Company Law - Pre-Module Reading Flashcards
Different legal forms of busines - (a) Introduction: Why set up a business?
- Generally to make a profit.
- Business generates income through selling product and or service and in doing so will incur expenses, as long as the income exceeds the expenses fo business, it will make a profit.
Different legal forms of busines - (a) Introduction: Why do businesses need to raise finance?
- Purchase premises to operate from and any plant and machinary, stock, computers, etc to be able to manufacture and sell goods or provide service.
- To employ staff
- To obtain professional advisors such as accountants
- To expand and grow such as aquiring other businesses, marketing activity, etc.
Different legal forms of busines - (a) Introduction: How do businesses raise finance?
- Owners may investy by contributing capital
- Outside investors may be prepared to make capacity contributions for a share of future profits
- Business may borrow money, such as from bank
- Proportion of profits may be retained to help grow rather than distrbuted to owners.
Different legal forms of busines - (a) Introduction: How much business models be considered?
- Lawyers may have to advise on most ppropiate business model for their business.
- As such, must be aware of the differewnt types and key considerations for each.
Different legal forms of busines - (a) Introduction: What are the business models we consider?
- Sole trader
- Partnership
- Limited Partnership
- Limited Liability Partnership
- Company’s
Different legal forms of busines - (a) Introduction: What are the key considerations when forming a business?
- Costs - How much will this business model cost to set up?
- Risk - Will participants in business have personal liability for debts?
- Structure - Does the business model provide clear organisational structure? Is this flexible?
- Formalities - Are there legal formalities which must be followed and how flexible is model regarding these?
- Privacy - to what extent is information by business required to be publically disclosed?
- Finance - How can business raise capital?
Costs, Entity, Liability, Structure, Filing/procedure, Privacy
Different legal forms of busines - (b) Sole Traders: What is the key characterstics?
- No set up costs - No formalities and sole trader can start trading straight away.
- Entity - Sole trader is not seperate legal entity and contracts from between individual and not a company with third parties.
- Unlimited personal liability - Sole traders personal assets such as home and cars potentially liable to be sold for debts.
- No formal structure - Individual can choose how they wish to run their business.
- Companies House - No filing or procedural requirements for runnign business.
- Complete Private - No need for pubically filed accounts.
Costs, Entity, Liability, Procedural, Privacy, Act
Different legal forms of busines - (b) Partnerships: What are the key characteristics?
- No set up costs - No formalities, partnership can start trading straight away and formed without any formal agreement of even intention. (See below)
- Entity - Not a seperate legal entity and any contracts between third partis and partners in the partnership as individuals.
- Unlimity personal liability - Partners have unlimited joint (in contract) or joint and several (in tor) liability for debts and obligations of the partnership incurred while they are partners so personal assets can be sold to meet.
- No companies house filing or procedural requirements.
- Complete privacy - No requirement for pubically filed accounts.
- Partnerships are governed by provisions of partnership act 1890.
Different legal forms of busines - (b) Partnerships: How are Partnerships formed?
S1(1) PA 1890 defines partnership as “the relation which subsist between persons carrying on a business in common with a view to profit.
This means that they can be created without any formalties and does not need to be an inention, and two or more people workign together with a view to profit automatically form a partnership
Different legal forms of busines - (b) Partnerships: Does a Partnership exist?
S2 PA 1980 contains list of rules determing existence of a partnership and factors include:
- Whether profits and or losses shared,
- If loan made from one partner to another,
- If property is held jointly
- Evidence of profit sharing will be prima facie evidence of partnership but not necessarily conclusive
A loan of money by one party to another does not necessaily create.
Different legal forms of busines - (b) Partnerships: How are the factors applied in determing if partnership exists?
No one factor alone will suffice to create, so necessaily in all cases to consider the facts such as:
- Limited v Minstry of National Revenue: If there is agreement to share losses as well as profits, then this makes existence of partnership more likely.
- Case law also set out if person is not being “held out” as a partner, this makes existence less likely - Walker v Hursch (A clerk lent money to partnership and paid fixed salary and 1/8th of profits and losses but never held out as partner so found no partnership.
Different legal forms of busines - (b) Partnerships: What is it advisable in respect of partnerships and why?
