Chapter 2: Police Psychology Flashcards
police selection procedures
a set of procedures used by the police to either screen out undesirable candidates or select desirable candidates
history of police selection
Psychologists have been involved in police selection since the early 20th century
Lewis Terman
used the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Test to assist with police selection in California in 1917. He tested 30 police and firefighter applicants and recommended a minimum IQ score of 80 for future applicants
police selection in the 1950s
By the mid-1950s, the psychological screening procedure of police applicants became part of the standard process
common U.S. police selection procedures today (in order of prevalence)
- background checks
- medical exams
- seleciton interviews
- personality tests
- drug tests
- physical agility tests
- polygraph tests
- recommendation letters
- cognitive ability tests
stages of developing police selection instruments
job analysis & construction and validation
job analysis
- A procedure for identifying knowledge, skills, and abilities (KSAs) that make a good police officer
- This can be done using a range of techniques
problems with job analyses
- The KSAs of a good police officer may not be stable over time, which makes it difficult to determine what the selection procedures could actually be testing
- Different types of police officers will be characterized by different KSAs
- Individuals may disagree over which KSAs are important (ex. police constables rank humour highly when asked about important police qualities, but senior officers do not rank humour highly)
predictive validity
the extent to which scores on a test (ex. Cognitive ability test) predicts scores on some other measure (ex. Supervisor ratings of police performance)
how can you determine a selection instrument’s predictive validity?
using a correlation coefficient
interpreting correlation coefficients
Correlation coefficients indicate the strength and direction of the relationship between the scores on the selection instrument and the ratings of job performance
problems with the validation stage
- Different trends can emerge based on what measure of performance is used
- Ratings by different individuals can contradict each other
selection interview
an interview used by the police to determine the extent to which an applicant possesses the knowledge, skills, and abilities deemed important for the job
format of police selection interviews
The interviewer has a preset list of questions that are asked of each applicant, ensuring a more objective basis for comparison
interviews and job performance
Research suggests that interviews can sometimes predict job performance but not always
Annell et al., 2015 interviews and job performance study
studied how well three types of interviews predicted performance, satisfaction, occupational retention, and health across three different settings and found that the largest coefficient was 0.10 (not very significant)
what types of interviews are more likely to predict future job performance?
structured interviews
psychological tests
- Some tests measure cognitive abilities while others measure personality
- Some tests are specific to police selection, but others are more broad
cognitive ability tests
procedures for measuring verbal, mathematical, memory, and reasoning skills
example of a cognitive ability test
the RCMP Police Aptitude Test
RCMP Police Aptitude Test
consists of multiple-choice questions designed to evaluate an applicant’s aptitude for police work
cognitive ability tests and job performance
- Cognitive ability tests for police selection tend to be better at predicting performance during police academy training compared to future on-the-job performance
- This may be because personality variables play a larger role in determining job success