Conflict of Laws Flashcards
Individual Domicile COL
Where present with
Intent to permanently remain
Infants Domicile COL
Where custodial parent(s) domiciled
Incompetents Domicile COL
Retains parents’ domicile UNLESS
Competent, chose domicile, and
Then became incompetent
Corporations Domicile COL
Always state where incorporated
COL Limitations
Constitution
Statute
Agreements between parties
Constitutional Due Process COL Limitations
Forum state may apply own law to case if
Significant contact or significant
Aggregation of contacts with state such that
Choice of law neither arbitrary nor fundamentally unfair
Full Faith and Credit COL Limitations
Requires forum to apply law of another state when
Forum state has no contacts with or
Interest in controversy UNLESS
Violation of own legitimate public policy
State Statutes COL Limitations
Requires certain COL rules to be applied in
Particular cases
Fed Statutes COL Limitations
Fed statutes may preempt state from claiming JDX
Contractual COL Limitations
Will enforce if:
Valid agreement with effective COL clause
Applicable to lawsuit under terms of k
Reasonably related to lawsuit
Not in violation of public policy of forum or
Another interested state
Exception to Contractual COL Limitations
No reasonable basis for choice OR true
Consent not given due to fraud or mistake
Vested Rights COL
Law of JDX where parties’ rights were vested
i.e. where act or relationship that gave rise to
COA occurred or created
Torts Vested Rights COL
Where last event necessary to make
Actor liable took place
K Vested Rights COL
Where k was executed (validity,
Defenses to formation, interpretation) or
Where performed (performance issues or
Excuses to nonperformance)
Most Significant Relationship (Restatement 2nd) COL
Law of state with most significant
Relationship to issue
Torts Most Significant Relationship (Restatement 2nd) COL
Policy reviewed to determine substantive law Taking into account: Place of injury, Place where conduct occurred Domicile Relationship of parties centered
K Most Significant Relationship (Restatement 2nd) COL
Policy factors
Location of contracting, negotiating, or performance
Where SM is located
Domicile
Default rules UNLESS another state found to
Have more significant relationship
Land K Most Significant Relationship (Restatement 2nd) COL
Law of state where land is located
Personalty K Most Significant Relationship (Restatement 2nd) COL
Law of state where delivery occurs
Life Insurance K Most Significant Relationship (Restatement 2nd) COL
Insured’s domicile.
Casualty Insurance K Most Significant Relationship (Restatement 2nd) COL
Where insured risk located
Loans Most Significant Relationship (Restatement 2nd) COL
Where repayment required
Suretyship K Most Significant Relationship (Restatement 2nd) COL
Law governing principal obligation