While no formalities, advisable to have partnership agreement drawn up otherwise it will be governed by default provisions of PA 1890:
- S24(1) - Profits and losses: Partners entitled to share equally in profits and must share equally in losses, even where capital contributed unequally. (So, best for express provision to set out profit sharing ratio other wise equal.)
- S24(6) - Remuneration: Partners not entitled to a salary.
- S24(8) - Decision Making: Decisions in ordinary course of business are decided by majority, except for any change to nature of partnership business whcih requires unamninity.
- S25 - Expulsion: Partner cannot be expelled by majority vote unless all partners have previously expressly agreed a majority can do this.
Different legal forms of busines - (b) Partnerships: What is it important for partners to do?
S19 PA sets out partners mutual rights and obligations can be varied at anytime by unamous consent so can themselves draw up the agreement.
However, important in modern days to seek legal advice as default provisions of PA not fit for modern business and such agrements will often focus on:
- Profit sharing ratio
- Salaries
- Decision making
- Leaving rhw partnership
- How to appoint new/remove partners
Two types, Act,
Different legal forms of busines - (c) Limited Partnerships: What are the key characteristics?
LP has two different types of partners:
- Limited Partners: These have limited liability and must not be involved in management of business (often called sleeping partners) and if they do become involved, they lose their limited status and become GP with unlimited liability.
- General partners who run the business and have unlimited liability (traditional partnership.)
- There must be at least one limited partner and one general partner.
LP’s governed by Limited Partnership Act 1907 and must be registered at CH but have no requirement to file accounts.
Different legal forms of busines - (c) Limited Partnerships: What are often used for?
Not commonly for general business but for investement vehicles.
Act, Entity, Tax position, who can createm Liability, procedural CH?
Different legal forms of busines - (d) Limited Liaiblity Partnerships: What are the key characteristics?
- Introduced by LLP Act 2000.
- Key different is that LLP has seperate legal personality and can own property or enter contract on its own behalf.
- Note, for tax purposes, treated as partnershp and members taxed as partners each liable to pay tax on their shares of income or gains (tax transparency)
- S2(1)(a) LLLPA 2000 states two or more persons associated for carrying on a lawful business with view to profit can incorpoate an LLP (Person can be a company as well as individual.
- All Partners in an LLP have limited liability and their liability to TP’s is limited to amlount they ahve agreed to pay under terms of partnership agreement.
- LLP’s registered at companies house as same way as companies and required to file annual accounts and therfore in effect are hybrid between traditional partnership and a company.
Profit sharing, Indemnity, Management, Decision making, expulsion
Different legal forms of busines - (c) Limited Partnerships: What is the orgnaisational strucure for LLP?
Very flexible and should be decided between partners in formal written members agreement, in absence of this, Reg 7 and 8 of LLP Regulations 2001 contain default provisions:
- Members share equally in capital and profits
- LLP must indemnify its members for payouts made and personal liabilities incurred by them in ordinary and proper conduct of business.
- Every member may take part in management but no member entitled to remuneration for managing LLP
- No person can become a member or assin their membership without consent of all existing members.
- Ordinary decision making may be the majority of the members with any change to nature of business requiring consent of all.
- No implied power of explusion of a member by majority unless members expressly provide for such power in agreement.
Entity, Liability, act, Procedural requirements.
Introduction to Companies - (a) Intro: What are the key characteristics?
Companies are the most popular business model and the characterstics are:
- Seperate legal entity and therfore distrinct from their owners known as shareholders or members so the company owns the property, enters contracts, can sue and be sued in name and profits and losses belong to company and not shareholders and therfore liabile for its own debts.
- Limited Liability- Liability of shareholders is limited to amount unpaid on shares (if any) so protects them and facilities investement.
- Governed by Companies Act 2006 which contains detailed requirements regulating how companies run and filings that must be made.
- Formal procedural requirements can be onerous especially for small private companies where shareholders and directors often same.
Introduction to Companies - (a) Intro: Who are the shareholders?
These are known as members are are the owners of the company who invest money in return for shares and possibility of dividends but not involved in day to day management but usually have voting rights on key decisions.
Introduction to Companies - (a) Intro: Who are Subscribers?
Name given to first shareholders in company who invest when is is initially incorporated
Introduction to Companies - (a) Intro: Who are the directors?
