china and korea Flashcards
Yuan overthrowing/ attempt of restoring monarchy
overthrowing:
- boxer uprising against foreigners led to deep dissatisfaction within Chinese society due to economic and social failings alongside increased foreign intervention, exposed weakness of Manchu dynasty
- Yuan approached by manchus to stop growing revolution despite previously being humiliated
- Yuan worked to overthrow monarchy but did not want to hand over power to republicans
- struck deal with Sun Yat Sen that he would convince monarchy to abdicate if he was handed over presidency
- became president in 1912
restoration:
- authority not absolute therefore wanted to resurrect the empire with himself as emperor
- led to rising revolution from beiyang generals, increased determination from opposition
- provinces declared independence from Beijing
- failed to address dire needs for modern republican, led to backlash and contributed to emphasized need on unified, non monarchial state that reflected interests of all chinese people
- Lack of loyalty led to renouncing of throne in March 1916, before he died that year
Failure of Yuan’s republic- financial failings
- by end of 1912 owed more than 170 million yuan
- sharp increase in military expense leading to large volume of printing of notes for military expenses, leading to severe inflation
- failed to impose himself as a leader meaning china failed to develop cohesion
- did not recognize possibilities behind peasant mobilization, contrast Mao
- ruled by corruption, top- heavy bureaucracy within his government, conservative, corrupt and inefficient
- did attempt to respond to needs despite his personal ambition, had some merit
- Yuan relied on the Beiyang Army to suppress opposition (e.g., the Second Revolution, 1913).
Disbanded provincial militias, weakening regional rivals. - A top-heavy, militarized bureaucracy dominated by Yuan’s allies (e.g., Duan Qirui, Feng Guozhang).
- Corruption & Inefficiency: Officials prioritized personal gain over governance.
impact on nationalism:
- weakened public faith in republican governnmnet
- many left disappointed and hoping for democratic china
- abandonment of nationalist ideals, harmed unity and coherence amongst nationalist movements due to conflict and power struggles
Failure of Yuan’s republic- foreign concessions
- 1913 Yuan Shi Kai able to accept large foreign loan by accepting demands of six member international banking consortium which was a part of dollar imperialism
- In 1913, the consortium eventually offered a loan of $100 million but on the following terms:
- China to pledge its future tax revenues as security and to place the administration of Chinese finances in the hands of foreign controllers.
- China to recognize Britain’s control of Tibet.
- China to recognize Russia’s control of Outer Mongolia.
impact
- Led to further loss of Chinese independence, led to condemnation of loan and accused of being guilty of compromising Chinese sovereignty in the same way as Manchus
- GMD too ill organized to have effective opposition left with significant financial burden from foreign debt
- led to 2nd revolution within GMD
warlordism- power vacuum
- Yuan’s death meant on symbol of national unity was destroyed
- roots of democracy were too shallow to survive
- yuan left power vacuum that was filled by warlords due to inability to establish centralized government, led to further lawlessness and disorder that had previously been present during Yuan’s rule
- difficulty in maintaining strong army that was loyal
- areas fell under domination of private armies and military commanders named warlords
impact:
- strengthened the republic’s political divisions and competition between political figures but all not strong enough to impose itself
- created disunity and distress but also urgency for needing strong, centralized state that could protect chinese interests and promote unity
- intensified nationalist feeling in china, gave new purpose for chinese radical movements
- led to intellectual diversity flourishing, engaged in intense discussion for modernization and strengthening
- led to formation of 1st united front
- led to may 4th movement
warlordism- living standards
- warlord common goal of becoming rich
- printed excessive amounts of paper money to fund armies, led to high inflation
imposed taxes and raising existing ones - revived trade in opium
- private armies of warlords were often a law unto themselves, behaving recklessly, harassing and assaulting locals, and stealing or destroying their property
- large number of peasants driven from land, leading to increased unemployment to 168 million of 1925
- majority of chinese especially rural peasantry suffered more warlords than under Qing
counterargument:
- handful of warlords attempted social reform but none entailed significant investment
- a few sincere and meaningful attempts to improve the lives of ordinary people
causes of first united front
- CCP only contained 50 members therefore were ineffective in facing warlords and incapable of becoming revolutionary force alone
- needed an effective army that the GMD forces had
- comintern wanted CCP to ally itself with GMD, thus could infiltrate senior positions to take power
- USSR provided the GMD and CCP with political and military advisers alongside economic assistance
- Sun willing to cooperate as he admired structure russian bolshevik party, saw common ground between revolutionary programme and 3 principles of the people
- first united front formed around common goal of defeating warlords and expelling foreign influence
- created a broad coalition of forces united against external threats
impact:
- enhanced nationalist sentiment and emphasis for needing unification against external threats
- though short list laid groundwork for future nationalist movements by demonstrating potential for unity against common enemies
- alliance with USSR and CCP bolstered Sun’s position as leader in nationalist movement and legitimized GMD role in promoting Chinese nationalism
northern expedition nature
strategy:
- surround individual warlord armies, cut supply lines and destroy them
- Often led to brutal warfare with heavy casualties
- By 1927 captured cities of Wuhan and Shanghai
- Not all of china was defeated of warlords however the GMD was in position itself as legitimate government of China and it could rule the new capital of Nanjing
CCP contribution:
- Many people living under warlord felt resentment toward oppressors meaning the local population was willing to pass on information to united front forces and occasionally assist them
- Mao in particular was well acquainted with peasant associations which enable United front’ units to drive through Guanxi and Hunan and then outflank the warlord armies
- Also contributed troops and disturbed warlord rule through sabotage and organizing strikes and boycotts
nanjing decade- social policies
Peasant life
- 30 million deaths in 1934-35 famine
4.5 % of the population lived in cities the GMD came to represent only a small proportion of the country, and the deprived peasant masses became resentful of the rural elite who also supported the GMD.
