about categories
How do quantifiers affect the difficulty of syllogisms?
generally easier to solve
What does it mean when a syllogism is indeterminate?
the premises do not provide enough information to draw a logical conclusion
What role do mental models play in solving syllogisms?
- used to represent the information in syllogisms and explore all possible outcomes
- they help in visualizing the relationships described in the premises
Why might syllogisms with negations be harder to solve?
can introduce complexity and ambiguity, making it more challenging to determine the relationships between the premises and the conclusion
What cognitive process is used to solve syllogisms?
Reasoning using mental models, which requires the construction of alternative models
What limitations affect the mental models used in deductive reasoning?
same types of things that limit other cognitive tasks
- working memory
- prior knowledge
- visual imagery
What are the two parts of a conditional statement?
- the antecedent (the “if” part)
- the consequent (the “then” part).
What is the structure of a conditional reasoning task?
If P, then Q. P. Therefore, Q.
What are the actions that can be performed in a conditional reasoning task?
- affirm part of the statement (say it’s true)
- Deny part of the statement (say it’s false)
What is affirming the antecedent?
- The “if…” part of the sentence is true
- this is a cat; therefore it is an animal
- Valid
What is affirming the consequent?
- The “then…” part of the sentence is true
- This is an animal; therefore it is a cat
- invalid
What is denying the antecedent?
- the “if…” part of the sentence is false
- This is not a cat; therefore it is not an animal
- invalid
What is denying the consequent?
- The “then…” part of the sentence is false
- this is not an animal; therefore it is not a cat
- valid
In the Wason Selection Task, what is the rule being tested with the cards E, J, 6, and 7?
“If a card has a vowel on one side, then it has an even number on the other side.”
Which cards should you turn over to test the rule in the Wason Selection Task?
You should turn over the E card (to check if it has an even number) and the 7 card (to check if it has a vowel).
What is confirmation bias in the context of reasoning?
tendency to seek out information that supports a hypothesis or belief, rather than looking for information that could disprove it
How did Griggs and Cox (1982) modify Wason’s original task?
used a real-life scenario involving a police officer checking for underage drinking, where cards represented ages and drinks, which led to better performance in identifying the correct cards to turn over
What is the difference in performance when people test abstract rules versus concrete examples in reasoning tasks?
People tend to perform better when testing concrete, real-world examples compared to abstract rules, as they can relate to familiar situations and patterns
What is a pragmatic reasoning schema, and how does it relate to the Wason Selection task?
a mental framework that helps individuals understand and apply rules in practical situations, making reasoning tasks easier by reducing cognitive load