Civ Pro Flashcards
Proper Court
JDX over persons involved, subject matter, proper venue
Defendant notice of suit and proper law used
PJ
Proper JDX over the parties
Ways to get PJ
Traditional
General
Specific
Traditional PJ
Personal Service
Consent
General Appearance
Domiciled
Personal Service Trad PJ
Present in the state when served (except when brought via fraud)
Consent Trad PJ
In advance through contract
General Appearance Trad PJ
If negotiates settlement Appearing to confirm settlement Seeking ex parte relief Local agent for service of summons Signing acknowledgment of service form Participation before filing motion to quash
Domiciled Trad PJ
Physical presence
Subjective intent to remain
General PJ
Domiciled for individual
Entity
Systematic and continuous contact with forum OR state of incorporation
Specific PJ Long Arm
Reach beyond own borders to assert JDX over nonresident under certain specified situations
If no long-arm, assumed to be in line with Federal rule
Minimum Contacts Long Arm
“[S]ufficient minimum contacts with the forum state such that asserting jurisdiction over him does not offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice”
Req to Meet Minimum Contacts
Purposeful Availment
Relatedness
Foreseeability
Fairness/Reasonableness
Purposeful Availment
Availed himself the benefits and protections: Presence in forum Doing business in forum Stream of commerce Effects from outside forum Internet sliding scale Property Contracts
Relatedness Minimum Contacts
The closer the contact related to claim less contacts need corp
Always at home in state of incorp and principal place of bus and others that render corp at home
Foreseeability Minimum Contacts
Reasonably foreseeable to be haled into court
Fairness Reason Minimum Contacts
Burden of defendant VS
Forum state’s interest in adjudicating
Plaintiff’s interest in convenient relief
Access to evidence and witnesses
Interstate efficiency
Shared interest in furthering social policy
SMJ
Proper JDX over subject matter
Types of SMJ
Fed Question
Diversity
Fed Question SMJ
I.e. Constitution, federal statutes, treaties
Well-Pleaded Complaint
When the federal law issue is presented in the plaintiff’s complaint only the complaint; not defenses
Exception Cases to Diversity
Probate
Domestic Relations
Req of Diversity
Complete Diversity
Amount in Controversy
Complete Diversity
All Plaintiffs/All Defendants diverse between the v
Where domiciled
Exceptions to Complete Diversity
Interpleader Only 2 adverse claimants Class actions over $5,000,000 Any member of the class diverse 75 persons died from same accident Only one defendant needs to be diverse
Domicile of Individuals Complete Diversity
Physical present
Subjective intent to stay permanently
Domicile of Corp Complete Diversity
State were incorporated
Principal place of business (PPB)
“Nerve center” where officers direct, control, and coordinate the corp’s activities (headquarters)
Domicile Unincorp Ass’ns Complete Diversity
Citizenship of all members
Domicile Incompetent Complete Diversity
Determined by them AND
NOT their representatives
Domicile Alienage Complete Diversity
No fed JDX between aliens UNLESS also US citizens on both sides
Amount in Controversy
Exceeds $75,000 at time of action
Aggregation of Amount in Controversy
One plaintiff v one defendant
Joint tortfeasor defendants
Multiple if common undivided interest BUT may have to pay defendant’s litigation costs if recovers less than $75,000
NOT allowed for counterclaims
Counterclaims not included to meet plaintiffs amount
Compulsory not required to meet
Permissive must meet
Supp JDX SMJ
Allows extension of subject matter JDX when additional claim does not have individual JDX AND based on common nucleus of operative fact
Removal
Move case from state court to federal court if originally could have been brought there
Only defendants eligible to remove UNLESS defendant citizen of forum
To federal district court in same state action is pending
Within 30 days after service of initial summons or pleading
Remand
Attempts to remove are improper
Federal court can remand back to state court
Plaintiff must remand within 30 days of removal
No time limit if no subject matter JDX
Venue
Geographic district that is the
Proper place for particular case to be heard
Place of Proper Venue
District where claim occurred, substantial part of claim arose, where land in dispute is located
District where defendant resides (PJ for business)
Catchall for Venue
If neither claim occurred or defendant resides, then venue proper where any defendant subject to PJ
Transfer of Venue when OG Venue Proper
Can transfer where could have been filed OR all parties consent
Transfer of Venue when OG Venue Improper
Dismiss OR interest of justice, transfer to proper venue
Can be waived by absence of timely objection
Forum Selection Clauses
Generally upheld
Forum Non Conveniens
May dismiss or stay case if far more appropriate forum (another state or country)
Notice
Met if reasonably calculated to apprise interested parties of pendency of action and afford opportunity to present objections
Service of Process
Delivery of summons and copy of compliant
Method of Service of Process
By anyone at least 18 and not a party
Types of Methods of Service of Process
Personal Service
Substituted Service
Constructive Service
Personal Service
Always adequate
Personal delivery to defendant
Substituted Service
Left at defendant’s usual abode served upon someone of suitable age and discretion who resides there OR served to authorized agent
Constructive Service
Served by registered mail ONLY IF defendant agrees to waive service of process
Choice of Law Fed Q
Fed substantive and procedural laws
Choice of Law Diversity
Must apply state substantive law and federal procedural law
Prevent forum shopping if conflict between state law and fed law
If Procedural and FRCP on point, tests unnecessary
Tests for Diversity Choice of Law
Outcome Determinative Test
Balance of interests
Outcome Determinative Test
Substantive if substantially affects outcome
Balance of interests
Fed interest of fed law vs. state interest of state law
If state greater interest, substantive
Pleadings
Documents that set forth claims and defenses
Notice of Pleadings
Provide opposing party with reasonable notice and nature of claim