Death and the afterlife Flashcards
Describe two examples of a physical afterlife
recreation of the Pre-Lapsarian world, God will recreate it here on earth at the end of time
A physical place, another realm or dimension, where our resurrected bodies will live in harmony with God
Describe a non-physical afterlife
a spiritual, disembodied existence, joining with God or your soul coming to God (Beatific Vision)
Give a quote that connotes an embodied afterlife
1 Corinthians 15:20- ‘Christ has been raised from death, as the guarantee that those who sleep in death will also be raised’
Define parousia
The arrival of Jesus and ‘uncreating of earth’. It occurs at the end of time, and all are judged, then the righteous are sent by Jesus to a new and restored world.
Schleiermacher’s criticism of a physical afterlife
The misery of knowing your loved ones are in hell would undermine the blessedness of any physical reality of heaven.
William Lane Craig’s rebuttal of Schleiermacher’s criticism of a physical afterlife
Craig- “God would ‘obliterate’ from the mind of the redeemed any knowledge of the lost person and therefore any feelings of remorse would be gone”
But is blissful ignorance a perfect, heavenly, form of happiness?
Is it what a loving God would do?
Bernard Williams’ criticism of physical afterlife
Concerning the supposed tedium of immortality
Immortality would lead to boredom, meaning it would become intolerable
(But as human’s are currently imperfect, when rid of all selfishness and temptation it would not be boring
But if we are changed completely are we the same person?)
Define ‘Beatific vision’
sight which contains in itself the power of banishing all pain, all sorrow, from the beholder, and of infusing, in their stead, joy and happiness.
Quote in support of Beatific vision
Psalm 17:15 ‘As for me, I shall behold your face in righteousness’
Strengths of Aquinas’ view of a disembodied, not physical afterlife
Beyond time and space, compatible with God’s OMNISCIENCE
No question of spacial LOCATION
No question of what people are physically doing or whether they would be BORED
Weaknesses of Aquinas’ disembodied, non-physical afterlife
If the soul exists timelessly in God’s presence, how is it the same person?
Beatific vision forces us to give up personal identity that survives in the afterlife, nothing remains to link us to our physical selves, so is it really us?
what could Jesus’ resurrection tell us about the afterlife?
He was raised physically, so we too could be raised with a physical body
Quotes from St Paul about disembodied afterlife
‘What is sown is perishable, what is raised is imperishable […] It is sown in physical body; it is raised in spiritual body’
what do both the Catholic Church and CofE teach about non/physical afterlife
Physical place in a new body
quote for disembodied afterlife (Corinth…)
1 Corinthians 15:50 ‘Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God’
Quote for disembodied afterlife (Eccles…)
Ecclesiastes 12:7 ‘Our bodies will return to the dust of the earth, and the breath of life will go back to God)
Define immediate afterlife
A person will be judged by God and enter straight to heaven or hell
Define delayed afterlife
Becomes nothing and then judged at the end of time, when Jesus comes again (Parousia)
Problems with an embodied afterlife
- Negative feelings towards BODY (neither just or benevolent- INCOHERENT).
Refute- Adam and eve felt no shame in Pre-Lapsarian world - Bodies are still present on EARTH. Some people’s bodies are disfigured or cremated
Refute- God gives us new bodies? - Cannot find physical LOCATION
Refute- another realm - Reliance on soul, problem of CONTINUITY. How is the new body the same? If the soul is the essence of a person, why is the soul necessary?
- Some people are disabled on earth, or die elderly or an infant, UNJUST in afterlife?
- Body is SENTIENT and feels pain- need to be kept alive would cause SUFFERING
Issues with disembodied afterlife
- Lack of EMPIRICAL evidence for the SOUL
- Cannot feel goodness or happiness without the SENSES
- Contradicts JESUS’ resurrection
- Are you still YOU without physical form?
Stories in the Bible that involve an embodied resurrection
Jesus’ resurrection
Jairus’ daughter
Lazarus
Questions arising from a belief in physical hell
Physical location
Is physical pain the worst form of torment?
Would we become immune to physical pain?
Is it benevolent to punish eternally?
what happens to physical bodies on earth?
Questions arising from a spiritual hell
Hell is unforgiving
Senses need to experience pain, inc emotional
If you already separate yourself from God in life, is it a true punishment in death
Is separation from God heaven to Satanists?
Quote for physical hell
Matthew 13:50 ‘In that place there will be weeping’