- GMD made no sustained attempt to tackle the issue
- Also no genuine attempt at introducing land reforms the GMD promised
- Failed to send the landlord’s control and exploitation of the peasants
- Failed to protect the peasants against excessive rents
- Failed guarantee of fair prices to the peasants for their produce
German influence:
- Formed close ties to the Third Reich sent military advisers to train the nationalist forces
- Seen in the organization of Jiang’s secret police “Blue Shirts” who were similar to the Gestapo
- Some historians argue that based on this the regime itself could be described as “fascist” due to its similarity to the Third Reich
- Similar to authoritarianism, nationalist ideology, policing methods
- ISB or Investigation and Statistical Bureau was a highly effective and feared security organization with 1800 agents working for him
- Operated outside of law, free to arrest and hold suspects indefinitely without having to bring charges
- Used torture and other violent methods to extract information, especially about CCP
agents used as intimidation and threats to extract information but also to suppress dissent in the media
Education:
- The education system was reorganized
secondary education increased considerably and in 1935 the government launched a crash programme of primary education.
- But there were still only 3,000 secondary schools serving half a million out of a population of 500 million.
- In 1932, only 15% of students enrolled in primary schools were girls.
Education in the countryside was neglected.
nanjing decade- economic policy
peasnatry:
- local administration tyrannical and corrupt leading to many peasants living in poverty
- global depression led to disaster for farmers who relied on cash crops
- thus GMD failed to gain mass support in the countryside and lacked control over the peasants
- taxation regressive, poor paying the most. income tax ineffective
- government expenditure went to repaying debt and military cost, limited productive investment
inflation:
- after 1945 cost of maintaining ary of 5 million troops = 80% of government expenditure
- led to heavy taxation and borrowing heavily abroad
- huge military spending and cost of war
- after 1945 inflation became hyperinflation, 1949 monetary policy collapsed, led to demoralization of people and discrediting the government economically and politically
- lynch argues even if they hadn’t been defeated in civil war they may have been unable to withstand impending financial collapse
foreign concessions:
- Many livelihoods of the Chinese depended on being employed by foreigners, thus preventing Jiang and GMD from truly achieving national independence from the 3 principles of the people
- Jiang similarly disliked foreign presence but it was clear that he would need foreign support, especially for the Japanese war
- Legal reforms and restructuring to increase the application of Chinese law in foreign concessions rather than foreign laws
- Higher tariffs and duties for foreign companies to promote local economic development
- China was already unstable had a relatively weak army virtually no naval influence, and would be badly outclassed by colonial powers that held concessions.
nanjing decade- political policy
corruption:
- Elite membership meant that it never became a mass party, only representative of minority interests
- Disregarded rural peasants therefore their interests were not reflected, and conditions in the countryside were not considered, instead focused on urban areas, limiting the extension of the party’s power
- did not control more than ⅓ of China or two-thirds of its population
- did not conquer warlords but simply came to terms with them, led to the prevention of fully controlling china and intensified determination to destroy communists
- faced resistence from local ruling factions which led to failure to declare effective land reforms
- warlords presence still felt in china despite victory from northern expedition
- showed GMD unable to tackle china’s most urgent economic and social problems
- betrayed sense of moral purpose by aligning with worst elements of chinese underworld
- turned to coercion and authoritarianism to consolidate power
- preoccupation with crushing communist opponents meant important energy was diverted from society
underworld dealings:
- GMD was reluctant to forgo income and also relied heavily on assistance from the underworld for anti-communist campaigns
- attempt to bring opium under state control and provide treatment for addicts ended up receiving illicit funding from gangster organizations such as the Green gang
- By the mid-1920s, China was the world’s largest source of opium, producing more than 80 percent of the world’s supply.
