Civ Pro Flashcards
Specific PJ requires two things:
(1) A long arm statute (2) that satisfies the constitution (through minimum contacts).
Federal courts decide PJ in the
Same way as the state court in the state where the federal court sits would
There must be enough contacts that the exercise of PJ over the def doesn’t….
Offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice.
To have enough contacts, there must have been 1. and 2.
Purposeful availment
Foreseeability
PJ is improper if the claim ______ relate to the ______ with the forum
Does not
Def’s contacts
The Constitutional analysis for specific PJ is divided into three categories:
Contact, Relatedness, Fairness
The fairness factors to be considered for Specific PJ (ONLY) are
Burden on the def/witnesses
State’s interest
P’s interest
To be proper, service of process must include:
Summons
Copy of the complaint
Service of process must take place within
90 days of the complaint
Service of process can be made through
- Personal service (anywhere)
- Substituted service (abode+suitably aged person+who lives there)
- Service on Agent
- State law methods (where Fed court sits or where service is made)
- To a business’s officer, manager, or agent
Waiver of process has this effect on defenses
none
Unlike PJ, SMJ ______ be waived
cannot
When is the diversity of a case determined for purposes of SMJ?
When the case is filed
Domicile can be changed by
-Physical presence in new domicile
-Intent to make that place your indefinite home
A corp is a citizen of
State of incorp and state of PPB
An unincorporated business is a citizen of
All the states of its members, partners, gen/limited partners
For class actions, the relevant citizenship (in terms of SMJ) is
The class rep
The AIC claim of a P is given
Good faith assumption of accuracy and only overturned if it is a legal certainty that the P cannot recover more than $75k
Aggregation for the AIC of SMJ is allowed if
It is a single plaintiff against a single def
OR
Multiple plaintiffs against a single def for the same claim
The value of equitable relief (for AIC) can be determined by looking at either
the value to the P or the cost to the D
Federal courts will not here the following family law cases including
ISSUANCE OF DECREE involving:
Divorce, alimony, child custody, probate
Collusive change of citizenship for SMJ purposes leads to
the court ignoring that change, finding diversity doesn’t exist
To get into Federal court on Fed Q SMJ, you must
- Include the federal issue in the well pleaded complaint rule
- The claim must arise under federal law
Ask if the plaintiff is enforcing a federal right
A case filed in state court can be removed to Fed court if
The case court have been filed in Fed court
Removal must occur within __ days after the _________
30
filing showing the case is removable
All ______ must consent to removal. No ______ can ever remove.
Defendants
Plaintiffs
Two limitations on removal for diversity cases:
-Home state def rule
-No removal if more than one year has passed since filing in state court
If for any reason other than lack of SMJ, remand must be requested within ___ days
30
Supplemental jurisdiction is possible for Fed Q cases if
the claim has a CNOF (arise from the same T/O)
Supp Jur is proper for Diversity cases if ______. It is improper if ______.
It is multiple P’s aggregating for AIC purpose
OR
D’s are bringing the claims
If P is bringing the claims
Supp Jur is always proper for these cases
Ones that independently meet the Fed Q/DIv requirements
Federal courts must have SMJ over ____ claim in a case
EVERY
If the Supp Jur requirements are met the court still has ____ whether to exercise
Discretion
The steps to Erie Analysis are
- Fed Law beats state law IF on directly point
- If no Fed law on point, is it one of the five issues that is always substantive
- If no fed law on point and not w/in the five categories, determine if the issue is substantive through one of three tests
The five issues that are always substantive for Erie purposes
- Conflict of law rules
- Elements of claim or defense
- Statute of limitations
- Tolling of SoL
- Standard for a new trial due to improper damages
The three tests to determine if an issue is substantive for Erie purposes are
- Outcome determinative test - if determinative, it is likely substantive
- Balance of interests - state v. fed have a greater interest?
- Avoid forum shopping
Venue is proper in any district where
Residential Venue - All def’s reside
OR
Transactional Venue - A substantial part of the claim arose or where the property involved in the lawsuit is located
For venue, the rules on a human and a corp are
Human is subject to Venue where domiciled
Business is subject to Venue anywhere it is subject to PJ