Cognition and Development AO1 and AO3 Flashcards
What is the difference between Piaget’s theory and Vygotsky’s theory?
Vygotsky suggested that cognitive development is a social process and he identified the importance of experts.
How does Vygotsky explain the cultural differences in cognitive abilities?
If a child is said to learn from the individuals around them, it makes sense that they will acquire the ‘tools’ important for their environment
What is the role of the ZPD in Vygotsky’s theory?
- The ZPD is the gap between what the child can understand on their own and what they may understand withh help from an expert
- Expert assistance can help children to cross the ZPD
- He also believed that high mental functions could only be acquired through interaction with others
What is the role of Scaffolding in Vygotsky’s theory?
The kinds of help given to a child to help them cross the ZPD
What are the 5 aspects of Scaffolding?
- Recruitment
- Reduction of degrees of freedom
- Direction maintenance
- Making critical features
- Demonstration
Who identified the 5 aspects of Scaffolding?
Wood, Burner and Ross (1976)
Outline the support for the ZPD (AO3)
Roazzi and Bryant gave 4-5 year olds a task to estimate the number of sweets in a box. On group worked alone while another worked with an older child. The children who received support mastered the task better
Outline the support for Scaffolding (AO3)
Corner and Cross (2003) followed up 45 children in a longitudinal study, who were solving tasks with the help of their mothers at 16, 26, 44 and 54 months. It was observed that over time mothers were less direct and gave more hints. Also, the mothers only offered help when it was needed rather than constantly
Outline the applications Vygotsky’s theory had in education (AO3)
- Peer tutoring and individual adult assistance from teaching assistants has been used to scaffold children through their ZPD
- Van Keer and Verhaeghe (2005) found that 7 year olds who were tutored by 10 year old progressed further in reading than children who were tutored.
Outline the role of individual differences in Vygotsky’s theory (AO3)
- Some children may learn best during social interactions whereas other children may learn better when working alone.
- Also, personality may have an effect on information processing
Evaluate Vygotsky’s theory in terms of individual learning of children even when in a group (AO3)
Christine Howe found that what children learn is considerably different between individuals even when in a group which suggests that children may not always pick up what we expect from interactions
Between what ages does the sensorimotor stage occur?
Between 0 and 2 years old
Outline the sensorimotor stage (0 - 2 years)
- A baby’s early focus is on physical sensations and developing physical co-ordination
- By 8 months they understand object permanence as they know that objects still exist even after they’re out of sight
Outline Piaget’s observation into object permanence
- He observed babies looking at an object when it was removed from sight throughout the first year
- He found that before 8 months the children shifted their attention from the object showing a loss of interest
- From 8 months on, the children continued to look for the object showing that they knew it still existed
Between what ages does the pre-operational stage occur?
2 - 7 years old
How did Piaget test conservation?
- Piaget placed 2 identical rows of counters and the children could understand that that the rows had the same amount.
- When one row was pushed closer together, the pre-operational children usually thought there were fewer proving they didn’t understand conservation
How did Inhelder test Egocentricism?
In 1956 she used the 3 mountains task, where a model was shown to the children and they had to state what a doll could see from different angles. Children in the pre-operational stage couldn’t describe what the doll could see suggesting they were egocentric
How did Piaget and Inhelder test class inclusion?
They showed 7-8 year olds a picture of 5 dogs and 2 cats and asked if there were more dogs or animals. In the pre-operational stage the children usually thought there were more dogs suggesting that they don’t see dogs as a part of the animal class
Between what age does the concrete operational stage occur?
7-11 years old
What are the skills concrete operational children can do?
Conservation, egocentrism and class inclusion
What are the skills concrete operational children can’t do?
Imagining and understanding abstract ideas
What skills are formal operational children able to do?
Focus on the form of an argument rather than the content
What age does the formal operational stage occur in children?
11+
How is formal reasoning tested?
Syllogisms with false content is told to the children
How did Piaget over and underestimate the abilities of children? (AO3)
He underestimated the ability of younger children as modern studies show that children can develop a good understanding of class inclusion and conservation with adult help. Studies have also found that familiar contexts prove pre-operational children to be less egocentric
Evaluate Piaget’s conservation task (AO3)
The children may have thought that Piaget wanted them to say that the counters were different which is why they said so.
McGarrigle and Donaldson (1974) used a ‘naughty teddy’ who moved the counters together and 62% of the children said the counters were the same as before showing they could conserve.
Evaluate Piaget’s class includion task based on findings from Siegler and Sventina (2006)
They tested 100 5 year olds who undertook 3 class inclusion tasks with an explanation after each task such as ‘there must be more animals than dogs because dogs are also animals. The children had a better understanding of class inclusion which contradicts Piaget
Evaluate Piaget’s egocentrism findings using Hughes (1975) task (AO3)
Hughes (1975) used a model using three dolls, a boy and a police officer to test egocentrism in children. 90% of the time children under 4 could place the boy where he wouldn’t be seen by the police officer.
This suggested that children could decentre
Evaluate Piaget’s domain-general approach to development (AO3)
He believed that intellectual development is a single process but research with children with ASD has found that egocentrism, language and reasoning develop separately. For example, children with Asperger’s Syndrome are egocentric but develop normal language skills but other children on the spectrum have problems with language and are egocentric
Outline the role of schemas in Piaget’s cognitive development theory (AO1)
Schemas are packages of knowledge developed from experience.
Children are born with a small amount of schemas but as they grow they have to construct new schemas including the ‘me-schema’ (knowledge about themselves)
What is the motivation to learn according to Paiget? (AO1)
We are motivated to learn when our existing schemas don’t allow us to make sense of something new.
This causes dis-equilibrium and we have to explore to reach equilibruim
How does learning take place according to Piaget? (AO1)
Assimilation is where we add new information to our existing schemas i.e understanding that there are different breeds of dogs
Accommodation is where we form new schemas for dramatically new information i.e. a new schema for an animal with four legs
Outline the applications in education Piaget’s theory of cognitive development has had? (AO3)
Piaget’s theory that children learn by exploring their environment has applications in education.
Children now engage in tasks that allow them to construct their own understanding of the curriculum.
Evaluate Piaget as he underplayed the importance of people in learning (AO3)
Piaget didn’t believe that children learn best in their own but he didn’t focus on that in his theory. But, other theories of cognitive development, Vygotsky’s, outline the importance of other people in learning.
Evaluate Piaget as he may have overplayed the importance of equilibration in learning (AO3)
Children vary greatly in their intellectual curiosity so not all children learn because they want to. His sample were middle-class nursery children who may have more of an interest than other children
Evaluate Piaget as he may have underplayed the importance of language in learning (AO3)
Piaget didn’t focus on language in his theory and he saw it as developing with other skills. However, other theorists have placed importance on language. For instance, children may be unable to express themselves well without langauge
How does Christine Howe’s research support Piaget’s theory? (AO3)
Howe put children between 9 and 12 in groups of 4 to discuss a topic. She found that although they all worked together, they didn’t have the same conclusion which supports Piaget as he stated that children learn by forming their own mental represeantations