- Officers/Managers of the company
- Involved in day to day running of company
- Collectively known as the board
- In small private companies, directors will often also be shareholders
Introduction to Companies - (a) Intro: Who are persons with significant control?
Details of PSC must be provided to companies house, and these are shareholders with over 25% of the shares.
Introduction to Companies - (a) Intro: Who are the other stakeholders?
Anyone interested in the company sch as employees, creditors, etc.
Introduction to Companies - (b) Comapnies Act 2006: What does this govern?
Key legislation which governs companies in England and Wales and primary am was to simplify the law for private companies, changes included:
- Removal of requirement for private companies to hold annual general meetings or submit annual returns
- Codification of directors duties so that directors of small rpviate companies can easily understand obligations
- Allow private companies to pass shareholder resolutions in writing, dispensing with requirement for meetings (general meetings)
Introduction to Companies - (c) Different types of companies: What are the different types of private company?
- Private companies limited by shares (Ltd)
- Private companies limited by guarantee
- Unlimited Companies
Introduction to Companies - (c) Different types of companies: What are elements of private company limited by shares?
- Most common type of company
- No minimum share capital requirements
- Prohibted from offering shares to public
- Can be formed by one person
Introduction to Companies - (c) Different types of companies: What are elements of private companies limited by guarantee?
- No Share capital
- Liability of members is limited to amount they agreed to contrubte in event of winding up
- Membership is not transferable
- These companies are relevatively rare.
Introduction to Companies - (c) Different types of companies: What are elements of Unlimited companies
- Liabiltiy of members if unlimited
- Companies are rare.
Introduction to Companies - (c) Different types of companies: What are the type of public companies?
- Public companies limited by shares (plc)
- Listed companies
Introduction to Companies - (c) Different types of companies: What are elements of Public companies limited by shares (plc)
- They can offer their shares to the public
- Need a minim of 2 directors
- Minimum share capital requirement of £50,000 (S763 CA)
- Requires a trading certificate before it can trade s761
Introduction to Companies - (c) Different types of companies: What are elements of listed companies?
- Only public comapnies can be listed
- Not all public companies are listed
- Listed means admitted on a regulated investement exchange such as London Stock exchange
Introduction to Companies - (c) Different types of companies: How does the CA define each type fo company?
- S4(1) CA 2006 states “a private company is any company that is not a public company” and will end with word Limited or Ltd (s59)
- S4(2) CA 2006 states a public company is a company whose certificate of incorpoation states that it is a public company and ends with Plc or Public Limited company.
For practical purpose, main different is generally only public companies can offer shares to public and are subject to more onerous regulatory requirements.
Introduction to Companies - (d) Key Different between Private and Public companies?: How is the name different?
As mentioned, name of private will end with Limited or Ltd and name of public will end Public Limited Company or Plc.
Introduction to Companies - (d) Key Different between Private and Public companies?: What are differences for share capital?
- No requirement for a private company to have any specific minimum amount of share capital and could be incorporated with just one share of 1p, in practice is is often £1 that is with one share that has nominal value of £1.
- Public company must have share capital with nominal value of at least £50,000 of which at least one quarter must be paid up (paid at time of purchase)
Introduction to Companies - (d) Key Different between Private and Public companies?: What is the director requirement?
Private need only have one whereas public must have two minimum.
Introduction to Companies - (d) Key Different between Private and Public companies?: Are company secretary’s required?
- Private company may choose if to have a company secretary but is not obliged and if they do not, directors or any person authorised may do anythign secrtary is required to do.
- Public company must have a company secretary and person appointed to post must have requisite knowledge and experince and hold one of qualificatiosn speficied in S273(2)
Introduction to Companies - (d) Key Different between Private and Public companies?: Are annual general meetings required?
- Public company is required to have one annual general meeting each year - s336 CA
- Private companies no longer required to hold an AGM, but may do so if they wish.
An AGM provides members who are not directors and opportunity to question them.
Introduction to Companies - (d) Key Different between Private and Public companies?: How are each regulated?
- Public companies are potentially able to offer their shares to the public and therfore they are subject to higher level of regulation than private companies.
*
Introduction to Companies - (e) Benefits/Disadvanges to incorporation? What are the advantages?
