Crime punishment Flashcards
Who would object to CCTV?
privacy campainers
Tony Blair 1993 labour party
‘We will be tough on crime, and tough on the causes of crime’
Wants to please everyone to get votes
2 approaches to punishment
retirbution (right wing) and rehabilitation (left wing)
retribution
make the offender pay/suffer, can be seen as a punishment or a form of revenge
rehabilitation
aims to reintegrate the offender back into society, reforming them and addressing the causes of offending
punishment and self concept - Braithwaite
2 types of shaming through punishment:
1. disintegrative shaming
2. reintegrative shaming
disintegrative shaming - Braithwaite
R
offender is labelled nd stigmatised, affecting their self concept eg being branded. This would lead to more crime accoring to Braithwaite
reintegrative shaming - Braithwaite
L
focus on behaviour, encourage remorse, face up to consequences and make amends whilst avoiding making the same mistakes in the future
left wing approaches to punishment
prevent offending by showing error of ways - impact of crime on victim and society
- community service
- treatment programs eg AA
- restorative justice
Restorative justice
- ‘Crime hurts, justice should heal’ (Braithwaite)
- foster dialogue between victim and perpatrator
- take responsibility for actions
- victim and offender central to process
- high rates of victim satisfaction, low rates of reoffending
UK example of restorative justice
since 2011, all youth crime in Surrey was refered to a panel of police and youth support workers to decide whether they should go to court, be given a caution or a youth restorative intervention YRI
right wing apporaches to punishment
- favour harsh, punitive sentences
- punishment must fit the crime
- deterance, retrubution, public denunciation
Example of right wing approach in USA
‘Three strikes you’re out’ policy involves inprisonment with no parole
Wilson disagrees with Murray as he believes that…….
the certainty of capture is more of a deterent than the potential harshness of the sentence