- While publicly opium was condemned, behind the scenes it was encouraged and supported and the party benefitted from the opium trade
suggesting the opium trade yielded as much as $US100 million in government income each year.
historiography:
- Hsu: on surface looked like formation of new order out of chaos, however clear fundamental issues of social and economic issues, alongside deficit spending
- sheridan: GMD failed to create the new unity that the nation required, growth in modern sector of economy did occur but traditional rural economy unchanged, society divided between peasantry and urban elite
May 4th movement- causes
- stimulated by warlord period and resentment against Japanese
- antiforeigner reaction and disillusionment with failed 1911 revolution and country’s lack of development
- from 1911 revolution to WWI and 21 demand, china had been humiliated and warlord system established no sense of direction
- WWI allies and urged china and japan to declare war on Germany, china entered after japan therefore had less international standing
- Woodrow Wilson’s 14 Points (1918) promised self-determination, leading China to expect return of German concessions (e.g., Shandong).
- However, Japan had already seized Shandong (1914) and secretly secured Allied support through secret allied japanese agreements and china’s contributions in the war were ignored
- US afraid that after the Japanese racial equality clause was refused and their offense to the restriction of immigration 150000 but specifically asiatics would result in Japan refusing to sign the treaty of Versailles and leaving the LON
- Japan was awarded Germany’s former rights in Shandong, despite China’s protests.
- led to holding of demonstrations against Versailles conferences and ministers that signed agreements
- British lack of resistance stemmed from reluctance to offend Japan as war ally and therefore could not offend Japanese support
- Americans also urged China to join war promising that it would earn them place in post war conferences
may 4th - main ideas and reaction
Main ideas:
- Attack on Confucianism and conservatism
Encouraging use of the vernacular standardized language
- Looked at ways in technology, philosophy, economics to help solve china’s problems, some turn to marxism hoping for unified china that would be able to deal with warlordism, landlords and foreign imperialism
- Much of the original thinking came from Beijing university
- Student supporting ideas and issued publications such as “new tide” which attacked traditional ideas and behaviour and instead advocated western ideas such as science, democracy, individualism
Reaction:
- Led to explosion of anger and intense chinese nationalism
- Chinese protestors protested in streets against allies, japanese and failure of republic to prevent such
- Government ministers physically attacked and anti japanese boycotts organised in Beijing and Shanghai
- Within 1 month protests spread to 20 provinces and demonstrations and strikes occurred in over 100 towns and cities
may 4th movement- intellectual and cultural expression
- intellectuals began questioning western ideas and looked at other models of development such as marxism, anarchism, bolshevism
- Intellectuals freely debated social and political issues, breaking away from traditional constraints.
- Encouraged the development of new literary forms and styles, including vernacular literature.
- University of Beijing professors Chen Duxiu and Li Dazhao encouraged their students to challenge Confucian ideas.
- An act of looking for practical solutions for problems found
- Progressives spoke of ‘Science and Democracy’ as the essential requirements in China’s modernization
- Inspired by the similar way the Industrial Revolution had furthered Western nations
- Moves were made to modernize China’s antiquated forms of written language.
- Introduction or expansion of subjects such as economics and sociology into the Chinese curricula.
- These subjects were regarded as having scientific value due to their empirical methods.
- Acknowledgment that Chinese manufacturing could not be effectively developed without adopting modern production methods.
- Progressive thinkers urged the study of successfully applied Western technology
may 4th movement- social mobilization and national identity
- the movement expanded beyond students to include workers, merchants, and other social groups, marking the first time such a broad coalition united for political change.
- students, workers, and businessmen joined forces against the government’s response to the Treaty of Versailles, setting a precedent for future social movements in China.
- workers in Shanghai and other cities organized large-scale strikes, demonstrating their growing political influence and pressuring the government to act.
- the movement fueled strong opposition to foreign interference, particularly Japan’s retention of Chinese territories under the Treaty of Versailles.
- linked to the New Culture Movement, it challenged traditional Confucian values and promoted modernization, democracy, and scientific thinking
- It stirred up debates and problems without creating lasting solutions or a new culture for everyone. China was still ruled by warlords and a government that remained unaffected by the changes and who held the keys to power.
