Chapter 21- Voluntary Statements Under 14th Amd Flashcards
What are the two types of incriminating statements?
- The spoke admission
- Adoptive Admission
What is a spoke admission?
The most frequent type of incriminating statement
What must be proven to justify the use of an adoptive admission?
- The suspect heard and understood the statement
- Had an opportunity to respond
- Context was one in which he would be expected to respond
Is the following scenario a good example of an adoptive admission? A girl calls the suspect and says ‘you killed my sister you can run but can’t hide,’ and the suspect hung up without saying a word.
Good
What does it indicate if a suspect never denied texts to a victim about sexual abuse?
It can be considered an adoptive admission
What are the three principles governing police interactions?
- Voluntary statements
- Warnings during custodial interrogation
- No interference with the attorney-client relationship
What is a key consideration in determining if an interaction was coercive?
The characteristics of the suspect
Fill in the blank: The law governing police interactions stems from three principles: voluntary statements, warnings during custodial interrogation, and _______.
no interference with the attorney-client relationship
True or False: An adoptive admission can occur if the suspect does not verbally respond to a statement.
True
What is the primary focus of interrogation issues?
Voluntary considerations
What is required for Miranda rights to apply?
State action must occur involving custodial interrogation to obtain testimonial evidence
Miranda rights are protections afforded to individuals during police interrogations.
What does Miranda rights not cover?
Private individuals
Miranda rights are specifically applicable to actions taken by the state.
What two conditions must be met for Miranda rights to be relevant?
- The accused is in a custodial situation
- Interrogation occurs
Custodial situations typically involve detention or arrest.
What additional considerations must be addressed if the conditions for Miranda rights are met?
- Were rights administered properly
- Were rights waived or invoked
Proper administration of rights is crucial to ensure they are respected.
What is Article 12 concerning?
Right to counsel
When does the article 12 right to counsel apply
When accused is indicted or arraigned and being questioning on pending case without a waiver or lawyer present
What must occur for police to question an accused without a lawyer present?
There must be no waiver of rights
What does the 14th Amendment require regarding voluntary statements?
Statements must be rational and not coerced
What is a rational speaker defined as?
A speaker who is not suffering from severe mental illness, intoxication, injury, or other impairing conditions
True or False: A suspect high on PCP making irrational statements should be interviewed.
False
What two considerations determine lack of coercion?
- How did police behave
- What are the characteristics of the suspect
Fill in the blank: The totality of the circumstances is used to assess _______.
Lack of coercion
What is an example of physical coercion in police behavior?
Suspect beaten was coercion
This highlights the use of physical force to extract information or confessions.
What is the legal standing of forcing a suspect to lie naked and handcuffed while questioned?
No good
This indicates that such treatment is considered unacceptable and may invalidate a confession.
What constitutes an unacceptable threat in police questioning?
Telling a person his daughter would be raised by strangers
This type of threat is seen as coercive and can lead to the exclusion of any obtained confession.
What is an example of a legally acceptable coercive statement during police questioning?
You’re not doing yourself any good lying to us
This implies that the police are encouraging honesty without direct threats.
In a scenario where a gun is found in a car, what is a good practice by the police regarding arrests?
Didn’t arrest girlfriend to get a response
This suggests that not coercing or threatening another party can lead to more reliable confessions.
Bringing diabetic person to hosptial and figure out they’re okay and start questioning them, good or bad
Good
Telling someone they won’t receive medical attention if they don’t answer questions first
No good
Telling someone if they speak with you you will try to get them help
Good
After rights waiver police walk a person by suspect and say they implicated him although it was a lie
Good