Contracts Flashcards
Offer - define
Manifestation of intention to be bound.
Applicable law?
Sale of goods: UCC Art 2
Lease of goods:
MBE: CL
NY UCC Art 2A
Other (real property etc): CL
Ad - offer?
Only if quantity specified.
No price stated - indefinite or offer?
Reasonable price applied EXC real property.
Quantity specified as “buyer’s requirement”?
OK. Minor fluctuations OK, not surprising/major fluctuations.
Offer termination - 2 forms
Lapse - reasonable time or stated time
Revocation - direct when received by offeree, or indirect via conduct when offeree aware of conduct.
Irrevocability of offer - 4 types
Option
Firm offer
Foreseeable reliance on offer (eg. Subcontractor)
Performance of unilateral
Option - requirements?
Promise + payment
(No need for merchant)
MBE: Payment always required
NY Payment not required if signed writing
Firm offer - requirements?
Merchant + signed writing Max period - 3 months (even if agreement states longer period) (No consideration needed) (Fallback position) [Art.2]
Foreseeable reliance on offer
Eg. subcontractor’s offer as basis of contractor’s bid
Rare because reliance is usually after acceptance
Performance of unilateral contract
Only MBE - cannot revoke once performance has started (not incl “mere preparation”
NY - can revoke until performance is complete (=acceptance)
Rejection of offer - 3 types
Counteroffer (not incl mere bargaining) Conditional acceptance (=counteroffer) Acceptance varying offer
Acceptance varying offer - Cl/SoG?
CL: Mirror image rule
SoG: 3 conditions for acceptance:
- Both merchants
- No material change
- No objection w/in reasonable time
Acceptance varying offer - when not applied to agr?
Change causes hardship/surprise to offeror.
Improper performance - result?
Simultaneous acceptance and breach.
EXC Sog - goods sent as accommodation (not acceptance yet)
Mailbox rule?
Acceptance - when mailed (even if rejected verbally later.
EXC:
- offer states otherwise
- irrevocable offer - acceptance when received
- if rejection mailed then acceptance mailed - race whichever arrives first
Defenses against formation - 8 types
Lack of capacity Economic duress Mis-rep / nondisclosure material fact Ambiguity / misunderstanding Mistake re material fact No consideration Public policy Unconscionability
Lack of capacity - power to disaffirm/enforce
May disaffirm. (EXC: necessities to live - reasonable value).
May enforce.
Silence after capacity restored = implied affirmation
Economic duress
Rare.
Threat to breach existing contract if 2nd offer not accepted.
and
No reasonable alternative
Misrep
Material fact only.
Even honest.
Mistake re material fact - mutual/uni?
Mutual only!
EXC: Mistake re value.
Uni - no defense, EXC other party knew of mistake.
Consideration - past consideration defense?
MBE: No
NY Yes if signed writing and can be proven
(promise to pay for something already done)
Must consideration reflect value?
No.
Illusory promise?
“I will if I want…”
Unenforceable
Consideration for contract modification?
Art. 2: Not required if good faith reason exists.
CL: Required. EXC if 3rd party agrees to pay.
NY No consideration needed if signed writing
Agr to make partial payment and waive remainder
Due and undisputed:
MBE: Invalid.
NY: Valid if signed writing.
(reasoning: creditor waiving w/o consideration)
EXC: Time-barred (collection barred by state limits): written promise enforceable
Fallback when unenforceable due to lack of consideration?
Promissory estoppel (reliance)
Public policy defenses?
Non-compete (scope, need/uniqeness)
Exculpatory: For negligence OK, for gross negligence of intentional - invalid
Unconscionability - 2 types
Substantive - unfair
Procedural - eg. small print
Statute of frauds - 6 transactions requiring writing
Real property transfer of interest
Performance cannot be completed in 1y.
SoG $500 or more
LoG for $1000 or more (yearly) (Art.2A)
Suretyship (even when not needed for orig debt)
Contract modification (when “as modified” required)
When marriage is part of the transaction.
NY writing requirements
Assignment of insurance policy
Promise to pay discharged debt
Finders fee, broker commission (EXC attorney, auctioneer, licensed realty agent)
Agr cannot be completed in 1y - EXC; when does clock start?
Irrelevant how long it took
Agreement to work for >1y - always needed.
Agreement to work forever:
MBE - no writing. NY writing!
Clock starts when agr made, not when work starts
For “as modified” - EXC?
Agr specifies amendments are only in writing.
CL: not enforceable [applies only to LoG on MBE]
Satisfactory writing - Sale of goods (Art.2)
Quantity term
Signed by defendant
Satisfactory writing - Lease of goods (Art.2A) NY
State it is a lease
Quantity + Duration + Rental payments
Signed by defendant
Satisfactory writing - other contracts
All material terms
Signed by defendant