- it brought together diverse groups under a shared agenda of strengthening collective resistance against foreign dominance and domestic corruption
may 4th movement- political implications
- set the stage for formation of nationalist organizations including the GMD and other political groups that sought to unify china and resist foreign imperialism
- laid ideological groundwork for CCP rise and later struggle against warlords and imperialism
- widespread unrest led radical thinkers to turn toward revolutionary theory, seeking to justify resistance against foreign domination
- The working class, student masses, and national bourgeoisie united in anti-Western and anti-Japanese demonstrations, challenging the legitimacy of the republican government.
- The working class, student masses, and national bourgeoisie united in anti-Western and anti-Japanese sentiment.
- Doubts about the republican government’s ability to represent Chinese interests grew.
- While the government managed to contain the immediate unrest, it could not quell the growing doubts about its ability to represent Chinese interests.
- This environment provided an opportunity for radicals to disseminate their propaganda and further invigorate nationalist sentiments.
3 principles of the people
- People’s National Consciousness (nationalism)
emphasizes the importance of national unity and independence, calling for the end of foreign domination and the assertion of China’s sovereignty. - People’s Rights (Democracy)
advocates for democratic governance, promoting the idea that the government should be accountable to the people. It encouraged the establishment of a political system that represents the will of the populace - People’s livelihood (Socialism)
focuses on the economic well-being of the citizens, advocating for social reforms that address inequalities and improve living conditions - the principles increased momentum of the party and gave it moral purpose
- emphasis on improving conditions not individuals, ending foreign dominance and reasserting Chinese independence
Whampoa military academy
- power base of army
- whampoa military academy under Jiang in the early 1920s which helped to create network of supporters and the officer corps
- The KMT received money, materiel, and advisors from the Soviet Union; military advisors provided training and began reorganizing the KMT’s forces along Soviet lines.
- blue shirts were headed by whampoa cadets
- instilled sense of nationalism and loyalty to the republic among its students
emphasized the need for unity and resistance against foreign imperialism which fostered collective national identity - served as political and military stronghold for the GMD
- developed disciplined and ideologically aligned military force that play role in unifying china and combatting warlords
may 4th movement impact- CCP
- significant in the establishment of the CCP as several of its founding members had been involved in the May Fourth demonstrations.
- Two Chinese professors, Chen Duxiu and Li Dazhao were the leading members of the party.
- Chen Duxiu became the first leader of the CCP and he supported the Comintern’s ideas for the party, believing that the CCP should align with international communist movements.
- Li Dazhao, more independent in his thinking. He was more of a nationalist communist who wanted to adapt Marxist ideas to the reality of conditions in China, he thus had different solutions to China’s problems to those of the Comintern
- concerned with the immediate needs of the Chinese people and advocated for a combination of nationalism and socialism, believed in a more tailored approach to revolution, taking into account China’s specific social and economic conditions
21 demands
- In 1915 japanese government presented Yuan Shikai with 21 demands which would have completely destroyed chinese independence
- Japan joined the war first and was taken more seriously in comparison to chinese as they joined later in 1917, also war in europe meant increased ability to interfere in china
- Chinese appealed to USA but received little help, instead USA recognized Japanese superiority and believed they were entitled
- Yuan wanted to maintain positive relations with the west and therefore accepted the demands
- Yuan surrender created resentment, led to demonstrations and stikes across Beijing, resentment directed at both Japan and Yuan himself
- Students, traders, lawyers, teachers and even local officials in open defiance
- Appeal to Japan led to Yuan’s further weakened position as president and damaged his reputation
- The appeal to Japan further weakened Yuan’s position as president and damaged his reputation, perceived as a “betrayal of national interests” that prioritized his consolidation of power over Chinese sovereignty.
- The acceptance of the demands fueled anti-Yuan sentiment and nationalist resentment against foreign intervention.
- contributed to political fragmentation in China, leading to the rise of warlord factions and a further weakening of central authority.
- events surrounding the 21 Demands inspired future political movements, including the May Fourth Movement in 1919, which emphasized anti-imperialism and cultural reform.
shanghai massacre- impact on GMD
- jiang openly implemented his 2nd goal of the northern expedition of purging CCP
- increasingly concerned with growing strength of the CCP2
- 50,000 members by 1927
- not only did CCP pose threat to position but was also scaring middle class GMD supporters due to strikes in cities
- jiang regarded first united front as completed by 1928 however it could be argued that not all warlords were crushed, simply came to terms with them
- Jiang abcked by Shanghai industrialists and merchant who were eager to crush the trade unions and by those living in the international settlements due to their fear of anti foreigner demonstrations
- Used information passed to them by city’s triads and underworld gangsters they dragged 5000 communist and their sympathisers for execution by shooting or beheading
- On 19th May 1927 warlord troops massacred union members and communists in Changsha and began attacks on peasant associations throughout the rest of Hunan.
