Attachements 1 Flashcards
When is infancy
First year or two of a child’s life, before speech begins
What type of communication establishes an infant caregiver relationship in infancy
Non-verbal
What are the two main types of caregiver-infant interactions
1) Reciprocity
2) Interactional Synchrony
What are alert phases
Signals from an infant that they are ready for interaction
How often do mothers respond to infant alert phases
2/3 of the time, Feldman and Eidelman (2007)
What is reciprocity
When each person responds to the other
Brazelton et al
- Infants take turns in ‘communication’ with their caregiver
- Important precursor to later communication
- suggested that sensitivity to infant behaviour lays foundation for later attachment
Interactional Synchrony
When both people carry out the same action simultaneously, reflecting what the other is doing
Meltzoff and Moore procedure
- Adult model
- Making facial expressions and gestures to an infant
- Recorded reactions of babies on video
- Observers see video (only infant can be seen) and note down in four behavioural categories
1) Mouth opening
2) Termination of mouth opening
3) Tongue protrusion
4) Termination of tongue protrusion - Inter/Intra observer reliability was greater than 0.92
Meltzoff and Moore findings
- Imitation was seen in infants as young as 2-3 weeks old
- Even in 3 day old infants, so interactional synchrony is likely innate
Murray and Trevarthen
- 2 month olds interacted via video monitor in real time with mother
- Video monitor displays a tape of their mother so responses are not synchronised
- Infants showed acute distress
- Were actively seeking a response from their caregiver
- Supports Meltzoff and Moore
Reciprocity and Interactional Synchrony Evaluation
+ Supporting studies
+ Abravenal and DeYoung to test if behaviour was merely imitation showed an object that simulated
tongue movement and mouth opening and closing movements. Infants made little response, so it is only directed at humans.
+ Valuable research, allows us to theorise how relationships are formed and thus how to conduct them
- Hard to reliably test infant behaviour (in constant motion)
- Failure to replicate Meltzoff and Moores findings (Koepke et al)
- Hard to tell if the behaviour is intentional or imitative (link to Abravenal and DeYoung)
- Individual differences between infants can play a role, there is more imitation with a stronger attachment
Schaffer and Emmerson procedure
- 60 babies
- 5-23 weeks of age
- Visited in their homes every 4 weeks for a year, then once more at 18 months
- Mix of observation and interview
- Report the infant response to different everyday situations:
1) Left alone in a room
2) Left with other people
3) Left in pram outside house
4) Left in pram outside shops
5) Put down after another adults holds them
6) Passed by while sitting on the cot/chair - Describe protest intensity on a scale of 1-4
- Therefore separation anxiety and stranger anxiety can be measured
Schaffer and Emmerson findings
- 65% had mother as primary attachment
- 30% had joint attachment to mother and some other figure
- 3% had father as primary attachment
- 27% were jointly attached to mother and father
- At 18 months, 75% had an attachment to their father
- More attached infants had mothers who responded quickly to their signals and interacted the most
- 40% of cases, primary carer was not primary attachment
Schaffer and Emmerson stages of development in attachments
1) Pre-Attachment phase: From 0-6 weeks babies act similarly to humans and inanimate objects. From six weeks to 3 months, infants prefer humans (smiling at faces). They prefer familiar to unfamiliar faces.
2) Indiscriminate Attachments: 3-7 months: Start to recognise familiar adults, accept comfort from any adult, doesn’t show too much preference.
3) Discriminate Attachments: 7-8 months: Showing more protest when one specific person puts them down, and show joy at reunion with them. Stranger anxiety forms at this stage
4) Multiple Attachments: 9+ months: Multiple attachments are formed depending on the amount of relationships the baby has. 30% of infants formed more attachments within 1 month of the first. Within 6 months, this was 78%
Primary and Secondary attachments importance
- Not much agreement on importace
- Bowllby suggests it is hierarchal, Rutter suggests they are all of equal importance and cover different aspects of the child’s life
Schaffer and Emmerson evaluation
+ Good external validity: carried out in the families’ own homes. Demand characteristics are less likely.
+ Mundane realism
+ Longitudinal design: the same babies were observed over time, so higher internal validity and less confounding variables
- Mothers can show social desirability bias (pretending they are better than they are)
- Biased sample of working class population, may not apply to middle-class. Also from the 1960s, and childcare has changed a lot since
- More fathers choose the stay at home to care for children now
- Hard to tell difference between attachment and playmate, babies still show distress if a playmate leaves the room
- The stage theory is inflexible, and may not apply to other cultures
How was attachment to the father determined (Schaffer and Emmerson)
Separation protest, which was seen in 75% of babies after 18 months
Grossman et al procedure
- Longitudinal study of babies till they were teens
- Assess attachment to both parents
Grossman et al findings
- Quality of attachment to father was not as important in adolescent attachments
- Quality of play with father was more important in adolescent attachments
When do most babies form a primary attachment by
7 months
Field (1978)
Primary caregiver fathers spent more time smiling, imitating, and holding their babies than secondary caregiver fathers, so men can be a primary attachment too
Role of father evaluation
+ Mothers may be pressured to stay home
+ Fathers may feel the need to focus on work over parenting
- MacCallum and Golombok found that children reared by single mothers do not develop any differently
- Hormones such as Oestrogen might be why women want to be more nurturing and this become the primary attachment
Imprinting
Baby animal/human attaches to first living thing seen after birth