Chapter 2: Strategy and Tactics of distributive bargaining Flashcards
Why do negotiators need to be familiar with distributive bargaining? (List 3)
- Interdependent situations may be distributive
e.g. At Wedding Banquet, the banquet manager gives you problems by wanting to charge extra for wine. This was not previously agreed upon. You may have to be distributive - Need to know how to counter the effects of the distributive bargaining strategies
- Distributive bargaining skills are needed at the “claiming-value” stage
Explain context of a distributive bargaining situation
(List 3)
- Goals of one party is in fundamental, direct conflict to another party
- Resources are fixed and limited
- Maximizing one’s own share of resources is the goal for both parties
The distributive bargaining situation:
What kind of points do you need to know? (know 3 things)
- Target point
- Reservation price (RP) or Resistance point
- Asking price
(EXAMPLE)
* Sofia: the seller of condominium
Asking price = 145k
- Barry: the buyer
Reservation price (highest price Barry will pay) = 150k Target price = 135k - What is Sofia’s Reservation price (lowest price Sofia will sell at)?
Barry believes it is = 130k
So his opening offer price should be….?
What you need to know about reservation price? (list 3)
- Parties will never know each other RP
- Do not share RP with opposite party
- Spread between RP known as (Zone of Potential Agreement)
Positive ZOPA vs Negative ZOPA
Positive ZOPA:
- you can see it as buyer RP (highest price willingness to buy) > Seller RP (lowest price willingness to sell) –> therefore deal
Negative ZOPA:
- you can see it as buyer RP (highest price willingness to buy) < Seller RP (lowest price willingness to sell) –> therefore no deal
What role do alternatives play in a negotiated agreement
- Alternatives give the negotiator power to walk away from the negotiation
- If alternatives are attractive, negotiators can Set their goals higher
- Make fewer concessions
- If there are no attractive alternatives: Negotiators have much less bargaining power
What is BATNA and WATNA? Need to look at other factors too
Best alternative to a negotiated agreement
Worst alternative to a negotiated agreement
Barry’s BATNA: alternative 142k condo elsewhere
Other factors
What if Sofia offers at 143k?
Buyer Target price < 143k < Buyer RP
Distance to work
Condition of apartment
Sofia’s BATNA: another buyer offering 134k
Other factors
What if Barry offers at 133k? Seller Target price > 133k > Seller RP Is new buyer serious? Lead time?
When will Barry need apartment?
Delay too long, you lose both
What are keys to distributive bargaining
*Discovering the other party’s Reservation Price
*Influencing the other party’s Reservation Price
What are the propositions that suggest how the keys affect the process*** (list 4)
- The higher the other party’s estimate of (your) cost of delay or impasse, the stronger the other party’s resistance point will be.
* (If you have time pressures or cannot delay, they have the advantage) - The higher the other party’s estimate of his or her (own) cost of delay or impasse, the weaker the other party’s resistance point will be.
* (If time is not an issue, you have the upper hand) - The less the other party values an issue, the lower their resistance point will be.
If the issue is unimportant to them, RP goes down - The more the other party believes that you value an issue, the lower their resistance point may be.
If other party knows you value an item, they will moderate RP
REALLY?
Is this applicable in an Asian context?
What are some of the tactical tasks of negotiators
(4 step process)
- Assess outcome values and the costs of termination for the other party
- Manage the other party’s impressions
- Modify the other party’s perceptions
- Manipulate the actual costs of delay or termination
How should you manage the other party’s impressions
- Screen your behavious
- dont say much to not give away anything
- known as calculated incompetence: limit information released - Direct actions to alter impressions
- selective presentation: present facts that may enhance one’s position or manage impression of RP
- “If you were in my shoes”
How can you modify the other party’s perceptions (list 4)
- Make outcomes appear less attractive
- Make the cost of obtaining goals appear higher
- Make demands and positions appear more or less attractive to the other party – whichever suits your needs
- Conceal vital information
Positions you can take during negotiations
Considerations:
* Opening offer
Where will you start?
* Opening stance
What is your attitude?
Competitive? Moderate?
* Initial concessions
Should any be made? If so, how large?
Understanding the role of concessions
- without them, either capitulation or deadlock
Patterns of concession making
- pattern contains valuable information
showing your final offer
-“that is all i can do”
Why are concessions important?
- Vital
- In reality, we have wishlist (for what we want); and concessions
list (what we can give away) - Shows that you are serious about deal – reciprocity
- You cannot:
Make concession that is of perceptually lower value
Not make a concession after other party has done so
Make additional/exaggerated concessions if other party has not done so – does not show credibility - How you frame the giving of concessions is important
How should you close the deal (list 5)
(PASED)
- Provide alternatives (2 or 3 packages)
Give opposite side opportunity to present to upper
management - Assume the close
Taking liberties to influence in a slightly assertive manner - Split the difference
- Exploding offers Usually with deadline
- Deal sweeteners