Chapter 1 Flashcards
what are the importances of definitions (5 things)
- core of our knowledge
- help us understand what to observe in order to begin observational research
- cannot be too narrow (you’ll miss info) or too broad (you’ll include irrelevant info) (ie. observing “couples” = too broad)
- may carry legitimacy and social status (ex. “parent” = legit. status b/c it’s regarded as normative)
- have an ideological component (ie. defining same-sex couples as “families” can be controversial as not everyone agrees with it)
2 theories of definitions
- Aristotle’s theory
2. The “Equivalence of Meaning” strategy
Aristotle’s theory re: definitions
- establishing the meaning of a word by 2 components: genus and species
- genus: what other things share similar properties
- species: what differentiates this thing from other things in its genus
- example: family -> genus = social group; species = membership achieved through the sexual bond of same-generation adults and biological offspring
“Equivalence of Meaning” strategy re: definitions
- definitions consist of a term to be defined followed by several words that do the defining
- adequacy tested by the ability of the phrase to replace the word in a sentence w/o damaging meaning
- example: family - equivalent to “a social group containing sexually bonded adults and biological offspring”
restrictive definitions
- very specific (ie. defining family as “sexually bonded adults and biological offspring)
- can be problematic (ie. “sexually bonded” excludes single-parent families; “biological offspring” excludes gay and lesbian families, adoptive families, and foster families)
4 important contexts for definitions used to study the family
- legal definitions
- normative definitions
- theoretical definitions
- research definitions
legal definitions
- context enforceable by legislated laws, used in courts
- about custody, maintenance, common law relationships, and cohabitation
- each province and territory has own legislation
- sometimes out of sync with social norms
normative definitions
- context is social norms in a society
- shared by majority of people in a country/region
- regarded as socially legitimate and approved
- ex. although many Canadians would view 2 married opposite sex parents and their biological kids as the central definition of family, unmarried parents, same-sex parents, adopted kids, single parents etc. are all normative definitions of Canadian families
theoretical definitions
- uses concepts and propositions of a social science theory
- aren’t “correct/incorrect”; only consistent with the concepts and propositions in the theory
- 2 types: rational choice theory and life course theory
concepts
- the starting point for theories
- an abstract set of ideas collected under one idea
- ex. “marriage” contains “having a publicly recognized sexual bond between 2 people”
propositions
- the backbone of a theory
- any statement that relates one concept to another concept
conceptual analysis/research hypothesis
- a statement that can have a truth value (true or false)
- a statement about how one concept is related to another
- research hypothesis = aka conceptual hypothesis (ie. “marital conflict is negatively related to academic performance” is both a research hypothesis and a conceptual hypothesis)
what does being defined as having a family carry with it?
- carries a status of normalcy
- isn’t formally defined, but there’s a common understanding of what’s normally meant
- uses normative biases (ex. assumption that families don’t usually have multiple wives/husbands)
what are the 5 ways in which families are changing nowadays?
- fewer married-couple families
- same-sex couples are increasing at faster ways than opposite-sex couples
- single-person households are increasing
- more 20-29 year olds live with their parents
- unmarried people outnumber married people (for the first time in Canadian history)
rational choice theory
- assumes everyone makes choices to maximize their profit
- would define family as a social group that over time optimizes the profit for each of its members
life course theory
- norms and expectations that exist throughout the life cycle create age-specific roles
- ex. a mother with a newborn’s role is to breastfeed it, but a mother with a teenager no longer has that role
- would define family as a temporal and normatively organized social group responsible for the nurturance and care of children
research definitions
- derived from a theory, social problem, or a hunch
- must be clearly stated and measurable
- must be measurable/operationalized in a way so that the dependent variable isn’t used in the measure of any other variables included in the research (independent)
- ex. marital equality can’t be measured in the same way you’d measure marital stability -> they would overlap and you would get a false result
steps in the research process
- research question
- conceptual research hypothesis and measurement hypothesis
- research definitions of concepts and relations
- identifying measures (operationalization)
- research design for measurement hypothesis
research question
- can be derived from a theory, social problem, gap in existing data, etc.
- because it’s a question, it can’t be proven true or false, which is why we need a declarative statement (or hypothesis)
measurement hypothesis
- a statement about how one set of measures (independent variable) is related to another (dependent variable)
- ex. if our conceptual hypothesis is that marital conflict is negatively related to academic performance, our measurement hypothesis could be the number of parental arguments per week and school grades
research definitions of concepts and relations
- define the relationship between the concepts
- ex. are you suggesting that there’s a positive or negative relation between the 2 concepts?
identifying measures (operationalization)
- making sure that each variable operates independently and isn’t linked to another variable
- ex. if your definition of academic performance includes access to technology, then that would actually be influenced by another variable; the wealth of the family
dynamics/life course analysis and its importance
- studies changes, transitions, and flows of people over time
- important because most data only captures one point in time w/o looking at transitions; most of our info is limited by the point in time we live in
definition of family from a dynamic/life course perspective
“an INTERGENERATIONAL social group organized and governed by social norms regarding descent, affinity, reproduction, and the SOCIALIZATION OF YOUNG”