- launched encirclement campaigns
shanghai massacre- impact on CCP
- On 19th May 1927 warlord troops massacred union members and communists in Changsha and began attacks on peasant associations throughout the rest of Hunan.
- This led to the collapse in CCP membership in Hunan from 20,000 to 5,000.
- However, the Comintern told the CCP to ignore these attacks and maintain the United Front.
- In June the CCP was ordered to set up an army of 50,000 workers led by 20,000 communists.
- The CCP’s attempt to gain power between 1926 and 1927 had been a disaster.
- The CCP was not strong enough at this time, it had launched its bid for power too early and the had been crushed by the ‘right wing’ of the GMD.
- In addition, the National communist bloc had been weakened.
- The CCP was in a total state of disorder.
- The leaders that had survived Jiang’s assault had been forced underground.
- The CCP’s working relationship with the ‘left wing’ of the GMD also ended as Stalin’s policy was for communist parties internationally to destroy socialists in their countries.
- This policy further undermined the CCP and strengthened Jiang’s hand against them.
- after failure of Autumn harvest uprising led to establishment of the Jiangxi soviet where area could not be reached by the warlords or Jiang’s forces
encirclement campaigns
- 5 encirclement campaigns on communist base increasingly intense from 1930-34
- led to taking reduge in Jiangxi as orthodox communists gradually imposed control
- first 4 campaigns ended in failure for the GMD due to use of guerilla forces by Mao
- The GMD forces outnumbered the CCP considerably, with 100,000 troops deployed in the first campaign and then 200,00 and 300,000 in the second and third campaigns respectively.
- Mao used guerilla tactics to draw out GMD groups deeper into countryside, then detach forces to ambush them and suprise attack
- 5th encirclement campaign:
- Chiang benefitted by using tactics suggests by General Hans von seeckt, german military advisor
- Used blockhouse tactics of advancing slowly, digging trenches and putting up barbed wire
- ended in disaster for the CCP, positional conventional warfare played into strengths of GMD with 800,000 troops
- Communists had to abandon guerilla warfare and by summer were surrounded by 4 lines of blockhouses and close to starvation
- Lost ½ of territory and 60,000 troops
- led to long march to flee
jiangxi Soviet- land redistribution
- believed in self sufficient economy involving low taxation
- red army was to support peasants, live frugally and not exploit resources
- moderate land reform program, removal of bad landlords, if cooperated they would retain some land for themselves
- wealthy middle class peasants left alone
- led to widespread peasant support, both poor benefitted and wealthier peasants not alienated
- The CCP focused on mobilizing peasants to participate in the revolution. This included encouraging them to support the party’s policies and work together in collective efforts.
jiangxi soviet- orthodox vs nationalist communists
Orthodox communists;
- Supported policies of the comintern
- Revolution should be based on the urban proletariat in the cities
- Accepted leadership of chinese communists trained in moscow or non chinese agents from moscow
- Accepted policies dictated by comintern
National communists:
- Believed conditions in china were very different from pre-revolutionary russia
- Believed that revolution should be based on the peasants
- Promoted policies that addressed the specific situation in china
- Li lisan vs Mao
- li wanted to pursue soviet model for revolution, belief in urban cities for more power for it military forces
- Li Lisan was moscow trained marxist as was main opposition to urban vs peasantry, Li criticized Mao for ignoring Comintern instructions and acting independently
- Mao rejected assertion that stressed that Marxist theory had to be interpreted in the light of the actual conditions in china
- Dismissed that genuine revolution could only be achieved by industrial workers
- Rural peasants made up of 88% of china population of 500 million
- Peasant revolution would be sufficient to fulfill the demands of the dialectic
- Therefore did not need to wait for industrial growth
- Proletariat redefined as any who suffered oppression at hands of class enemies
- However Mao emerged victorious due to
Field research on peasantry gave him unrivalled knowledge on chinese peasantry which meant he dominated any discussion of party’s peasant policy - Intense self belief and determination allowed him to silence opposition
- Indispensable military planner
- Mao wanted a popular democratic style of government, consult people based on what the people wanted then draft policy based on this