Chapter 13- Obtaining search warrants Flashcards
Who must issue a search warrant?
A neutral magistrate
The magistrate must be neutral and detached.
What can a search warrant authorize?
To search anywhere in the commonwealth
This indicates the broad jurisdiction of the warrant.
What is required for an officer to submit an affidavit?
The officer must personally appear
Communication by phone or fax is rare and only if all options are exhausted.
On what basis is the decision for probable cause (PC) made?
Based on only written facts ‘within the four corners’
This means the affidavit must contain all necessary information without external references.
How should marginal cases be resolved?
In favor of the police
This suggests a bias towards law enforcement in ambiguous situations.
What can be done if the first affidavit does not establish probable cause?
Submit additional information
This allows for resubmission to satisfy the probable cause requirement.
Is it necessary to disclose all steps of an investigation when establishing probable cause?
No, only the steps necessary to establish probable cause need to be disclosed.
Investigators do not have to reveal steps that do not yield useful information.
What must be done if exculpatory evidence is obtained after a warrant is issued?
You must re-apply for the warrant with that information.
Exculpatory evidence refers to evidence that may be favorable to the defendant.
Does a clerical error nullify a warrant?
No, a clerical error does not nullify a warrant as it does not impact the underlying information.
An example of a clerical error could be a typo in the warrant.
What was the outcome of the case where the judge failed to sign the warrant?
The failure to sign the warrant was deemed a good error since the judge intended to sign it.
This indicates that the intention behind the action matters in legal contexts.
What is the time frame for returning a warrant to court after it is issued?
The warrant must be returned to court within three days of being returned to the judge or clerk.
This ensures timely processing of legal documents.
What happens to the affidavit and warrant when returned by the police?
They become public documents.
However, a prosecutor can petition for it not to be made public.
What must an affidavit explain regarding the evidence and the place to be searched?
It must explain why evidence is probably located at the place to be searched.
This explanation can be based on circumstantial evidence and reasonable inferences.
Fill in the blank: An affidavit must explain why evidence is probably located at the place to be _______.
[searched].
This is crucial for establishing probable cause.
True or False: The nature of the crime can be a basis for establishing probable cause in an affidavit.
True.
The type of crime can provide context for the likelihood of evidence being found at a specific location.
What are some factors that can be included in an affidavit to establish probable cause?
- Type of crime
- Nature of the item
- Suspect’s opportunity to conceal
- Normal inferences
These factors help justify the need for a search warrant.
What is the legal significance of finding stolen credit cards at a suspect’s house?
It supports probable cause to search for related items
The presence of stolen credit cards can indicate involvement in criminal activity, justifying further investigation.
In the case of a husband and wife where the husband poisoned the wife, what justified the search of the computer?
The probable cause existed due to the husband’s fake acceptance to Harvard and subsequent firing
This establishes a motive and potential evidence of premeditation.
What can a police officer infer when they find ‘useful items’ in a house?
That those items are likely to remain in the house
Useful items are less likely to be disposed of, aiding in establishing probable cause.
What items might be considered ‘useful’ when establishing probable cause?
- Knives
- Sneakers
- Clothing
- Facemasks
These items could be relevant in investigations related to various crimes.
What is the significance of multiple sales in establishing probable cause for a residence?
Multiple sales are needed to establish probable cause for searching a residence
This is based on the legal standard that requires more than a single instance of drug dealing to justify a search warrant.
What can police infer from a suspect leaving their house twice to sell drugs?
It is considered good evidence for establishing probable cause for a search warrant at the house
The repeated behavior suggests a pattern that may indicate the house is used for drug-related activities.
What is a ‘stash house’ in the context of drug dealing?
A stash house is where a dealer meets drug runners, without any personal belongings or residency indicators
Characteristics include no mail, no registration, and trash containing drug packaging.
What does staleness refer to in legal terms regarding search warrants?
Staleness refers to the requirement that information must be recent enough to show that evidence is still present at the location
If the information is outdated, it may not support a search warrant.
True or False: A single observation of a defendant selling drugs is sufficient for probable cause to search their residence.
False
Multiple observations or sales are needed to establish a pattern indicating drug activity at a residence.
Fill in the blank: Police may present evidence of a _______ to support a case against a drug dealer.
stash house
Evidence can include the absence of personal items and presence of drug-related trash.
What is required to support a search warrant at a house based on drug sales?
Evidence of multiple drug sales or consistent behavior indicating drug activity
This can include the suspect arriving in a vehicle for each sale.
What determines whether information is considered stale?
The facts of each case
Staleness is determined by various factors surrounding the crime and circumstances.
What are the variables to consider when assessing staleness?
- Character of the crime
- The criminal
- Things to be seized
- Place to be searched
- Durable vs Disposable items
Each variable can influence the likelihood of evidence being present at the time of search.
True or False: A stolen item is likely to be present five months later if it is durable.
True
Durable items, like stolen coins, are less likely to be easily transferred and thus more likely to be found after some time.