- Allows investement with limited liability
- Minimises risk
- Gives a formal structure for the business to run?
- Easier to raise finance through issue of shares/bank loans
- Potential for return on investmeent through dividends
Introduction to Companies - (e) Benefits/Disadvanges to incorporation? What are the disadvantages?
- For small private companies where directors and shareholders same, effective seperation of ownership from control not achieved
- High levels of formality may not be appropiate
- Public disclosures necessary
The company’s Constititon - (a) Introduction: What is it important to understand?
- CA 2006 came into force on 1 October 2009 and prior to this, companies goverend by CA 1985 and as you will deal with companies incorporated before CA 2006, it is important to note some provisions of 1985 still apply
The company’s Constititon - (a) Introduction: What was and is the position for consittional documentS?
- CA 1985 required companies to ahve two constitional documents, the articles of association and the memorandum.
- Under S17 CA 2006, memorandyum no longer forms part of company’s constitution, it is only required as part of procedure to register at companies house.
- Momorandum of company under CA 2006 simply is declration of part of company’s subscribers that first member of company wish to form a company and agree to become members.
The company’s Constititon - (b) Memorandum: What was position for memorandum under CA 1985?
- More complex document forming part of company’s constitution
- Companies could set out constitutional restrictions in their memorandum and were required to include an objects clause setting our purposes for which company formed and anything outside this was acting outcome company’s capacity.
The company’s Constititon - (b) Memorandum: What was position for memorandum under CA 2006?
Companies have unrestricted objects S31 unless objects are specifically restricted in company’s articles.
The company’s Constititon - (b) Memorandum: How does CA 2006 impact memorandum of company under 1985?
Any provisions in memorandum must be treated as provisions of company’s articles so under CA 2006, therefore the object clause of older company continues in force, operating on limitation of capacity unless and until articles of company amended to remove its objects clause
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association: What are the requirements for articles of association (articles)?
- All Companies must have Articles.
- Under CA 2006, articles form main constitional document of a company and purpose of articles is to regulate relationship between shareholders, directors and the company.
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association: What are the examples of provisions within Articles?
- Number of directors required to transact business (both to form a quorum at board meetings and take decisions at board meetings.
- Method of appoointment of directors
- Powers of directors
- How board meetigs are to be conducted
- Any special rights attaching to shares
- How shateholder meetings are to be conducts and
- How and to whom shareholders may transfer their shares
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association - Relationship between CA and Articles: What is the relatonship between CA 2006 and the Articles?
Company’s articles must be interpreted in light of relevant legislation and there is considerable scope of overlap between procedures set out in CA 2006 and those that may be contained in articles.
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association - Relationship between CA and Articles: What must article comply with and what is it known as?
Article must comply with minimum provisions of CA 2006 and this is known as legality test.
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association - Relationship between CA and Articles: Can Articles be more oneerous than CA 2006?
- A company may in certain circumstance provided a more onerous procedure.
- E.G: S154(1) provides that a private company must have a minimum of one director. Company X could set out three directors required and therefore would need to comply with the articles rather than CA 2006.
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association - Relationship between CA and Articles: Can all provisions be more onerous in articles than CA 2006?
No - There are some provisions in CA which override anything in company’s articles such as S321 CA 2006, the right to demand a poll vote at a general meeting cannot be removed in articles.
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association - Relationship between CA and Articles: What do CA provide by default?
Powers available under provisions of CA 2006 unless articles provide otherwise such as power of private company to issue redeemable shares.
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association - Relationship between CA and Articles: What must therefore be reviewed?
**Importatn to check the procedures set out both in relevant legislation and client’s articles. **
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association - Form of Articles: What are the three choices to form of articles?
- Model Articles (MA)/Table A
- Amended MA
- Tailor Made Articles
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association - Form of Articles: What are the model Articles / Table A?
- Sec of State has prescribed MA’s for different types of company under S19
- If new company does not register articles at CH, S20 provides that relevant MA will consistute company’s articles by default.
- This was similar under CA 1985, but these were known as Table A and you may encounter in older companies.
The company’s Constititon - (c) Articles of Association - Form of Articles: What are the amended MA’s?
- Not all provisions within MA’s are suitable for all companies.
- Many choose to adopt MA as articles, but elect to exclude or modify some.